• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Individual Character Poll: (Poll Extravaganza BOOM BOOM! Top 10 Most Voted!)

Joined
Apr 19, 2015
Messages
10,596
Indifferent to Agumon, strong NO to Jumpman (no offence, but he is probably the worst suggestion I've ever heard) and no to the rest.

Summary (Bold means strong like/dislike)
Yes: King K. Rool, Bandanna Dee, Wolf, Ridley, Black Mage, Gengar, Isaac, Dixie Kong, Bomberman, Captain Toad, Rayman, Chibi-Robo, Cranky Kong, Impa, Meowth

No: Geno, Young Link, Reckless Safety Man, Bayonetta, Ninten, Jumpman, Pichu, Lip, Balloon Fighter, Shovel Knight, Corrin, Sora, Shantae, Prince Sable, Cloud, Hawlucha, Daisy, Mr. Resetti, Ayumi Tachibana, Mike Jones, Shadow, Dark Samus, Anna, Dig Dug, Hades, Bubbles, Chorus Kids, Quote, Chun-Li, Spyro, Tingle, Style Savvy, Fiora, Professor Layton, Delphox, Captain Rainbow, Tails, Urban Champion, Hanafuda, Phoenix Wright, Karate Joe, Marshal, Rhythm Girl, Rhythm Wrestler, Lark, Sheriff, Barbara, Melia, Harry the Teleroboxer, Henry Fleming, Maxwell, Medusa, Donkey Kong Jr., Tetra, Masked Man, Nightmare, Andy, Monster Hunter, Skull Kid, Viridi, Callie & Marie, Dr. Wily, Elma, Sukapon, Tiki, Crono, Slippy, Frogger, Star Man, Wario Land Wario, Ganbare Goemon, Lana, Zael, Agnes Oblige, Dr. Kawashima, Baby Mario, Knuckles, Mallo, Jibanyan, Nintendog, Slime, Fossil Fighter, Haruka Amami, Ryu Hayabusa, Chrom, Toon Zelda, Donbe and Hikari, Lloyd Irving, Yoshimitsu, Amaterasu, Agent J, Heihachi, Lara Croft, Monita, Micaiah

Indifferent: Takamaru, Mach Rider, Paper Mario, Ice Climbers, Squirtle, Ivysaur, Excitebiker, Wonder Red, Krystal, Banjo-Kazooie, Midna, Sceptile, Starfy, Ray MK, Simon Belmont, Inkling, Ghirahim, Dr. Eggman, Classic Ganon, Porky, Waluigi, Snake, Zoroark, Dillon, Samurai Goroh, Sylux, Black Shadow, Agumon
 
Last edited:

SegaNintendoUbisoft

The Amateur Artist
Joined
Jan 26, 2014
Messages
7,301
Location
This thread
NNID
S.N.U0203
3DS FC
4725-8740-7336
Yes: Rayman, King K.Rool, Wolf, Isaac, Ice Climbers, Shantae, Dixie Kong, Wonder Red, Bomberman, Banjo & Kazooie, Captain Toad, Hades, Tingle, Cranky Kong, Dr. Eggman, Medusa, Snake, Viridi, Slippy, Knuckles

Indifferent: Bandanna Dee, Krystal, Lip, Mach Rider, Takamaru, Ridley, Paper Mario, Squirtle, Ivysaur, Prince of Sable, Excitebiker, Hawlucha, Muddy Mole, Mr. Resetti, Ayumi Tachibana, Mike Jones, Anna, Chibi Robo, Dig Dug, Chorus Kids, Bubbles, Quote, Ray MK, Starfy, Sceptile, Spyro, Professor Layton, Style Savvy, Captain Rainbow, Simon Belmont, Hanafuda, Impa, Meowth, Karate Joe, Marshal, Rhythm Girl, Rhythm Wrestler, Black Mage, Lark, Sheriff, Barbara, Classic Ganon, Porky, Harry, Henry Fleming, Maxwell, Waluigi, Masked Man, Tetra, Andy, Skull Kid, Callie and Marie, Dilon, Elma, Crono. Samurai Goroh, Starman, Ganbare, Lana, Sylux, Zael, Dr. Kawashima, Jibanyan, Mallo, Black Shadow, Fossil Fighter, Haruka, Ryu, Donbe and Hikari, Agent J, Monita

No: Young Link, Pichu, Shovel Knight, Bayonetta, Reckless Safety Man, Corrin, Sora, Cloud, Lyn, Daisy, Shadow, Dark Samus, Fiora, Delphox, Phoenix Wright, Melia, Donkey Kong Jr, Gengar, Nightmare, Zoroark, Monster Hunter, Dr. Wily, Sukapon, Tiki, Frogger, Wario Land Wario, Anges, Baby Mario, Nintendog (NO), Slime, Chrom, Lloyd, Toon Zelda, Yoshimitsu, Amaterasu, Agumon, Heihachi, Jumpman, Lara Croft, Micaiah
 

Troykv

Smash Master
Joined
Jan 24, 2015
Messages
3,990
Micaiah! You are the character that I want more in this game, in this franchice. You're my lovd one Micaiah, you have every Yes that I can give you.

Also: We don't really have so many FE characters that can be unique whatever they (the developers) made it. Micaiah can still give new things.

