Good Controller Setup for the New Shorthop Shortcut?

[R O F L]

I've been wanting easy shorthops ever since they revealed the shorthop attack shortcut, mostly because I'm trash at shorthops. My only problem, is that when pressing both jump buttons, I don't have easy access to the R-stick to attack. I'm using the Pro Controller BTW

My current map is A attack, B special, X jump, Y jump, ZL grab, ZR shield, L jump, R jump (my R button is half-broken), D-Pad taunt, R-Stick tilt.
When I try to do L+R, I can't get it most of the time, and when I do X+Y, my thumb has a hard time reaching the R-stick in time if I want to attack.

Is there any controller map that you'd think would work better for the Shorthop Shortcut? Or should I just practice X+Y then quickly moving to the R-stick/A button.

 

[FartyParty]

If you're really looking for simplicity, and your R button is messed up, then you should just get used to one of X+Y, L+Y, or L+X and then moving your finger quickly to attack after, but I recommend getting comfortable with a variety of inputs based on the situation you are in. I use dual joy cons with L, X, and Y set to jump and right stick set to tilt, and I will use all of the various short hop techniques below in different situations based on what I'm trying to do, what my opponent is doing and what I expect them to do next, where my opponent and I are on stage, and where my fingers are on the controller from previous inputs.
1) Immediate rising short hop nair - A+X
2) Immediate rising short hop aerial other than nair - L+tilt stick (absolute best method for reverse aerial rushing, no question about it) or occasionally A+X+left stick direction
3) Short hop w/ the intention of doing nair - quickly slide thumb over X diagonally down and to the right towards A
4) Short hop w/ intention of doing an aerial other than nair - quickly slide thumb over Y from the top downwards towards tilt stick
5) Short hop for movement only or uncertain if I will attack - mainly X+Y or slide thumb downwards over Y but also possibly L+Y or L+X

EDIT: I neglected the option of setting both L and ZL to jump and using that as the primary short hop method, however, I personally find it awkward pressing both left shoulder buttons while also attempting to move my character with left stick.

 

[h4 Gambiteer]

I've been trying mapping both L buttons to jump, so I can press both with one finger when I want to short hop, and only one if I want to full hop.
If your R trigger is broken, you might try
1. setting both L buttons to jump
2. changing X or Y to grab/shield
3. changing ZR to grab/shield

That way you keep all your options and have two same-side triggers for jumping.
I don't like pressing X + Y for the shorthop shortcut, because you always want to use the tilt stick after that and it's better to have your fingers on stick while pressing the shorthop.

 

[Mogisthelioma]

Use a power A wireless, configure the AG buttons to Y, and press either one and X to short hop. Total cheat.