Geno
(I want him in) He's not third party, he's co-owned, Nintendo just needs to give S/E credit for him, since they co-created him.
Geno's legal situation is tricky. I still think he'll make it, though thanks to demand and Sakurai's personal interest. And don't give me that "he wasn't the main character" He might as well have been, given the story. Oh, and Sheik says "hi". At least Geno was actually PLAYABLE in the game he was in.
Bowser Jr.
(Argue why you want him)
He's be alright. He's the up-and-coming star of the Mario series, though I do have a bit of a bias against him because he killed the Koopa Kids. Either way, it's not completely impossible for the Mario series to have six reps this time around, and after Geno, he's the next best thing. I'd much rather see Geno, but both being in the game would make me happy.
Waluigi
(Argue why you want him)
Yuck, NO! He's got nothing going for him. The only game where he did anything but be worthless filler was DDR: Mario Mix, and he was only the first boss. He's an AT at very best.
Zelda-
Midna (Never played TP) honestly she would be a great addition then cell-shaded link
I've never played TP, but she looks like an interesting character. Better than WW Link, that is.
WW Link
(Argue why we need another blond haired, bomb, boomerange, sword user)
While he's not quite as bad as Paper Mario in the duplicate character aspect, he's still just another Link. At least he has less of a chance of taking away spots from characters who deserve it more.
STAR FOX-
Wolf
(Argue why you want him)
I love Wolf, but it's so hard for me to picture him not being a clone. Well, it's either him or Falco to be decloned for this game, and only one will appear. Something's telling me that Falco will be playable and Wolf will be an SE boss. It's completely up in the air for now, though...
Falco
(Argue why you want him back)
See Wolf
MP-
Ridley- I don't care if he's a PC or a boss or both, but i do hope he is in
He WILL be in the game. Best case scenario, he's playable. Worst case he's a boss. Either way, we win.
Pokemon-
Jiggs is in, I don't even like Jiggs
(Argue why _____ pokemon should be in)
Lucario would be nice, because this game's in desperate need for 4th gen representation, but it's looking bleaker and bleaker as time goes on. That being said, Jiggs and Mewtwo are very likely returning.
DK-
(Argue why Dixie or K.Rool should be a PC)
I know nothing about any of the DK Country games, so I'll take the "More the merrier" stance with these guys.
EarthBound/Mother
How come there can't be more then 2 reps? there were 3 games!
Agreed. The Mother series is a fantastic one, yet with the general elimination of Mother 2 influence, ther's not many options. I hate to say this, but Lucas and Claus will probably do.
Fire Emblem-
I can't see Roy getting in cause he was a promotional ad. Marth has a chance but I can't see him coming back either.
(Argue why you want Marth or Roy back or anyone else in)
Oy...I don't know ANYTHING about Fire Emblem. I just don't want Roy back. I never liked him.
Sonic-
I don't see why we need another Sonic rep.
As much as it pains me to say this, there shouldn't be any more playable characters, though. The Grey Fox AT pretty much promises us a Tails/Knuckles AT, however, so that makes me happy. Plus, Robotnik (or, very hopefully, Metal Sonic) is probably going to be a SE boss.