Everyone else indifferent.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jul 12, 2014
Messages
19,183
Location
An elevator
yes: Balloon Fighter, Bandana Dee, Takamaru, K rool, Ridley , Isaac, Corrin, Sora, Ice Climbers, Paper Mario, Ivysaur, Squirtle,Dixie Kong, Wonder Red, Lyn, banjo-kazooie, rayman, captain toad, Anna, Dark Samus,hades,Midna,Chun-li,spyro,Fiora, Tingle, Ghirahim, Inkiling, Tails,Phoenix Wright, Rhythm Wrestler, black mage, dr. Ivo robotnik,Ganon, Melia,Porky, Henry Fleming, Snake, Tetra, Masked Man, Zoroark, viridi, callie and marie, dillon, elma, Lana, Knuckles, Agnes Oblige, mallo, slime, chrom, toon zelda, Agent J, Amaterasu, Agumon

no: Pichu, Mach Rider, Shovel Knight, Lip, Bayonetta, "RSG", Shantae, Excite Biker, Cloud, Hawlucha, Muddy Mole,daisy,ayumi tachiabani, mr resetti, shadow, Dig Dug, quote, bubbles, Geno, Ninten, sceptile, Stlye Savvy, Urban Champion,Hanafuda,Impa,Meowth, Karate Joe, lark, sheriff, Barbara, Harry the teleroboxer, maxwell, Medusa, Gengar,DK jr, frogger, goroh, wario 2.0, starman, Sylux, Kawashima, baby Mario, nintendog, idolmaster chick, ryu hayabusa, black shadow, fossil fighter, yoshimitsu, donbe and hikari, Jumpman, Lara Croft

indifferent: Krystal, Wolf, Young Link, Prince Sable, Bomberman, mike jones, Chibi Robo, chorus kids,starfy, ray, Layton, Rhythm Girl, Marshall, Waluigi, Niightmare, andy, skull kid, monster hunter guy, dr wily, Zael, Goemon, jibanyan, lloyd, Heihachi, Monita, Micaiah

this has really made me realize how many characters I DON'T want even though i have said I want pretty much anyone in the past. I mean some of these choices are ridiculous but dang that is a big list of no.
 

murdokdracul

"What do you mean you support Yoshimitsu?!"
Joined
Jul 13, 2014
Messages
210
Location
Manchester, United Kingdom
NNID
murdokdracul
3DS FC
2836-0188-2561
Switch FC
SW-5151-9208-7814
... What are you doing?

Anyway, I'm indifferent to most of those. Agumon I love, and I'd actually be ecstatic if he did get in, but...eh. I'd never actively support a Digimon character for Smash. Micaiah I also love, along with all things Fire Emblem, but I'm satisfied with the representation the series already has. I think a franchise other than Mario, Fire Emblem and Pokémon (unless we're talking Squirtle and Ivysaur) would be more deserving.

Heihachi I wouldn't mind, but Yoshimitsu would be infinitely better. Monita isn't very interesting. Amaterasu would be cool, but I've never played Okami so I'm not going to push for her inclusion over characters I already know. I have absolutely no interest in Agent J. Lara Croft is one of the most iconic video game characters, but she doesn't fit in Smash.

strong NO to Jumpman (no offence, but he is probably the worst suggestion I've ever heard).
^ That.
 
Last edited:

~Krystal~

True American Heroine
Joined
Nov 6, 2007
Messages
3,124
Location
Texas
Ammy: Double yes all the way across the sky.
Agent J: No.
Agumon: Not my favorite Digimon, but yes.
Heihachi: Strong no.
Jumpman: No.
Lara Croft: Yes.
Monita: Indifferent.
Micaiah: Yes.
 

FunAtParties

PM me ur character ideas girl
Joined
May 21, 2015
Messages
3,880
Location
Illinois
NNID
ZestyÑ
Switch FC
SW-8404-4905-2993
No- Pretty much everyone. (I like Amaterasu, but the whole rep thing has me saying no. Everyone else just sucks.)
Yes- Monita (I'd be down)
Indifferent- Micaiah (I wanted her before, but I'm all Fire Emblemed out right now)
 

SleuthMechanism

Smash Ace
Joined
Sep 25, 2014
Messages
736
Location
The void
NNID
SleuthMechanism
3DS FC
4184-2631-5815
Switch FC
SW-7949-7248-8280
Amaterasu: No.
Agent J: indifferent. i cant give elite beat agents a hard no, i just can't..
Agumon: No. i really don't think Digimon has any place here.
Heihachi: No way.
Jumpman: ..wat. Hell no. why would anyone even.. im sorry, but this is probably one of the dumbest ideas i have ever heard
Lara Croft: Associated mosty with nintendo's competitors and a boring normal as hell human when you have so many characters with awesome powers to choose from? No way.
Micaiah: No
Monita: No It would honestly be insulting if this chaacter got in over others.

summary(bold for strong support/dislike)

Yes: Balloon Fighter, Banjo Kazooie, Bomberman, Ice Climbers, Ivysaur, King K.rool, Lip, Mach Rider, Reckless Safety Man, Ridley, Shantae, Squirtle, Wolf, Dark Samus, Dig Dug, Quote, Ray MK, Cranky Kong, Ghirahim, Inkling, Dr. Eggman, Rhythm Girl, Classic Ganon, Waluigi, Snake, Masked Man, Dr. Wily, Sukapon, Samurai Goroh, Warioland Wario, Knuckles, Skull Kid, Black Shadow

