I agree with Enshoku that your points are indeed valid, however; you calling it dumb is extremely short sighted and shows a lack of futher contemplation on your part.
Think of this, Play computers and then go to a tournament vs. playing people and see how you'll do better. Now, think about playing Wi-Fi free for all, then going to a tournament. Now, think of playing a few clansmen and their secondaries for some hours then going to a tournament. Sure, the whole forum is dedicated to Ike (This section of it); but what we're trying to achieve is something deeper with more a more personal way to have fun in the game.
Ontop of that, it's always the possibility of going Out of city or state and you being able to smash or use a clansman as a partner in case you don't have one. Or even just running into each other; it's much more things than just being character specific. Besides, if one person is good, they can easily bring up every member to their level. Think abou tall the benefits and reasons beyond just the general perception.
Alright, I'll elaborate on what I meant by saying 'dumb'.
Yes, playing against computers all day, or FFA wi-fi and then going to a tournament is a bad idea. It's a completely different experience, I know (well, minus the wi-fi). And yes, I could see the advantages of playing against people's secondaries in order to get good at the match up, learn different techniques, etc. It all makes sense, and I took this all into consideration.
However, there's several things I need to point out here. First off, it's still wi-fi. The timings will be at least a little off, which just isn't a good situation to practice in. (I know not that great of a point, but at high end tournies it makes a difference)
Second, is that training against the clan members secondaries is just that. They are "Secondaries" yeah, they'll still be GOOD with them, but they aren't the BEST with them. Personally, I'd just go and ask someone from [character]'s forum to have some matches against me if I wanted to get some practice against a character in.
Another thing you mentioned, was that you could go out of city, and pair up with your clan members and stuff, because you'll be dealing with stuff on a more 'personal' basis. Ok, don't get me wrong, it's a good idea and all, but let's face it. You're still meeting someone you met over the internet, clan or not. I've met plenty of smashers during melee without a clan, and they're all cool people, and I met them through this forum, not a clan. You might have more interaction online with them in your clan, but you're still meeting a person from the web in person, and it's not much different from meeting them at a smash fest from a forum. It's going to be weird one way or the other, until after you've met them the first time.
I'm not saying you guys are wrong or that you shouldn't do it, just in my opinion (see, no second p this time
), it is generally the same thing. I didn't mean to say it was 'dumb' as an insult, I meant it more or less as, "you are doing something similar right now".
...I suppose I could've used redundant, but that might've confused people..
EDIT: Somewhere along what I wrote, I forgot to mention another thing. Overall, playing in person is better than wifi, due to no lag, getting to know other people, being able to decide what to practice, and MOST IMPORTANTLY, you can get/give advice a lot easier during matches, and after matches. To be told what to do, and what not to do, and little things here and there is one of the most important things to making a good player great.