3 Old, 3 New

[bossyjellyfish]

Old

Marth
Ness
Link

New

ROB
Wolf
Toon Link

 

[reothepenguin]

OLD
marth
fox
luigi

NEW
Ike
King Dedede
PT

 

[Xiroey2]

[edited for privacy]

 

[espio87]

Old:
Kirby
Ganondorf
Luigi

New:
Wario
Snake
Lucas

 

[Lucas_User]

Ness
Falco
Luigi

Lucas
Lucario
ZSS

 

[Cheezball]

Old:

Pikachu
Ganon
Falco

New:

R.O.B.
Pit
Pokemon Trainer or Wolf

 

[eggs-on-toast]

Old:
DK (yes donkey kong has a user)
Yoshi
Fox/Ice Climbers

New:
Wolf
Diddy
Wario

 

[Kevtrev]

Old:
Bowser
Donkey Kong
Captain Falcon

New:
Wario(Classic!)
Pokémon Trainer
King Dedede

Apparently I like heavyweights.

 

[JoJoRukus]

Old:
Marth
Ganondorf
Bowser

New:
Dedede
Ike
Meta Knight

 

[kunai_abuser]

Old
Yoshi
Marth
Falco

New
Ike
Toon Link
Pokemon Trainer

 

[fuzzy4]

Old:
Mario
Kirby
Donkey Kong

New:
Diddy
Sonic
Wario

I quick made a list of the most chosen characters so far, in case anyones curious. I was.

Old:
Mario x12
Kirby x12
Marth x11
Falco x10
Bowser x10
Fox x8
Luigi x8
Samus x7
Link x7
C. Falcon x5
G&W x5
Yoshi x5
Ice Climbers x4
Pika x4
Ness x3
Zelda x3
Jiggly x3
Sheik x1
DK x1

New
Dedede x13
Wolf x11
PT x11
R.O.B. x11
Lucario x10
Sonic x8
Ike x8
Pit x7
Olimer x7
Diddy x7
Snake x6
Metaknight x6
Wario x6
Lucas x5
ZSS x4
Toon Link x4

This may be a bit inaccurate. I'm tired, and a lot of people were very indecisive in their posts, but it's a general idea of where everyone stands right now.

 

[DOGE]

Old:
Link
Captain Falcon
Young Link

New:
DeDeDe
Pokemon Trainer
Lucario

 

[PaperLink]

Old
Link
Luigi
C. Falcon

New
PT
Snake
Dedede

Does Toon link count as new or old? Whichever, just knock off the bottom guy on that list and put him on top.

 

[Kye L]

Lessee...

Old:
Captain Falcon
Falco
Mario

New:
Dedede
Meta Knight
Olimar

This list doesn't matter much, though, there are waaaaay too many characters that I'm waaaaay too excited about playing as.

 

[Fimbulvetr]

Old:
Samus
Link
Falco

New:
All of them, quite frankly. If I had to choose though...
Lucario
Sonic
Ike

 

[Lynkx]

Old:

Link
...

That's it really for the old. But if I had to choose...

Falco
Mario

For the new fellas, it'd be:

Meta Knight
Sonic
Toon Link

 

[heartless-bowser]

Sure, why not.

Old:
Mario
Bowser
Marth

New:
Pokemon Trainer
Wolf
Snake

 

[soulz]

Old
Ice Climbers
Yoshi
Peach

New
Dedede
Sonic
Wolf

 

[Ridley22]

Old:
Falco
Yoshi
C.F.

New:
DDD
Olimar
Diddy

 

[P!z@]

old:
peach
marth
bowser

new:
Wolf
Zamus
sonic

 

[Rhubarbo]

Vets:
Mario
C.Falcon
Ness

Newcomers:
Pikmin and Olimar
Pokemon Trainer
Sonic

 

[The Fail Tracer]

Old
Fox
Luigi
Marth

New
Toon Link
Ike
Wolf

 

[d0c926]

OLD:Fox/Falco, C.Falcon, Link
New: Wolf, Lucario and choice between Ike and/or PT

 

[Doggalina]

Old
Falcon
Pikachu
Falco

New
Wolf
Snake
Olimar

I'm going to try everybody out, though. I want to get a feel for every character before I choose (well, besides Falcon, I know that he rocks)

 

[Banjodorf]

Old

-Marth
-Falco
-Link

New

-Olimar
-Lucario
-ROB

 

[Greevy]

Old:
Pikachu
Ice Climbers
Samus

New:
ZSS
P. Trainer
Olimar
(Possible Pit instead of ZSS)

 

[Hitage]

Old
Ness
Yoshi
Bowser

New
Sonic
Pit
Toon Link

 

[TheLeperKhan]

Veterans:
Pikachu
Captain Falcon
Marth

Newcomers:
Wario
Snake
Pit

 

[this_plumber]

Who I already main:Mario, Young Link(Toon Link), Peach, Samus, Puff, Fox, C.Falcon

Old:G&W, Shiek, Kirby maybe?

New:MetaKnight, Sonic, Snake

 

[Raym]

Veterans

Marth(SSBM Main)
Pikachu(SSB64 Main)
C.Falcon or Link(SSB64 and SSBM second Main respectively)

Newcomers

Lucario
Sonic
Snake

 

[gangstajuice02]

old:
Fox
Captain Falcon
Link

New:
Lucario
Sonic
Wolf

 

[SmashChu]

Old:
Peach
Ice Climbers
Falco

New:
Wario
R.O.B.
Ike

 

[frankisvital]

Vets:
Marth
Luigi
Gannondorf

Newbies:
Pokemon Trainer
Ike
R.O.B.

 

[Oblivion129]

Old:
Marth
Luigi
Link

New:
Meta Knight
King DeDeDe
Wolf

 

[DeChTu]

Oddly enough, this is exactly the system I follow for mains...

In Melee, I had...

Link
Yoshi
Kirby

Mewtwo
Falco
Bowser

In Brawl, I'm looking at...

Toon Link
Yoshi
Kirby

Lucario
Ivysaur
ROB

 

[Toesrus]

Old:

Fox
Marth
Zelda(shes really good now)

New:

Toon Link
DeDeDe
Pokemon Trainer

 

[Windlord]

Old:

1. Marth
2. Falco
3. Link

New:

1. Ike
2. Metaknight
3. Toon Link

 

[MrPitters2351]

Old
Samus
Link
Falco

New
PT
Meta Knight
Sonic

Must Kill at all costs
ROB

 

[MysticKenji]

Old:
Marth
Pikachu
Kirby

New:
PT
Ike
Lucario

 

[VideoGamer713]

Old:
Falco
Link
Luigi

New:
Lucario
Sonic
Pit