No: Ayumi, Bandana Dee, Bayonetta, Cloud, Corrin, Daisy, Dixie Kong, ExciteBiker, Krystal, Mr. Resetti, Muddy Mole, Pichu, Prince of Sable, Shovel Knight, Sora, Takamaru, Wonder Red, Young Link, Mike jones, Captain Toad, Rayman, Chorus Kids, bubbles, Sceptile, Starfy, Spyro, Delphox, Fiora, Layton, Style savvy, Tingle, Tails, Urban Champion, Lark, Sheriff, Karate Joe, Rhythm Wrestler, Impa, Marshal, Meowh, Hanafuda, Barbara, Melia, Porky, Harry, Henry Fleming, Maxwell, Donkey Kong Jr., Gengar, Tetra, Nightmare, Zoroark, Callie and Marie, Monster Hunter, Elma, Crono, Slippy, Tiki, Frogger, Lana, Goemon, Zael, Agnes, Baby Mario, Dr. Kawashima, Andy, Viridi, nintendog, mallo, Haruka Amami, Fossil Fighter, Chrom, Lioyd, Toon Zelda, Yoshimitsu, Amaterasu, Agumon, Heihachi, Jumpman, Lara, Monita, Micaiah

Indifferent: Isaac, Lyndis, Paper Mario, Shadow, Anna, Chibi Robo, Captain Rainbow, Simon Belmont, Black Mage, Phoenix Wright, Medusa, Dillon, Star Man, Sylux, Jibanyan, Slime, Ryu Hayabusa, Donbe & Hikari, Agent J
 
Last edited:

Mikegamer0608

Smash Lord
Joined
Jun 24, 2012
Messages
1,406
Location
Somewhere in the Cosmos.
NNID
Mikegamer0608
Yes: Bandana Dee, Issac, King K Rool, Krystal, Shantae, Sora, Takamaru, Wolf, Dixie Kong, Cloud Strife, Wonder Red, Bomberman, Banjo & Kazooie, Rayman, Chun-Li, Fiora, Professor Layton, Simon Belmont, Tails, Inklings, Phoenix Wright, Impa, Black Mage, Dr. Eggman, Melia, Snake, Tetra, Andy, Skull kid, Viridi, Elma, Crono, Lana, Knuckles, Black Shadow, Lloyd Irving, Toon Zelda

No: Bayonetta, Corrin, Ivysaur, Mach Rider, Pichu, Reckless Safety Man, Ridley, Squirtle, Hawlucha, Lyndis, Daisy, Mr. Resetti, Mike Jones, Dark Samus, Dig Dug, Hades, Chorus Kids, Bubbles, Ninten, Starfy, Sceptile, Tingle, Style Savvy, Delphox, Ghirahim, Urban Champion, Hanafuda, Meowth, Karate Joe, Marshal, Rhythm Girl, Rhythm Wrestler, Lark, Sheriff, Barbara, Harry the Teleroboxer, Henry Fleming, Donkey Kong. Jr, Nightmare, Zoroark, Monster Hunter, Dillon, Dr. Wily, Sukapon, Slippy, Tiki, Frogger, Starman (Pro Wrestling), (Wario Land) Wario, Sylux, Baby Mario, Dr. Kawashima, Nintendog, Slime, Fossil Fighter, Yoshimitsu, Agent J, Agumon, Jumpman, Lara Croft, Monita

Indifferent: Balloon Fighter, Ice Climbers, Lip, Paper Mario, Prince of Sable, Shovel Knight, Young Link, Excitebiker, Muddy Mole, Ayumi Tachibana, Captain Toad, Shadow, Chibi-Robo, Anna, Quote, Midna, Geno, Spyro, Ray MK, Captain Rainbow, Cranky Kong, Porky, Classic Ganon, Maxwell, Waluigi, Gengar, Medusa, Masked Man, Callie & Marie, Samurai Goroh, Ganbare Goemon, Zae, Agnes Oblige Jibanyan, Mallo, Ryu Hayabasa, Haruka Amami, Chrom, Donbe and Hikari, Amaterasu, Heihachi, Micaiah
 

Aetheri

W/E happens don't panic...
Joined
Jan 13, 2015
Messages
8,847
Location
ZDR
Switch FC
SW-3397-5428-2304
Oh look, more characters I can give NOs to...
Amaterasu - Indifferent - A wolf would be cool...a wolf with an imp, that attacks with her hair, riding on his back would be cooler though...Haven't played the Okami games though but I do hear good things...perhaps by then I will be more accepting of Amaterasu, until then I'm staying neutral...

Agent J - no - yeah...no thanks...

Agumon - no - Digimon was cool back in the day...'Was'...the whole Pokemon vs. Digimon thing has really lost it's flair now...and I doubt it would spark the same hype as Mario vs. Sonic did in Brawl...

Heihachi - Indifferent - Heihachi's cool...but there is another Tekken character I would much prefer....namu!

Jumpman - NO! - Seriously?...I mean seriously? Paper Mario actually makes sense as a third Mario, because he'd actually be unique but Jumpman?...

