Dice rolls make battles "random" like real war and moves the focus towards strategic troop placement and movement. This also prevents someone from stacking up some huge army and sweeping over everyone.I don't like the Brawl idea, and I don't like the dice roll either.
I'll try to think of something.But I'm not offering any help as I don't have any better idea though.
Guess what guys? I've got Phantom7 making the map for me! After he finishes it, I'll pm everyone and reopen signups for a week.