Character Removals

[nessokman]

Don't post anti support threads...Waiting for lock

 

[soviet prince]

instead of posting waiting for lock dont post, if it needs locked a mod will get it

 

[DarkKry4]

Why should Wolf get removed? If a SF character gets ousted it needs to be Falco, Wolf is the closest thing to a villain character that SF has. Falco can easily be replaced by someone like Krystal who has potential for a nonclone moveset.

Falco will never get ousted for that nobody.

 

[Lemonwater]

Lucas
Olimar
Sonic
Snake
Diddy
Toon Link
Pokemon Trainer
Ike
Lucario


Seems pretty cut-happy, but I'd do away with these characters. I DO like some of them, but these are the likeliest ones to go, IMO.

 

[Mr.Universe]

Pichu, Doctor Mario, Young Link

Remember that when he said this he was talking about ALL veterans.
(Although I wouldn't be surprised it Snake and Ike got cut)

 

[Varg Foad]

I would remove ROB, Pokemon Trainer, Yoshi and Lucario, but I think that any characters who's in the smash series since at least melee will be in SSB4. So yoshi will be there...

Edit : Toon Link as well.

 

[MasterOfKnees]

I would remove ROB, Pokemon Trainer, Yoshi and Lucario, but I think that any characters who's in the smash series since at least melee will be in SSB4. So yoshi will be there...

Why the grudge against Yoshi? Not really trying to be offensive, just curious. There are many characters I don't like playing but I acknowledge have all rights to stay and should stay, like Olimar, G&W and Peach. Yoshi is a character that deserves to be in if you ask me.

Lucas
Olimar
Sonic
Snake
Diddy
Toon Link
Pokemon Trainer
Ike
Lucario


Seems pretty cut-happy, but I'd do away with these characters. I DO like some of them, but these are the likeliest ones to go, IMO.

Wolf, Falco, Ice Climbers, R.O.B and even Jigglypuff would go before Diddy Kong, which means he is as good as confirmed.

 

[BADGRAPHICS]

They should cut Mario, Link, Kirby and Pikachu for starters. Those guys have been in all the game up until now, and it's time they left to let some other characters have a chance.

Come on, they could totally fit Geno into the roster, and who doesn't love Geno! He was the coolest character in Super Mario RPG, which is the most popular and special Mario game ever.

 

[Varg Foad]

Why the grudge against Yoshi? Not really trying to be offensive, just curious. There are many characters I don't like playing but I acknowledge have all rights to stay and should stay, like Olimar, G&W and Peach. Yoshi is a character that deserves to be in if you ask me.

There's too many Mario series reps, and some series have like 1 or 2 characters (Mother, F-Zero...). So I think it'll be a good idea to balance the roster in that way.

 

[MasterOfKnees]

There's too many Mario series reps, and some series have like 1 or 2 characters (Mother, F-Zero...). So I think it'll be a good idea to balance the roster in that way.

To be honest, F-Zero and Mother don't really need any more reps, considering they're both pretty much dead franchises with minimal success compared to the other represented franchises in the game, despite my love for both of the series. Yoshi more or less represents Yoshi's Island, and even if you count him under the Mario banner Mario is big enough to have 5 reps, as seen in Melee. I'd also rather boot Peach off instead of Yoshi if anything, but that's just my opinion.

 

[KingofPhantoms]

How has this not been locked yet?

 

[Z1GMA]

Lucas & ROB.

 

[Lemonwater]

Why the grudge against Yoshi? Not really trying to be offensive, just curious. There are many characters I don't like playing but I acknowledge have all rights to stay and should stay, like Olimar, G&W and Peach. Yoshi is a character that deserves to be in if you ask me.



Wolf, Falco, Ice Climbers, R.O.B and even Jigglypuff would go before Diddy Kong, which means he is as good as confirmed.

I know, haha, Icies should be on my list too and I forgot about em. I just hate Diddy due to his annoying noises.

 

[MasterOfKnees]

I know, haha, Icies should be on my list too and I forgot about em. I just hate Diddy due to his annoying noises.

Diddy is extremely frustrating to play against, and I absolutely hate playing him, but I still think he has more than deserved his slot. I feel that way about a handful of characters actually, though with Diddy I actually don't dislike him in his source game.

How has this not been locked yet?

Because people keep spamming it to be locked.

 

[Morbi]

I didn't get around to posting my anti-Pokemon Trainer propaganda? Well PKMN Trainer should be cut. Cutting him would arguably be cutting 4 characters. It would save some other high risk characters like Toon Link, Ike, and Lucario.

 

[New_Dumal]

Toon Link , R.O.B , Lucario and Falco are the best choices in my opnion....
TL should stay because Zelda WW HD...
Maybe remove TL and insert Toon Ganon with a unique moveset. Replacing the Zelda non-toon villain with Giraihim.

That should be o.k... Lucario... just cut off...

 

[Lemonwater]

Diddy is extremely frustrating to play against, and I absolutely hate playing him, but I still think he has more than deserved his slot. I feel that way about a handful of characters actually, though with Diddy I actually don't dislike him in his source game.



Because people keep spamming it to be locked.

I'd be very happy if they just muted his monkey sounds lol

He, like most of the other speedy characters, can be annoying but nothing approaches the maddening rage caused by the repeated monkey noises.

 

[MasterOfKnees]

I didn't get around to posting my anti-Pokemon Trainer propaganda? Well PKMN Trainer should be cut. Cutting him would arguably be cutting 4 characters. It would save some other high risk characters like Toon Link, Ike, and Lucario.

Can't tell if ironic or not, but here goes.

I'd gladly sacrifice Toon Link, Lucario, and even Lucas for PKMN Trainer personally, and I'm not even close to maining him. It's an extremely unique character, and honestly, I'd gladly cut a clone, a semi-clone and a Pokémon that's inferior to Charizard in popularity, relevance and importance for him to make it back. Plus, it's not 4 characters' work, Red himself doesn't even require a quarter of the same work as any of his Pokémon.

Mind you I actually like playing Lucas more than PKMN Trainer, so I'm merely standing up as a matter of principles. Lucas can be replaced by Ness, Toon Link can be replaced by Link, but PKMN Trainer is irreplacable imo.