Lara Croft - yes - Arguably the most iconic female gaming character in history rivaled only by Nintendo's own Samus Aran...Tomb Raider's a bit of a juggernaut even outside of video games...But Seeing both Lara Croft and Samus Aran duking it out in the same game is actually quite a cool prospect...However if Snake is any indication, 'No realistic firearms allowed' in Smash and Lara's signature weapons are the dual pistols...although if they take que's from her newer appearances she may still have something to work with...I actually like her new iteration better as well, she seems more...'natural'...

Monita - No! - This one should be reserved for an assist trophy role...here's an idea, make Midna playable then add Monita as an Assist Trophy in her place....no?...what about Dark Samus?.....ok fine...

Micaiah - NO! - 'Twoo Many Repz' 'No MoAr Firez BEMblemZorZ' and stuff......but seriously Roy's great, awesome he's back, but now it's time for other franchises to get their share...mainly Metroid and Zelda...plz...

----

YES
Top Picks (Hard YES!)
-Midna!
-Dark Samus
-Ridley
-Impa
-Wolf
-Shantae
-Ganon
Would Like (Medium Yes!)
-Ice Climbers
-King K Rool
-Krystal
-Banjo & Kazooie
-Rayman
-Sceptile
-Ghirahim
-Inklings
-Tails
-Snake
-Zoroark
-Skull Kid
Like the Idea (Soft yes)
-Cloud Strife
-Mr. Resetti
-Hawlucha
-Bomberman
-Chun Li
-Delphox
-Meowth
-Black Mage
-Gengar
-Nightmare
-Tetra
-Elma
-Samurai Goroh
-Yoshimistu
-Lara Croft

INDIFFERENT
Simply Neutral
-Isaac
-Bandana Dee
-Balloon Fighter
-Mach Rider
-Takamaru
-Prince Sable
-Excitebiker
-Dixie Kong
-Wonder Red
-Muddy Mole
-Ayumi Tachibana
-Mike Jones
-Captain Toad
-Shadow
-Chibi Robo
-Dig Dug
-Ninten
-Ray MK
-Spyro
-Captain Rainbow
-Simon Belmont
-Urban Champion
-Hanafuda
-Marshall
-Karate Joe
-The Wrestler
-Rhythm Girl
-Dr. Eggman
-Lark
-Sheriff
-Barbara
-Porky
-Donkey Kong Jr.
-Medusa
-Masked Man
-Andy
-Monster Hunter
-Dillon
-Dr. Wily
-Frogger
-Starman (Pro Wrestling)
-Goemon
-Knuckles
-Mallo
-Fossil Fighter
-Haruka Amami
-Ryu Hayabasa
-Donbe and Hikari
-Lloyd Irving
-Amaterasu
-Heihachi

NO
Rather Not (Soft no)
-Bayonetta
-Shovel Knight
-Lip
-Bubbles
-Quote
-Starfy
-Fiora
-Cranky Kong
-Professor Layton
-Phoenix Wright
-Viridi
-Callie & marie
-Sylux
-Zael
-Agnes Oblige
-Toon Zelda
-Agent J
-Agumon
Don't Want (Medium No!)
-Paper Mario
-Pichu
-Squirtle
-Ivysaur
-Chorus Kids
-Melia
-Crono
-Sukapon
-Slippy
-Warioland Wario
-Dr. Kawashima
-Lana
-Chrom
-Monita
Absolutely NOT! (Hard NO!!)
-Reckless Safety Man
-Sora
-Young Link
-Lyndis
-Daisy
-Anna
-Hades
-Geno
-Style Savvy
-Tingle
-Tiki
-Baby Mario
-Jibanyan
-Nintendog
-Slime
-Black Shadow
-Jumpman
-Micaiah
 
Last edited:

PreedReve

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Apr 10, 2015
Messages
416
Yes: Bandana Dee, Lip, Pichu, Shovel Knight, Bayonetta, Reckless Safety Man, Ice Climbers, Squirtle, Ivysaur, Shantae, Wonder Red, Bomberman, Banjo & Kazooie, Mr. Resetti, Captain Toad, Chibi-Robo, Dig Dug, Chorus Kids, Chun Li, Starfy, Fiora, Professor Layton, Style Savvy, Tingle, Captian Rainbow, Simon Belmont, Inkling, Meowth, Phoenix Wright, Marshal, Rhythm Girl, Black Mage, Melia, Snake, Tetra, Andy, Callie & Marie, Dillon, Sukapon, Tiki, Zael, Anges Oblige, Jibanyan, Mallo, Slime, Fossil Fighter, Haruka Amami, Donbe & Hikari, Agent J, Agumon, Monita,

No: Krystal, Wolf, Ridley, Paper Mario, Cloud Strife, Hawlucha, Daisy, Shadow the Hedgehog, Dark Samus, Midna, Ninten, Sceptile, Spyro, Cranky Kong, Delphox, Tails, Dr. Eggman, Lark, Classic Gannon, Skull Kid, Dr. Wily, Frogger, Wario, Baby Mario, Knuckles, Ryu Hayabasa, Toon Zelda, Amaterasu, Heihachi, Jumpman, Lara Croft, Micaiah,

