Bingo Mafia: OVAH! Who won?

[#HBC | J]

This is awful. J, if you're allowed to post in words, please do so.

I don't like how you finally have time to post yet we're supposed to just guess the meaning behind most of the pictures.

 

[Pink Lemonade]

Actually, Nabe, list your scum picks as well, whether that includes J or not.

 

[#HBC | J]

So thoughts coming out of yesterday: Seikend town, Asdioh scum, TDW leaning town, Soup and Nabe leaning scum.

 

[#HBC | J]

Declaring V/LA from 4/11/11-4/15/11

My play's hell week.

 

[#HBC | J]

Well J, what's your result? Were you roleblocked or double roleblocked?

 

[#HBC | J]

Vote: Nabe

Well J, what's your result? Were you roleblocked or double roleblocked?

Unvote
Vote: Glyphmoney

 

[DtJ Glyphmoney]

You're kidding me right

 

[#HBC | J]

You're kidding me right

 

[Asdioh]

The person who reacted least like I would expect was you Asdioh, you were on the side that wanted J lynched and you are a claimed vt, but instead of defending JTB as town which you should have believed he was from his claim, you kept hacking away at why J is probably scum watcher and not town. Since you wanted J lynched, from your point of view there was no reason not to make it public that JTB's claim was legit and push J from there.


So thoughts coming out of yesterday: Seikend town, Asdioh scum, TDW leaning town, Soup and Nabe leaning scum.

I... did believe JTB was town? Thus why I didn't vote him?
I mean, I did list him as one of my strongest town reads a long time ago, and stuck with it. It was kind of harder to stay with that view towards the end when J got that wonderful bandwagon going on him, and everyone was at JTBs throat, but I stuck with it, and I was right. I had a few doubts, mostly (like I said) because he slipped by me in Dissidia, but overall I felt he was hella townier than J, which is why I wanted J lynched despite his claim.
Interestingly enough, JTB and Smarg both had bandwagons pushed against them that forced them to claim, and I was on neither bandwagon because I couldn't understand why people thought they were scummy. And I was right. I wasn't right 'because I'm scum that knows who town is' but because I've been trying to get reads on people based on what they've posted and their relations.

Wait, are you saying that I should have used the word "contestant" to "confirm" that JTB was indeed a VT? Lol?

Speaking of reads, I didn't like this from the time where JTB was getting wagoned:

Seik are you stupid? I don't care about getting flack for this if J does eventually pop scum but you are getting him lychee before he even has the chance to return a result with the risk of losing two PRs?

You even state that you think JTB is scum but are going to lynched the claimed watcher over him because of a recent gut read? My god.

Look how pro-town this looks. He wants to get a night result out to possibly catch scum or learn the scum team PRs, while protecting possible town PRs. Surely, if he were scum, he would try to get the Watcher killed because it's a bigger threat to his team than the VT.

...right?

But what if he's scumbuddies with J? Then he gets a guaranteed mislynch on JTB and knows J can just claim he was roleblocked, and there was nothing we could do to prove J was lying unless someone happened to investigate or track him and saw something that didn't belong.
OR what if J actually is town and TDW knew that mafia had a roleblocker, so he knew that letting the watcher live would look good for him and pose no risk to his team? :D

Not saying TDW is for sure scum, but leaving the possibility out there.

also lol

the fact that Kuzi doesn't want J lynched is suspicious to me

Right because it's my meta to get J lyched when I'm town.

You say this every game, Asdioh, and you know just as much as I do that it's getting us nowhere.

insert "why so defensive?" here?


@J: glyph was heavily implying that he knew you were going to claim you were roleblocked, because he thinks you're scum.
Or he's scum that knows you were roleblocked and wants to make you look bad.
But I'm thinking it's the former. It would be pretty dumb for Glyph to tunnel you that hard, all game if he were scum and knew you were town.

Update since preview post shows new posts: voting glyph, implying he knew too much about your 'double roleblock?'

This Day is starting off so weird.

 

[Aposl]

Idk if I believe J cant type, not sure atm, but if someone would go through every possibility that J could have visited. Also J you post a picture and we will make up what it means, like yes and no, so that you can have the power to answer our questions more accurately. If you claim double role block im voting for you probably. But seeing as its very hard to communicate with you we might have to find another lead.... uggh

 

[#HBC | J]

I... did believe JTB was town? Thus why I didn't vote him?
I mean, I did list him as one of my strongest town reads a long time ago, and stuck with it. It was kind of harder to stay with that view towards the end when J got that wonderful bandwagon going on him, and everyone was at JTBs throat, but I stuck with it, and I was right. I had a few doubts, mostly (like I said) because he slipped by me in Dissidia, but overall I felt he was hella townier than J, which is why I wanted J lynched despite his claim.
Interestingly enough, JTB and Smarg both had bandwagons pushed against them that forced them to claim, and I was on neither bandwagon because I couldn't understand why people thought they were scummy. And I was right. I wasn't right 'because I'm scum that knows who town is' but because I've been trying to get reads on people based on what they've posted and their relations.

@J: glyph was heavily implying that he knew you were going to claim you were roleblocked, because he thinks you're scum.
Or he's scum that knows you were roleblocked and wants to make you look bad.
But I'm thinking it's the former. It would be pretty dumb for Glyph to tunnel you that hard, all game if he were scum and knew you were town.

Update since preview post shows new posts: voting glyph, implying he knew too much about your 'double roleblock?'

