Game: Who would you rather have?

[Tree Gelbman]

Excite Biker, but only because I've played that game.

Muddy Mole or Urban Champion?

 

[Groose]

Eh... Urban Champion. After all, he is a "classic."

Master Hand or Tabuu?

 

[Starbound]

Master Hand because playing him in Melee is the best.

Pokemon Trainer (Kanto) or Mewtwo's Three Formes? Both would take up one character slot.

 

[jaytalks]

Mewtwo, so you can yell out "This isn't even my final form!" to your opponents.

Masked Man or Masked "Marth"?

 

[Tree Gelbman]

Masked "Marth", but would prefer it just to be alternate look for Marth.

Earthbound doesn't really need more than one rep.

Shadow the Hedgehog or Raiden (MGS)?

 

[Autumn ♫]

Shadow the Hedgehog because he is one cool motherfudger.

Raveoli or Luguini?

 

[MrBigstuff]

Pokemon Trainer (Kanto) or Mewtwo's Three Formes? Both would take up one character slot.

Mewtwo has 3 forms? I thought there was just Mewtwo and the new Awakened one?

 

[Reznor]

Shadow the Hedgehog because he is one cool motherfudger.

Raveoli or Luguini?

Luguini because I say so

Mewtwo or Lucario

 

[LaniusShrike]

Luguini because I say so

Mewtwo or Lucario

. Because .

Julius Caesar or Alexander the Great?

 

[FalKoopa]

Julius Caesar!

Jeff or Kumatora?

 

[LaniusShrike]

Julius Caesar!

Jeff or Kumatora?

Jeff for sure. We don't have any inventor characters, and we don't need any more Earthboundian psychics.

Genghis Khan or Napoleon?!

 

[Reznor]

Jeff for sure. We don't have any inventor characters, and we don't need any more Earthboundian psychics.

Genghis Khan or Napoleon?!

Genghis Khan because Napolion was really stupid

Abraham Lincoln or George Washington

 

[_R@bid_]

It's been said before: Abe is infinitely superior due to the greatness of his beard.
More bearded guys:
Bearded Isaac or Zangief?

 

[Swamp Sensei]

Bearded Isaac.

Golden Sun is amazing.

Saki, Shulk or Isaac?

 

[LaniusShrike]

It's been said before: Abe is infinitely superior due to the greatness of his beard.
More bearded guys:
Bearded Isaac or Zangief?

I like Bearded Isaac more than younger/unbearded Isaac. Also, I'm opposed to Street Fighter characters gettin' in... they've already spent enough time in Fighting Games.

Edit: Ninja'd!
I'd put my vote in for Isaac out of those three.

Aragorn or Legolas? (Lord of the Rings)

 

[Reznor]

I like Bearded Isaac more than younger/unbearded Isaac. Also, I'm opposed to Street Fighter characters gettin' in... they've already spent enough time in Fighting Games.

Edit: Ninja'd!
I'd put my vote in for Isaac out of those three.

Aragorn or Legolas? (Lord of the Rings)

Aragorn I find Legolas very annoying

Gen 2 Trainer or Gen 3 Trainer

 

[Autumn ♫]

Gen 3 because that was my first Pokemon generation.

Haunter or Gengar?

 

[CrusherMania1592]

Gengar because he's epic


Toon Zelda or Impa?

 

[Zuby]

Impa, I don't think Toon Zelda is at all necessary (Tetra absolutely, but TZ - no thanks)

Paula (Earthbound) or Kyle Hyde (Hotel Dusk)?

 

[HeroG]

Impa, I don't think Toon Zelda is at all necessary (Tetra absolutely, but TZ - no thanks)

Paula (Earthbound) or Kyle Hyde (Hotel Dusk)?

Kyle cause that game looks cool

Elite beat Agents or Rythem heaven rep (Karate Joe? is that his name?)

 

[DragonSniperNintendo]

Kyle cause that game looks cool

Elite beat Agents or Rythem heaven rep (Karate Joe? is that his name?)

Elite Beat Agents, they would be a fun rep to have. A very unique moveset.

Aeron (Pandora's Tower) or Zael (Last Story)?

 

[Opossum]

Zael has a crossbow, right? Then Zael.

Duster or Flint?

 

[LaniusShrike]

Zael has a crossbow, right? Then Zael.