Indifferent: Balloon Fighter, King K. Rool, Mach Rider, Takamaru, Young Link, Isaac. Corrin, Sora, Prince Sable, Exitebiker, Dixie Kong, Lyndis, Muddy Molem, Ayumi Tachibana, Mike Jones, Rayman, Anna, Hades, Bubbles, Quote, Geno, Ray MK, Ghirahim, Urban Champion, Hanafuda, Impa, Karate Joe, Rhythm Wrestler, Sheriff, Barbara, Porky, Harry the Teleroboxer, Henry Fleming, Maxwell, Waluigi, Donkey Kong Jr., Gengar, Medusa, Masked Man, Nightmare, Zoroark, Monster Hunter, Viridi, Elma, Crono, Slippy, Sam Goroh, Starman, Ganbare Goemon, Lana, Sylux, Dr. Kawashima, Nintendog, Black Shadow, Chrom, Llyod Irving, Yoshimitsu,
 

dangeraaron10

Smash Master
Joined
Apr 7, 2015
Messages
3,222
Location
Ohio

Yes to Amaterasu. She is not only a friggin' wolf (an actual wolf, not a person with a wolf head) but she has these wicked disks on her back that helps her fight, kinda like in MvC. Her game was the bee's knees on the Wii, too. Closest thing I'll ever get to Wolf Link so I'll give a yes to Amy here.

No to Agent J. I literally can't care any less about this series.

I want to say no to Agumon but I can't pass up the ability to pit him against Pikachu. So sure, why not. (Agumon happens to digivolve into my favorite digimon, Greymon, and a FS for Agumon would surely be WarGreymon, which would be rad, so I guess Agumon has my favorite line of Digimon in them, second only to Guilemon's line)

Indifferent to Heihachi. He's awesome, sure, and he'd make a great rival to Ryu but we don't need another third party fighting game character.

<insert max sized expletive here> NO on Jumpman. We have 2 Marios. 3 if we get Paper Mario. We don't need this poser. As @ Sir Gengar de Èctoplasma Sir Gengar de Èctoplasma put it, this has to be the dumbest Smash suggestion I've ever seen. I'd take Shrek over this guy.

Lara Croft...oh Lara Croft. You literally have nothing to do with Nintendo and you just happen to be owned by Square Enix, in a vast and nearly limitless pool of choices for a Square Enix rep. Your most recent games don't even appear on the Wii U. All accounts point to No and my brain registered to my right hand to click "No" but somehow the next page said I hit "Yes". Maybe it's just the fact that Lara Croft is in Super Smash Bros. is literally THAT hype and I salivate at the idea of THE leading lady in video games being playable, especially duking it out alongside or against Samus Aran, the other leading lady of gaming.

No to Monita. No clue who this person is.

Yes to Micaiah. Sure. I don't have any particular hatred towards FE as a franchise although I think it's pretty over-repped as it is, and Micaiah doesn't use a sword so she has that going for her. I'd take her over any other FE character that dares brandishes a sharp metal pointy thing that isn't on a pole (aka swordsman), though I'd take Azura over Micaiah (don't kill me @ Troykv Troykv )
 
Last edited:

Koopaul

Smash Champion
Joined
Oct 29, 2013
Messages
2,336
Wow... Barbara is doing terrible. She's doing worse than Reckless Safety Man.

Seriously what do you guys have against her?
 

SleuthMechanism

Smash Ace
Joined
Sep 25, 2014
Messages
736
Location
The void
NNID
SleuthMechanism
3DS FC
4184-2631-5815
Switch FC
SW-7949-7248-8280
^not malice, i just really don't see the point mostly and i've barely even heard of her game. if a rhythm game were being repped i'd probably prefer a rhythm heaven character to be honest.
 

Koopaul

Smash Champion
Joined
Oct 29, 2013
Messages
2,336
That's why you do research. Sometimes a character you don't know could be a potential new Star.

Imagine in an alternate universe that Roy was never in Melee. The many people who loved him and wanted his return might say "Meh, never heard of him. Why would I want him in Smash 4?"
 

Lord-Zero

Smash Lord
Joined
Aug 2, 2015
Messages
1,740
I missed quite a few characters...I might as well vote now.

Ryu Hayabusa: Indifferent

Haruka Amami: Yes

Fossil Fighter: Yes

Black Shadow: Yes

Chrom: Yes
- He must make Palutena pay for her jokes.

Donbe & Hikari: Indifferent

Lloyd Irving: No

My ToS vote would go to Zelos only.

Toon Zelda: No

Yoshimitsu: Indifferent

Amaterasu: Indifferent

Agent J: Indifferent

Agumon: Indifferent

Heihachi: No

Jumpman: No
- He lives on as Mario.

Lara Croft: No

Monita: No

Micaiah: Yes
 

Troykv

Smash Master
Joined
Jan 24, 2015
Messages
3,990
Yes to Micaiah. Sure. I don't have any particular hatred towards FE as a franchise although I think it's pretty over-repped as it is, and Micaiah doesn't use a sword so she has that going for her. I'd take her over any other FE character that dares brandishes a sharp metal pointy thing that isn't on a pole (aka swordsman), though I'd take Azura over Micaiah (don't kill me @ Troykv Troykv )
It's okay xD. I also prefer to see Azura over another swordsman.

