Game: Who would you rather have?

[Game&Watcher]

If Charizard brings back the trainer, Ridley, if he doesn't, Charizard. The trainer, although a cool mechanic is just a waste of space to me. Sorry, Pokemon Trainer fans.

Another F-Zero Rep or another Yoshi Rep?

 

[Reznor]

would rather have another Yoshi rep because it makes more sense

another Earthbound character or Geno

 

[Morbi]

would rather have another Yoshi rep because it makes more sense

another Earthbound character or Geno

Um... another Earthbound character. I really hate them... but I hate Geno even more. Isn't he 3rd party too? So another Earthbound character wouldn't be so bad.

Another Legend of Zelda rep, another Pokemon rep, or another Mario rep? (They saturate the roster, so I was wondering which one needed another)

 

[Game&Watcher]

I'd say Pokemon, despite the fact that the series already has the most reps, it also has the most potential additional reps.
Black Shadow or Samurai Goroh?

 

[Reznor]

I'd say Pokemon, despite the fact that the series already has the most reps, it also has the most potential additional reps.
Black Shadow or Samurai Goroh?

Black Shadow
Black Shadow looks awesome also Samurai Goroh would probably use a sword and we have enough sword guys

Paper Mario rep or Fawful

 

[moneyfrenzy]

Black Shadow
Black Shadow looks awesome also Samurai Goroh would probably use a sword and we have enough sword guys

Paper Mario rep or Fawful

Depends, if the paper mario rep is paper mario, then fawful. If the paper mario rep is someone like dimentio or count bleck, then a paper mario rep.

Bomberman or rayman?

 

[Swift Fox]

Paper Mario rep
Even though he'd be the 2nd Mario alongside the real Mario, but dat movesets... will be completely different. Take Link VS Toon Link for example!

Bomberman! It'd be funner to throw various bombs

Nice suggestions. Personally, I'm hesitant to make the second one a rule because if the game gets really slow, people may need to post more often in order to keep it relevant.

Actually, never mind! It'd be more fun to see someone gets ninja'd. XD

Bidoof or Mudkip for Pokeball?

 

[Morbi]

Paper Mario rep
Even though he'd be the 2nd Mario alongside the real Mario, but dat movesets... will be completely different. Take Link VS Toon Link for example!


Actually, never mind! It'd be more fun to see someone gets ninja'd. XD

Bidoof or Mudkip for Pokeball?

Mudkip because he is an internet meme and everyone hates Bidoof (besides me).

Wolf or Peppy?

 

[Swift Fox]

Aww, poor Bidoof

Wolf, needs a villain rep of Star Fox, obviously!

Lucario or Mewtwo² (AKA Mewtwo's alt form)?

 

[Reznor]

Mewtwo hes one of the best and coolest pokemon and I like his new form

Master Hand playable or Tabuu playable

 

[Mr. Mumbles]

Mudkip because he is an internet meme and everyone hates Bidoof (besides me).

Wolf or Peppy?

Peppy but only if his taunts were "Use the boost to get through" and "Do a barrel roll.'

Edit: Ninja'ed. Hard call, I like the both. But Mewtwo. Yay nostalgia!

Mr. G&W or Little Mac?

 

[moneyfrenzy]

tabuu, master hand would not be able to do much, and technically was playable in melee . Tabuu is just cool.
EDIT: ninja'd. Game and watch because he is way more important and has a hilarious moveset
deoxys or genesect?

 

[Swift Fox]

Dat sexy humanoid car... I mean Genesect XD

Would you rather have, Peach or Daisy?

 

[Starbound]

Peach because Melee main.

Chain Chomp (Super Mario) or Koopa Troopa (Super Mario)?

 

[LaniusShrike]

Peach because Melee main.

Chain Chomp (Super Mario) or Koopa Troopa (Super Mario)?

Koopa Troopa, because the Chain Chomp would be a great item!

