I need your opinions

[Yoon]

[Battle] Yoon vs Rhysin
The theme is "Freestyle".

Any style is accepted, go nuts.

Sig size: Maximum - 450x150; Minimum 350x90
Style: Any
Theme: "Freestyle"
Animation: Allowed
Restrictions: No C4D's allowed. (Includes wireframes)
Must clearly contain your current forum username.


Important:
* The signature must be original work created specially for this battle (no pre-mades).
* The signature must be posted in this battle thread before being posted anywhere else.
* C4D's will NOT be allowed, this includes wireframes, etc.
* This battle will be judged by a pre-defined judge based on the basic elements of a signature, this will insure it isn't a popularity contest.
* You may use any stock or render you desire.

I battled some kid on another forum. (Non-GFX) and now he's saying that he won because I didn't bring up a good judge. You guys wanna judge these sigs based on;

Flow - 10 pts
Lighting - 10 pts
Text - 10 pts
Effects - 10 pts
Depth - 10 pts
Composition - 10 pts

60 points total.

His entry:

My entry:

He remade a thread and picked a judge that has absolutely NO experience in GFX. So I refused his battle. Now he's trying to say he's better than me and he officially beat me cause I forfeited, etc. So yeah, mind judging for me?

 

[Signal]

his entry -
flow - 3 points
lighting - 8 points
Text - 1 point
Effects - 5 points
Depth - 3 points
Compo - 6 points
26 points total

Your entry -
flow - 7 points
lighting - 5 points
Text - 6 points
Effects - 4 points
Depth - 7 points
Compo - 7 points
36 points total


IMO you win for sure

 

[MojoMan]

HIs entry:
Flow:3
Lighting:6
Text:4
Effects:6
Depth:7
Compo:3
29
Yours
Flow:8
lighting:6
Text:7
Effects:9
Depth:4
Compo:6
40

 

[Black Waltz]

His Entry:
Flow - 3 pts
Lighting - 5 pts
Text - 1 pts
Effects - 3 pts
Depth - 4 pts
Composition - 3 pts
19



Your Entry:
Flow - 7 pts
Lighting - 5 pts
Text - 5 pts
Effects - 6 pts
Depth - 6 pts
Composition - 7 pts
36

His entry looks like someone through Katie Holmes into a ****ing blender.

 

[Yoon]

XD, He thinks you all are biased cause you know me. LOL

 

[fsdfsdgsgdf]

XD, He thinks you all are biased cause you know me. LOL

Well he is right, running over here only guarantees your "victory" >_>

 

[Yoon]

I'm pretty sure you guys would judge the art, not the person. I could post on GI or PR too. I'd probably get the same results.

 

[zrky]

flow-3
lighting-4
text-2
effects-6
depth-3
composition-3
21

flow-4
lighting-6
text-5
effects-7
depth-4
composition-6
33

not your best but only thing I REALLy like about his are the very low opacity square brushes he used, yours I just flat out like

 

[Signal]

Well if he thinks its biased let him read this post.

I am judging quality, not how much I like it.
Yoon I personally don't like yours, but at first glance his is nice, I like it more.

 

[fsdfsdgsgdf]

Katie holmes is just ugly, that's all

 

[cmpr94x]

You should have put these as anonymous.

 

[Signal]

You should have put these as anonymous.

That's the stupidest idea I've seen in a while, their names are in their sigs, FAIL

 

[cmpr94x]

lolll i didn't notice that XD XD.