Oh! And if you're interested, you can visit the Micaiah's Thread and @Micaiah4Smash in Twitter.
 

MacDaddyNook

Smash Lord
Joined
Apr 24, 2015
Messages
1,197
Wow... Barbara is doing terrible. She's doing worse than Reckless Safety Man.

Seriously what do you guys have against her?
Nothing against her personally, I just liked her better as an Assist Trophy.

----------

My Votes

YES
Amaterasu

NO
"Jumpman" (Ok, now these suggestions are starting to get ridiculous, this is just plain ol' ordinary Mario and nothing more, not even an alternate Mario like Dr. or Paper, just Mario)
Agumon
Agent J
Lara Croft
Monita
Micaiah

INDIFFERENT
Heihachi
Ryu Hayabasa
Lloyd Irving
Yoshimitsu
 

FunAtParties

PM me ur character ideas girl
Joined
May 21, 2015
Messages
3,880
Location
Illinois
NNID
ZestyÑ
Switch FC
SW-8404-4905-2993
Wow... Barbara is doing terrible. She's doing worse than Reckless Safety Man.

Seriously what do you guys have against her?
I'm cool with her, but you have to admit she doesn't have that much appeal.
 
Last edited:

loganhogan

Smash Ace
Joined
Dec 22, 2011
Messages
816
I gave Donbe & Hikari, and Micaiah a yes. The rest got indifferent votes but Jumpman got a no.

I think Hikari has a nice modernised design but regardless if they pick her child look or modern look I think they could make for a fun duo

Micaiah is not my first option for a fire emblem newcomer but I like her magic only potential.

The characters I voted indifferent seem nice but not enough to convince me.

At last jumpman, I have him a no for the fact that I would much rather have Pauline, Donkey Kong jr, or Stanley. They are different characters with unique designs and I much prefer that over a third version of an already playable character.

I just realized I mistakenly voted on Donbe & Hikari and not Agumon.

Wow... Barbara is doing terrible. She's doing worse than Reckless Safety Man.

Seriously what do you guys have against her?
Barbara is very underrated in general but I think she's more fortunate than a lot of characters ranking higher Yes scores. For one she's got her own series and she's one of the luckier ones to have their series continue to this day.
 
Last edited:

smashkirby

Smash Hero
Joined
Feb 15, 2014
Messages
6,981
Location
Smashville
I gave Donbe & Hikari, and Micaiah a yes. The rest got indifferent votes but Jumpman got a no.

I think Hikari has a nice modernised design but regardless if they pick her child look or modern look I think they could make for a fun duo

Micaiah is not my first option for a fire emblem newcomer but I like her magic only potential.

The characters I voted indifferent seem nice but not enough to convince me.

At last jumpman, I have him a no for the fact that I would much rather have Pauline, Donkey Kong jr, or Stanley. They are different characters with unique designs and I much prefer that over a third version of an already playable character.

I just realized I mistakenly voted on Donbe & Hikari and not Agumon.



Barbara is very underrated in general but I think she's more fortunate than a lot of characters ranking higher Yes scores. For one she's got her own series and she's one of the luckier ones to have their series continue to this day.
Honetly, I would MUCH rather have Pauline join Smash, and even then, I actually support her for Smash, so I'd be pretty excited. Weird, huh?
 

loganhogan

Smash Ace
Joined
Dec 22, 2011
Messages
816
Honetly, I would MUCH rather have Pauline join Smash, and even then, I actually support her for Smash, so I'd be pretty excited. Weird, huh?
I feel the same, Pauline is my prefered option of the group. After her it's jr and then Stanley with Jump man last.
 

Freduardo

Smash Champion
Joined
Jan 8, 2014
Messages
2,389
Amaterasu: Indifferent. He's already in Marvel Vs. Capcom, I don't see another Okapi game happening, but I also think this would be fun.
Agent J: I'm just going to assume he's a costume and every other agent is as well. Cause there's no difference. Then I'm going to say yes. Because I like DK's final smash and think rhythm character could be interesting.
Agumon: Indifferent. Part of me says no, but another part of me wants to see digimon vs pokemon.
Heihachi: No. If I'm getting a tekken character, I want Yoshimitsu. In his soul caliber version.
Jumpman: As a skin, yes. As a character, no.
Lara Croft: No.
Monita: Indifferent. Part of me wants to say no, and another part of me can't look away from the idea of yes.
Micaiah: I'd want other fire emblem characters but she's also pretty cool. So I'll go with indifferent but in a way I'd probably be pretty content with Micaiah anyway.
 

jamesster445

Smash Lord
Joined
May 7, 2015
Messages
1,174
Agnes- indifferent, just because I'm not sure how they'll utilize all her job changes without transformations.
Baby Mario- no
Kawashima- no
Knuckles- no, wold rather have a different Sega rep than a 2nd Sonic character
Jibanyan- indifferent
Mallo- indifferent
Nintendog- no,
Slime- indifferent
Black Shadow- Yes, and not as just a replacement for our current Ganondorf also Falcon Punch scene
Fossil Fighter- yes, There's probably some moveset potential thanks at least to the pick-ax
Haruka- no
Chrom- no, maybe in Smash 5 as an alt for Lucina. But he never had anything to justify an appearance for Smash aside from being the main character.
Donbe and Hikari- no
Michaiah- yes
Monita- yes, as a silly inclusion like Wii Fit trainer
Lara Croft- no
Jumpman- no
Heihachi- indifferent
Agumon- Yes
Elite Beat Agents- yes
Amaterasu- no, enough Capcom characters its not like they made the game or anything.
Yoshimitsu- yes, bizarre moveset that represents the Tekken and Soul series.
Toon Zelda- no,
Lloyd- indifferent
Hayabusa- I'm leading the support threads, need I say more.
 