Kamek (Yoshi) or a Shy Guy (Yoshi)?

 

[Swift Fox]

Kamek, he can do much more than Shy Guy... He got a scepter, he was Bowser's assistant in some Mario games, a main villain in some Yoshi games, he's proven to be much more powerful than Shy Guys!

Captain Falcon or Ganondorf with his Melee movesets?

 

[Starbound]

Ganondorf because it's freaking Ganondorf.

Pichu (Pokemon) or Tingle (Legend of Zelda)?

 

[Morbi]

Kamek, he can do much more than Shy Guy... He got a wizard, he was Bowser's assistant in some Mario games, a main villain in some Yoshi games, he's proven to be much more powerful than Shy Guys!

Captain Falcon or Ganondorf with his Melee movesets?

That is one of the hardest questions I have ever been asked... both are my Co-Mains. Jesus...

Captain Falcon mostly because he is more iconic to smash. He was also one of the OGs of Smash. Not too mention Ganondorf is the knock-off. FALCON PUNCH! Show ya moves!

Edit- Ninjaed.... like a boss.

Pichu because he is the most troll worthy character. Even more than Tingle. Not to mention he is cuter. He actually made me like Pikachu. I used to hate that little rat. Also he has Veteran status.

Dr. Mario vs Luigi?

 

[Reznor]

That is one of the hardest questions I have ever been asked... both are my Co-Mains. Jesus...

Captain Falcon mostly because he is more iconic to smash. He was also one of the OGs of Smash. Not too mention Ganondorf is the knock-off. FALCON PUNCH! Show ya moves!

Edit- Ninjaed.... like a boss.

Pichu because he is the most troll worthy character. Even more than Tingle. Not to mention he is cuter. He actually made me like Pikachu. I used to hate that little rat. Also he has Veteran status.

Dr. Mario vs Luigi?

Luigi its not even up for debate

Tom Nook or Kamek

 

[Starbound]

Tom Nook because he will kill people with thousands and thousands of bells. and maybe a couch too.

Fawful (Super Mario) or Hades (Kid Icarus)?

 

[Morbi]

Luigi its not even up for debate

Tom Nook or Kamek

Right. I forgot he was in the original. Derp. Anyways... Tom Nook.

He is way cuter. I mean not to mention that Kamek is just a generic enemy. Tom Nook has a name!

Dr. Mario vs Waluigi? (get it? I just added a Wa... tee hee)

Edit- GOD damn mother of Ninjas I HATE this game.

Hades. HADES is WAY better. He is funny, sexy, cunning, and beautiful! Not to mention we could use a villain.

Dr. Mario or mother fing Waluigi?!

 

[Reznor]

Right. I forgot he was in the original. Derp. Anyways... Tom Nook.

He is way cuter. I mean not to mention that Kamek is just a generic enemy. Tom Nook has a name!

Dr. Mario vs Waluigi? (get it? I just added a Wa... tee hee)

Edit- GOD damn mother of Ninjas I HATE this game.

Hades. HADES is WAY better. He is funny, sexy, cunning, and beautiful! Not to mention we could use a villain.

Dr. Mario or mother fing Waluigi?!

Fawful is a villain also

Waluigi because he would have a cool sports themed move set

Hades or Majora

 

[Starbound]

Hades. HADES is WAY better. He is funny, sexy, cunning, and beautiful! Not to mention we could use a villain.

King Boo (Super Mario) or Petey Piranha (Super Mario)?

 

[Morbi]

Fawful is a villain also

Waluigi because he would have a cool sports themed move set

Hades or Majora

That is actually a really difficult question. Both are some of my favorite villains in ANY given franchise.

Hades. He isn't a floating mask. He is fabulous. His hair is sexy and flowing. His bulging muscles glisten with sweat. His commentary was hilarious. His design is pretty unique too. His manhood is probably favorable as well. He just seems like the better choice. I am not going to allow nostalgia to speak for me.