 

[#HBC | J]

Idk if I believe J cant type, not sure atm, but if someone would go through every possibility that J could have visited. Also J you post a picture and we will make up what it means, like yes and no, so that you can have the power to answer our questions more accurately. If you claim double role block im voting for you probably. But seeing as its very hard to communicate with you we might have to find another lead.... uggh

 

[Aposl]

j post a pic to mean yes with this quote

 

[Aposl]

j post a pic to mean no with this quote

 

[DtJ Glyphmoney]

There is no such thing as a double roleblock in a mafia game. Even if someone was targeted twice, it would be no different than if they were roleblocked regularly.

vote: J

 

[Aposl]

J pick a picture to mean you are not sure with this quote

 

[Aposl]

@ glyph, there is no pr that could make his watching power not work, and there is no power that can make him not talk?

 

[Aposl]

j please cooperate thx

 

[#HBC | J]

j post a pic to mean yes with this quote

j post a pic to mean no with this quote

There is no such thing as a double roleblock in a mafia game. Even if someone was targeted twice, it would be no different than if they were roleblocked regularly.

vote: J

J pick a picture to mean you are not sure with this quote

 

[#HBC | J]

j please cooperate thx

 

[DtJ Glyphmoney]

There's almost certainly a PR that could block a tracker (though I don't believe at all that J is one), simply called a roleblocker.

As for talking, it could exist, but not like this. There is no PR that would stipulate "your target may only post in gifs from video games. You know, the ones J uses".

This way he can take actions and not support them, while giving the illusion of productivity!

 

[Aposl]

j was you watch put on smarg?

 

[#HBC | J]

There's almost certainly a PR that could block a tracker (though I don't believe at all that J is one), simply called a roleblocker.

As for talking, it could exist, but not like this. There is no PR that would stipulate "your target may only post in gifs from video games. You know, the ones J uses".

This way he can take actions and not support them, while giving the illusion of productivity!

 

[#HBC | J]

j was you watch put on smarg?

 

[Aposl]

There's almost certainly a PR that could block a tracker (though I don't believe at all that J is one), simply called a roleblocker.

As for talking, it could exist, but not like this. There is no PR that would stipulate "your target may only post in gifs from video games. You know, the ones J uses".

This way he can take actions and not support them, while giving the illusion of productivity!

I aware of this, but giving him limited ability to communicatewill eventually reveal the truth or he will refuse to answer certain questions making him look scummy. I will interogate him until I am satisfied

 

[Aposl]

put no if you are saying that your ability was blocked

 

[DtJ Glyphmoney]

So about that J wagon you guys should get on now.

 

[#HBC | J]

put no if you are saying that your ability was blocked

 

[Aposl]

put yes if you know who visited her

 

[#HBC | J]

put yes if you know who visited her

 

[Aposl]

why would they block you then mute you? put yes if you think you know why, put the other response if you are not sure.

 

[#HBC | J]

 

[Asdioh]

conveniently enough, you didn't start your new "posting restriction" until after he had already said those words.
conveniently enough, you didn't claim watcher until after the doctor claimed.
conveniently enough, you were roleblocked. etc. etc.

Also the "double roleblock" thing is just something I could imagine Glyph saying irl. He was basically saying "were you roleblocked or were you roleblocked?"

Anyway:
1. J is scummy
2. If he's town, his PR is useless because of a roleblocker. In before someone tries to let him survive another day with the excuse "they could be a 1-shot roleblocker!"

Idk if I believe J cant type, not sure atm,

He probably can.

but if someone would go through every possibility that J could have visited.

What's the point? He was obviously going to watch Smarg, and if he was "roleblocked" it wouldn't matter in the slightest who he visited.

Also J you post a picture and we will make up what it means, like yes and no, so that you can have the power to answer our questions more accurately. If you claim double role block im voting for you probably. But seeing as its very hard to communicate with you we might have to find another lead.... uggh

welp

>_>


But then suddenly J says he knows who visited Smarg but can't talk because of Talkblocker. I'll play along for now.

J: Yes or no, was Smarg visited by more than one person?

 

[#HBC | J]

J: Yes or no, was Smarg visited by more than one person?

 

[#HBC | J]

conveniently enough, you didn't start your new "posting restriction" until after he had already said those words.
conveniently enough, you didn't claim watcher until after the doctor claimed.
conveniently enough, you were roleblocked. etc. etc.

 

[Aposl]

in your opinion if you can be role blocked are you of any more use to town J? not today but in the future, shouldn't we lynch you. I want to know what you think, obviously yes or no is all you can say. And dont say idk, that would feel scummy, just be honest.

 

[Asdioh]

But then suddenly J says he knows who visited Smarg but can't talk because of Talkblocker. I'll play along for now.

freaking got confused because of Aposls wording:

put no if you are saying that your ability was blocked

I would think "put yes" would make more sense, so that's what confused me.

So tl;dr


unvote
Vote: J

 

[Aposl]

so you say you know why and your not sure why they double blocked you. Okay


new pic here for im not sure, but I have an idea

because you shouldn't use yes and idk in the same answer

 

[#HBC | J]

in your opinion if you can be role blocked are you of any more use to town J? not today but in the future, shouldn't we lynch you. I want to know what you think, obviously yes or no is all you can say. And dont say idk, that would feel scummy, just be honest.

freaking got confused because of Aposls wording:

I would think "put yes" would make more sense, so that's what confused me.

So tl;dr

unvote
Vote: J

 

[DtJ Glyphmoney]

Here's an idea J,

You've clearly proven that you're only going to post in images, and those images can have text in them. So type your responses in word, prnt scrn, upload and boom.

"Oh but print screens get you modkilled and are against the rules!"

Nope, not in this game. So J you can either put on your big boy pants and post actual thoughts, or you can be lynched. Well actually you're getting lynched either way, but I'll see a continuation of posting in that manner as an admission of being scum.