POKEMANSPIKA

Smash Master
Joined
Sep 12, 2014
Messages
4,394
Location
Mexico? (reference to Star Man)
NNID
POKEMANSPIKA
Nice pun on the Absol one Blue.
Chrom- no, maybe in Smash 5 as an alt for Lucina. But he never had anything to justify an appearance for Smash aside from being the main character.
And what did Lucina have to justify an appearance in Smash aside from being a main character in Awakening and being popular, JUST like Chrom.
 

SegaNintendoUbisoft

The Amateur Artist
Joined
Jan 26, 2014
Messages
7,301
Location
This thread
NNID
S.N.U0203
3DS FC
4725-8740-7336
Yes: Rayman, King K.Rool, Wolf, Isaac, Ice Climbers, Shantae, Dixie Kong, Wonder Red, Bomberman, Banjo & Kazooie, Captain Toad, Hades, Tingle, Cranky Kong, Dr. Eggman, Medusa, Snake, Viridi, Slippy, Knuckles

Indifferent: Bandanna Dee, Krystal, Lip, Mach Rider, Takamaru, Ridley, Paper Mario, Squirtle, Ivysaur, Prince of Sable, Excitebiker, Hawlucha, Muddy Mole, Mr. Resetti, Ayumi Tachibana, Mike Jones, Anna, Chibi Robo, Dig Dug, Chorus Kids, Bubbles, Quote, Ray MK, Starfy, Sceptile, Spyro, Professor Layton, Style Savvy, Captain Rainbow, Simon Belmont, Hanafuda, Impa, Meowth, Karate Joe, Marshal, Rhythm Girl, Rhythm Wrestler, Black Mage, Lark, Sheriff, Barbara, Classic Ganon, Porky, Harry, Henry Fleming, Maxwell, Waluigi, Masked Man, Tetra, Andy, Skull Kid, Callie and Marie, Dilon, Elma, Crono. Samurai Goroh, Starman, Ganbare, Lana, Sylux, Zael, Dr. Kawashima, Jibanyan, Mallo, Black Shadow, Fossil Fighter, Haruka, Ryu, Donbe and Hikari, Agent J, Monita

No: Young Link, Pichu, Shovel Knight, Bayonetta, Reckless Safety Man, Corrin, Sora, Cloud, Lyn, Daisy, Shadow, Dark Samus, Fiora, Delphox, Phoenix Wright, Melia, Donkey Kong Jr, Gengar, Nightmare, Zoroark, Monster Hunter, Dr. Wily, Sukapon, Tiki, Frogger, Wario Land Wario, Anges, Baby Mario, Nintendog (NO), Slime, Chrom, Lloyd, Toon Zelda, Yoshimitsu, Amaterasu, Agumon, Heihachi, Jumpman, Lara Croft, Micaiah, Absol, Blastoise, Blaziken, Gallade, Gardevoir, Grovyle, Plusle and Minun, Weavile
 
Joined
Apr 19, 2015
Messages
10,596
Indifferent to Absol and Weavile, no to the rest (I like Grovyle, Gallade, Blaziken, and Blastoise, but I prefer Sceptile over Grovyle, both Psychic and Fighting are represented in Smash and we already have Fire and Water starters in Smash).

Summary (Bold means strong like/dislike)
Yes: King K. Rool, Bandanna Dee, Wolf, Ridley, Black Mage, Gengar, Isaac, Dixie Kong, Bomberman, Captain Toad, Rayman, Chibi-Robo, Cranky Kong, Impa, Meowth

No: Geno, Young Link, Reckless Safety Man, Bayonetta, Ninten, Nintendog, Jumpman, Pichu, Lip, Balloon Fighter, Shovel Knight, Corrin, Sora, Shantae, Prince Sable, Cloud, Hawlucha, Daisy, Mr. Resetti, Ayumi Tachibana, Mike Jones, Shadow, Dark Samus, Anna, Dig Dug, Hades, Bubbles, Chorus Kids, Quote, Chun-Li, Spyro, Tingle, Style Savvy, Fiora, Professor Layton, Delphox, Captain Rainbow, Tails, Urban Champion, Hanafuda, Phoenix Wright, Karate Joe, Marshal, Rhythm Girl, Rhythm Wrestler, Lark, Sheriff, Barbara, Melia, Harry the Teleroboxer, Henry Fleming, Maxwell, Medusa, Donkey Kong Jr., Tetra, Masked Man, Nightmare, Andy, Monster Hunter, Skull Kid, Viridi, Callie & Marie, Dr. Wily, Elma, Sukapon, Tiki, Crono, Slippy, Frogger, Star Man, Wario Land Wario, Ganbare Goemon, Lana, Zael, Agnes Oblige, Dr. Kawashima, Baby Mario, Knuckles, Mallo, Jibanyan, Slime, Fossil Fighter, Haruka Amami, Ryu Hayabusa, Chrom, Toon Zelda, Donbe and Hikari, Lloyd Irving, Yoshimitsu, Amaterasu, Agent J, Heihachi, Lara Croft, Monita, Micaiah, Blaziken, Blastoise, Gardevoir, Gallade, Grovyle, Plusle & Minun