Duster or Flint?

Duster, he has more interesting tools at his disposal and we don't really have a rogue/thief kind of character.

A koopa in hi-tech Black Ops gear or a koopa Samurai? Now we're getting to the hard hitting questions.

 

[Opossum]

Duster, he has more interesting tools at his disposal and we don't really have a rogue/thief kind of character.

A koopa in hi-tech Black Ops gear or a koopa Samurai? Now we're getting to the hard hitting questions.

Hmm...Koopa Samurai. Just seems cooler.

Ryu from Street Fighter or Ryu from Ninja Gaiden?

 

[Good Guy Giygas]

Ryu from Ninja Gaiden, just because he looks cooler.

Raiden from MGS or Joel & Ellie from the Last of Us?

 

[LaniusShrike]

Ryu from Ninja Gaiden, just because he looks cooler.

Raiden from MGS or Joel & Ellie from the Last of Us?

Raiden, simply because he's actually pretty cool, I guess, and Joel+Ellie is from such a bleak game that I feel like they wouldn't fit. Also, not sure how their team gimmick would work anyway.

A podobo or a buzzy beatle? (minions from Mario)

 

[OcarinaOfDoom]

Podobo for absolutely no reason.

Reggie or Non-Specific Action Figure?

 

[Swamp Sensei]

DON'T MAKE ME CHOOOSE!!!!

Reggie. My body is ready.

A Redead or a Gibdo?

 

[LaniusShrike]

DON'T MAKE ME CHOOOSE!!!!

Reggie. My body is ready.

A Redead or a Gibdo?

A combo character- starts out as a Gibdo who's slow but as he takes damage the bandages unravel and he becomes the faster Redead! Kind of a Lucario thing, but with speed instead of damage.
(if super pressed to choose, I'd say Redead.)

But the question is... Ocarina of Time Redead or Wind Waker Redead?

 

[Good Guy Giygas]

Ocarina of Time Redead, just look at it...

Daisy or Rosalina?

 

[shinhed-echi]

Daisy would be cool to have. If Zelda is based on her SS self, we'd have plenty of blonde princesses.

Crono or Cloud?

 

[LaniusShrike]

Daisy would be cool to have. If Zelda is based on her SS self, we'd have plenty of blonde princesses.

Crono or Cloud?

Crono, any day of the week. Until Cloud has a big appearance on Nintendo, he can go be his emo self with the Playstation All-Stars.

Green Arrow or Green Lantern?

 

[Opossum]

Crono, any day of the week. Until Cloud has a big appearance on Nintendo, he can go be his emo self with the Playstation All-Stars.

Green Arrow or Green Lantern?

Green Arrow. We need more archers.

Speaking of which,

Virion or Noire? Fire Emblem Awakening archers.

 

[LaniusShrike]

Green Arrow. We need more archers.

Speaking of which,

Virion or Noire? Fire Emblem Awakening archers.

I like them both, but I think Noire's extreme bi-polarity can just be thrown into her moveset in an interesting way.

Also, I think I'd like Virion more if he was actually more of, like, a fantasy gambler. Throwing deadly darts, cutting cards, and fun witticisms. His personality matches that so much better... but I guess "Oddly lethal dice thrower" isn't a Fire Emblem class.

Arthas (warcraft) or Master Chief (Halo)?

 

[DragonSniperNintendo]

Master Chief would be interesting, being like Snake but with more explosives and future tech

Adult Isaac or Matthew?

 

[BridgesWithTurtles]

Adult Isaac, though I'd rather have young Isaac. But yeah, Isaac's more important to his series overall and more recognizable.

Keldeo or Meloetta?

 

[Opossum]

Keldeo! He's a horse. :3

Marowak or Donbe? Battle of the club users.

 

[HeroG]

Keldeo! He's a horse. :3

Marowak or Donbe? Battle of the club users.

Marowak because the Sadness of a cubone :'(
The Virtual Boy or The Power Glove?

 

[shinhed-echi]

Power Glove because it's so bad.


Larc/Nester from Pilot Wings 64
vs
Fighter Hayabusa from Pro Wresling

(lol, same initials)
Go!

 

[Game&Watcher]

NINJAEDIT: Hayabusa, we could use a pro wrestler.
Mewtwo returning... as a Pokeball Pokemon or Roy returning... as an Assist Trophy?