Fortanono
Smash Ace
- Joined
- Sep 24, 2013
- Messages
- 893
And now...
lonekonwolf vs. SuperBrawler!
lonekonwolf's roster:
Dixie Kong: I'd consider her a semi-clone, but she'd be an awesome semi-clone (if there are any)
King K. Rool: He has a ton of moveset potential, using things from all his appearances.
Saki: He'd be okay, not very unique but not bland either.
Ridley: I personally think he is too big, but I won't make it a bad thing as all of your rosters have him.
Palutena: She'd actually be really cool, I'd prefer another KI character but that's bias.
Dark Pit: Could be unique or a semi-clone, depending on how Sakurai does it.
Little Mac: Sorry, I just don't see any potential in a guy that only punches.
Takamaru: I think he has a bit of potential, but I prefer other retros over him.
Waddle Dee: My bias is saying no, but the moveset potential (Waddle Doo Beam, Spears, Megaton Punch) says yes.
Lip: One of the most unique characters I've seen.
Roy: A bit of a clone, but I know nothing about FE, so I wouldn't know.
Lyn: See Saki.
Dillon: Would be really cool, although I'd see him as a Sonic clone due to him probably not being able to use guns.
Tom Nook: I'd see him as a Villager clone, although he could also be unique.
Shulk: See Saki again.
Mewtwo: Awesome! Mewtwo could definitely return to the fray with Psystrike and his Mega Evos.
Banjo and Kazooie: Microsoft bought Rare, but from what I've heard, they would be awesome, and this is a creativity contest anyway.
Bomberman: A bomb-only character would be pretty darn cool, actually.
Overall: 7.5/10
SuperBrawler's roster:
Dr. Mario: In Melee, he was not only a clone, but one that greatly overshadowed Mario by being better in every way. And Mario is Nintendo's mascot, so... yeah.
Toad: Honestly, I just don't see much potential in Toad, for some reason. Not to mention the fact that he's been deconfirmed by now.
King K. Rool: He has a ton of moveset potential, using things from all his appearances.
Tetra: A pretty interesting idea, but I kinda see her transformation (Toon Zelda) being a clone.
Ridley: I personally think he is too big, but I won't make it a bad thing as all of your rosters have him.
Waddle Dee: My bias is saying no, but the moveset potential (Waddle Doo Beam, Spears, Megaton Punch) says yes.
Krystal: She'd be cool, the first SF rep that isn't a clone.
Pichu: He was your main, so I won't go all out on you, but he is another clone, and one who hurts himself when he attacks.
Mewtwo: Awesome! Mewtwo could definitely return to the fray with Psystrike and his Mega Evos.
Roy: A bit of a clone, but I know nothing about FE, so I wouldn't know.
Lyn: She'd be okay, not very unique but not bland either.
Porky: Seeing as he doesn't have very many weapons other than his mech, which is too big... Yeah.
Black Shadow: Another clone, but a good one as he could use Ganondorf's old moveset, allowing him to have a unique moveset.
Isaac: Just read about him, and he sounds awesome. Then again, it's the Smashboards thread we're talking about, so yeah.
Takamaru: I think he has a bit of potential, but I prefer other retros over him.
Palutena: She'd actually be really cool, I'd prefer another KI character but that's bias.
Lip: One of the most unique characters I've seen.
Pac-Man: Would be very unique. And seeing him with Mario, Sonic and Mega Man would be plain awesome.
Overall: 6.5/10
And...
lonekonwolf is the winner! Sorry SuperBrawler.
lonekonwolf vs. SuperBrawler!
lonekonwolf's roster:
Dixie Kong: I'd consider her a semi-clone, but she'd be an awesome semi-clone (if there are any)
King K. Rool: He has a ton of moveset potential, using things from all his appearances.
Saki: He'd be okay, not very unique but not bland either.
Ridley: I personally think he is too big, but I won't make it a bad thing as all of your rosters have him.
Palutena: She'd actually be really cool, I'd prefer another KI character but that's bias.
Dark Pit: Could be unique or a semi-clone, depending on how Sakurai does it.
Little Mac: Sorry, I just don't see any potential in a guy that only punches.
Takamaru: I think he has a bit of potential, but I prefer other retros over him.
Waddle Dee: My bias is saying no, but the moveset potential (Waddle Doo Beam, Spears, Megaton Punch) says yes.
Lip: One of the most unique characters I've seen.
Roy: A bit of a clone, but I know nothing about FE, so I wouldn't know.
Lyn: See Saki.
Dillon: Would be really cool, although I'd see him as a Sonic clone due to him probably not being able to use guns.
Tom Nook: I'd see him as a Villager clone, although he could also be unique.
Shulk: See Saki again.
Mewtwo: Awesome! Mewtwo could definitely return to the fray with Psystrike and his Mega Evos.
Banjo and Kazooie: Microsoft bought Rare, but from what I've heard, they would be awesome, and this is a creativity contest anyway.
Bomberman: A bomb-only character would be pretty darn cool, actually.
Overall: 7.5/10
SuperBrawler's roster:
Dr. Mario: In Melee, he was not only a clone, but one that greatly overshadowed Mario by being better in every way. And Mario is Nintendo's mascot, so... yeah.
Toad: Honestly, I just don't see much potential in Toad, for some reason. Not to mention the fact that he's been deconfirmed by now.
King K. Rool: He has a ton of moveset potential, using things from all his appearances.
Tetra: A pretty interesting idea, but I kinda see her transformation (Toon Zelda) being a clone.
Ridley: I personally think he is too big, but I won't make it a bad thing as all of your rosters have him.
Waddle Dee: My bias is saying no, but the moveset potential (Waddle Doo Beam, Spears, Megaton Punch) says yes.
Krystal: She'd be cool, the first SF rep that isn't a clone.
Pichu: He was your main, so I won't go all out on you, but he is another clone, and one who hurts himself when he attacks.
Mewtwo: Awesome! Mewtwo could definitely return to the fray with Psystrike and his Mega Evos.
Roy: A bit of a clone, but I know nothing about FE, so I wouldn't know.
Lyn: She'd be okay, not very unique but not bland either.
Porky: Seeing as he doesn't have very many weapons other than his mech, which is too big... Yeah.
Black Shadow: Another clone, but a good one as he could use Ganondorf's old moveset, allowing him to have a unique moveset.
Isaac: Just read about him, and he sounds awesome. Then again, it's the Smashboards thread we're talking about, so yeah.
Takamaru: I think he has a bit of potential, but I prefer other retros over him.
Palutena: She'd actually be really cool, I'd prefer another KI character but that's bias.
Lip: One of the most unique characters I've seen.
Pac-Man: Would be very unique. And seeing him with Mario, Sonic and Mega Man would be plain awesome.
Overall: 6.5/10
And...
lonekonwolf is the winner! Sorry SuperBrawler.