Indifferent: Takamaru, Mach Rider, Paper Mario, Ice Climbers, Squirtle, Ivysaur, Excitebiker, Wonder Red, Krystal, Banjo-Kazooie, Midna, Sceptile, Starfy, Ray MK, Simon Belmont, Inkling, Ghirahim, Dr. Eggman, Classic Ganon, Porky, Waluigi, Snake, Zoroark, Dillon, Samurai Goroh, Sylux, Black Shadow, Agumon, Absol, Weavile
 
Last edited:

SleuthMechanism

Smash Ace
Joined
Sep 25, 2014
Messages
736
Location
The void
NNID
SleuthMechanism
3DS FC
4184-2631-5815
Switch FC
SW-7949-7248-8280
Absol: No. especially in that gaudy mega form. Absol's oneof my fave pokemon and i would love to see it in pokken but i think it has absolutely no place as a character in smash.
The rest: No. same reasons as absol. random pokemon, no importance, would rather see other series get thrown a bone. Only other pokemon i'd want to see are the cut vets.

summary(bold for strong support/dislike)
Yes: Balloon Fighter, Banjo Kazooie, Bomberman, Ice Climbers, Ivysaur, King K.rool, Lip, Mach Rider, Reckless Safety Man, Ridley, Shantae, Squirtle, Wolf, Dark Samus, Dig Dug, Quote, Ray MK, Cranky Kong, Ghirahim, Inkling, Dr. Eggman, Rhythm Girl, Classic Ganon, Waluigi, Snake, Masked Man, Dr. Wily, Sukapon, Samurai Goroh, Warioland Wario, Knuckles, Skull Kid, Black Shadow

No: Ayumi, Bandana Dee, Bayonetta, Cloud, Corrin, Daisy, Dixie Kong, ExciteBiker, Krystal, Mr. Resetti, Muddy Mole, Pichu, Prince of Sable, Shovel Knight, Sora, Takamaru, Wonder Red, Young Link, Mike jones, Captain Toad, Rayman, Chorus Kids, bubbles, Sceptile, Starfy, Spyro, Delphox, Fiora, Layton, Style savvy, Tingle, Tails, Urban Champion, Lark, Sheriff, Karate Joe, Rhythm Wrestler, Impa, Marshal, Meowh, Hanafuda, Barbara, Melia, Porky, Harry, Henry Fleming, Maxwell, Donkey Kong Jr., Gengar, Tetra, Nightmare, Zoroark, Callie and Marie, Monster Hunter, Elma, Crono, Slippy, Tiki, Frogger, Lana, Goemon, Zael, Agnes, Baby Mario, Dr. Kawashima, Andy, Viridi, nintendog, mallo, Haruka Amami, Fossil Fighter, Chrom, Lioyd, Toon Zelda, Yoshimitsu, Amaterasu, Agumon, Heihachi, Jumpman, Lara, Monita, Micaiah, Absol, Blastoise, Blaziken, Gallade, Gardevoir, Grovyle, Plusle and Minun, Weavile

Indifferent: Isaac, Lyndis, Paper Mario, Shadow, Anna, Chibi Robo, Captain Rainbow, Simon Belmont, Black Mage, Phoenix Wright, Medusa, Dillon, Star Man, Sylux, Jibanyan, Slime, Ryu Hayabusa, Donbe & Hikari, Agent J
 

Sabrewulf238

Smash Hero
Joined
Oct 17, 2007
Messages
5,164
Location
Ireland
No to all of them.

and before anyone says anything I probably would have said indifferent to Hawlucha (I think maybe he was already voted on?) and maybe even yes to a number of my favourite Pokemon. (but they're not popular enough to be considered)
 
Last edited:

Yomi's Biggest Fan

See You Next Year, Baby
Joined
Sep 20, 2011
Messages
26,203
Location
Chicago, Illinois
NNID
Takamaru64
3DS FC
1375-7346-9605
Switch FC
SW-8277-6509-2593
That moment when the likes of Galalde has more yeses than Blastoise and Blaziken. Scrubs like them have poor taste in Pokemon. :4wario2:
 

Zelduh!

Smash Cadet
Joined
Aug 13, 2015
Messages
58
Location
UK
Do people still wan't more Pokemon in smash. Tbh the only fighting game I want too see these Pokemon in is Pokken tournamet.
 

Delzethin

Character Concept Creator
Joined
Mar 23, 2012
Messages
3,972
Location
St. Louis, MO
NNID
Delzethin
Do people still wan't more Pokemon in smash. Tbh the only fighting game I want too see these Pokemon in is Pokken tournamet.
There're a lot of possibilities with all the different powers the various 'mons have. Considering it's Nintendo's second biggest series and broke even while Mario gained three characters, I don't think it's out of the question it'd see two more characters, both of them newcomers!
 
Top Bottom