Meowth or Victini?

 

[Hippopotasauce]

Meowth. Victini isn't very relevant anymore, but Meowth is timeless.
Also, Petey Piranha. King Boo wouldn't really work as a character, and I've always liked Petey in the games he's performed.
Ice Climbers without the 2 character gimmick, or Olimar without the Pikmin gimmick?

 

[LaniusShrike]

Meowth. Victini isn't very relevant anymore, but Meowth is timeless.
Also, Petey Piranha. King Boo wouldn't really work as a character, and I've always liked Petey in the games he's performed.
Ice Climbers without the 2 character gimmick, or Olimar without the Pikmin gimmick?

@MorbidAltruisim
FYI, Kamek isn't a generic minion-- the generic minion is "Magikoopa", Kamek is an actual character's name of someone who is a powerful magikoopa.

I don't think I even understand what Olimar without the Pikmin gimmick is... but I'd be curious to see it!

Waluigi or Daisy?

 

[Starbound]

Daisy. She actually did something outside of playing sports and racing.

Genesect or Keldeo?

 

[BridgesWithTurtles]

Genesect. My favorite legendary, and he'd be really unique (not that Keldeo wouldn't).

A second Ice Climber character or Big the Cat?

 

[Reznor]

Genesect. My favorite legendary, and he'd be really unique (not that Keldeo wouldn't).

A second Ice Climber character or Big the Cat?

Second Ice Climber character
Big the Cat is an awful character

Excite Bike guy or Balloon Fight guy

 

[Morbi]

Second Ice Climber character
Big the Cat is an awful character

Excite Bike guy or Balloon Fight guy

Balloon Fight guy just to troll everyone who thought the balloons on Villager were enough to count him out.

Ninten or Roy?

 

[Starbound]

Roy because teh ph1r3.

Lucina or Kumatora?

 

[LaniusShrike]

Balloon Fight guy just to troll everyone who thought the balloons on Villager were enough to count him out.

Ninten or Roy?

Roy because:
-He's more wanted.
-Ninten explicitly had no offensive specials/PSI attacks, making him kind of a poor choice for a fighting game.
-Earthbound really doesn't need another little psychic boy representative, let's be honest.
-Roy has a history with Smash and could be brought back with a renovated moveset.
-I made Roy some new specials that I really like.

Edit: Dang, fast thread.
Lucina over Kumatora, due to popularity. Besides, who knows, maybe it'll become a fun challenge to see exactly how much Smash can do with five hundred blue-haired Fire Emblem swordlords.

An original Smash character (i.e. Playable Tabuu) or Bomberman?

 

[Reznor]

Roy because teh ph1r3.

Lucina or Kumatora?

Bomberman I love his games and an original character makes no sense the game is about our favorite gaming franchises coming together not some original character

Baby Bowser or Bowser Jr

 

[Starbound]

Bowser Jr. because I grew up with Mario Sunshine.

Rosalina or Shadow Mario?

 

[IsmaR]

Rosalina, if only because Cosmic Mario > Shadow Mario.

F.L.U.D.D.-less Mario or Poltergust-less Luigi?

 

[BridgesWithTurtles]

Poltergust-less Luigi. I like him as he is.

Swordless Ganondorf or Pokemon-less Trainer?

 

[Starbound]

Swordless Ganon.

A Pokemon Trainer without Pokemon would fish, ride a bike and run into things.

Super Princess Peach styled Peach or Brawl Peach?

 

[wildvine47]

While a SPP Peach would be really fun, I quite like Brawl Peach's moveset. She just needs to be buffed.

Black Mage or Rayman?

 

[Noler_Mass]

I've always liked the idea of black Mage and never really liked the idea of Rahman so there you go.

Zubat or geodude?

 

[foolssigma]

Edit: Geodude... makes me think of Onyx and in turn Brock, bringing me back to the days of the pokemon anime. good times

Atlus rep or Mewtwo?