• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Yet Another Roster Contest! (Waiting to be locked)

Status
Not open for further replies.
loganhogan

loganhogan

Smash Ace
Joined
Dec 22, 2011
Messages
816
Oooooooooohohohoho I want in! Super Boss Brothers, Super Bash Sisters, and Super NAY Brothers yes please! When is the deadline?
 
Fortanono

Fortanono

Smash Ace
Joined
Sep 24, 2013
Messages
893
BTW, any rosters or changes to rosters will be due tomorrow. So SuperBrawler, add Lanky quick!
 
Z

Zigzagar

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Aug 7, 2013
Messages
225
lonekonwolf said:
oh okay, seeing how changes can be done, can I add one spare change?

View attachment 4696
Click to expand...
Why do you have 3 kid icarus characters (I question the importance of adding a second kid icarus character) but 3 is way too much since pit was just a newcomer in brawl and also dark pit is a recolour of another character and a bit too similar and already in brawl as a colour scheme

Why do you have more pokemon slots than mario slots

Why do you have Roy and Lyn in addition to Marth and Ike (They are just random protagonists now with no current relevance

Why have Tom Nook when you have the Villager

Why Dillon over Isaac, Golden Sun is well received and critically acclaimed and Dillon's Rolling western didn't make as big as an impact compared to other series imagine having the style savvy shop manager

Banjo & Kazooie is owned by Microsoft and has no current relevance

Why are you changing the representation of Konami by having Bomberman over Snake I think if Konami is represented in SSB4 the chances will be stuck with Snake
 
BluePikmin11

BluePikmin11

Akko is my dear daughter!
Joined
Jan 5, 2013
Messages
28,373
Location
https://twitter.com/BPikmin11
NNID
blue
Zigzagar said:
Why do you have 3 kid icarus characters (I question the importance of adding a second kid icarus character) but 3 is way too much since pit was just a newcomer in brawl and also dark pit is a recolour of another character and a bit too similar and already in brawl as a colour scheme

Why do you have more pokemon slots than mario slots

Why do you have Roy and Lyn in addition to Marth and Ike (They are just random protagonists now with no current relevance

Why have Tom Nook when you have the Villager

Why Dillon over Isaac, Golden Sun is well received and critically acclaimed and Dillon's Rolling western didn't make as big as an impact compared to other series imagine having the style savvy shop manager

Banjo & Kazooie is owned by Microsoft and has no current relevance

Why are you changing the representation of Konami by having Bomberman over Snake I think if Konami is represented in SSB4 the chances will be stuck with Snake
Click to expand...
This is a roster contest, the rules state it does not have to be realistic bud.
 
LoneKonWolf

LoneKonWolf

Lazy Lonely Lurker☕
Joined
Oct 8, 2013
Messages
3,661
Location
Somewhere with Coffee
Zigzagar said:
Why do you have 3 kid icarus characters (I question the importance of adding a second kid icarus character) but 3 is way too much since pit was just a newcomer in brawl and also dark pit is a recolour of another character and a bit too similar and already in brawl as a colour scheme

Why do you have more pokemon slots than mario slots

Why do you have Roy and Lyn in addition to Marth and Ike (They are just random protagonists now with no current relevance

Why have Tom Nook when you have the Villager

Why Dillon over Isaac, Golden Sun is well received and critically acclaimed and Dillon's Rolling western didn't make as big as an impact compared to other series imagine having the style savvy shop manager

Banjo & Kazooie is owned by Microsoft and has no current relevance

Why are you changing the representation of Konami by having Bomberman over Snake I think if Konami is represented in SSB4 the chances will be stuck with Snake
Click to expand...
this is a want roster contest, those are my wants mate,
read the op before you judge people
 
SmasherMaster

SmasherMaster

Smash Lord
Joined
Jul 31, 2012
Messages
1,679
Location
USA
NNID
TelevisionGamer
Can I change my roster? Made a last few minute changes along wiht the addition for same slot characters
60CharRoster.png
 
Fortanono

Fortanono

Smash Ace
Joined
Sep 24, 2013
Messages
893
And now it's time for...
Keybladeguy vs. Tepig2000!

Keybladeguy's roster:



Toad: Honestly, I just don't see much potential in Toad, for some reason. Not to mention the fact that he's been deconfirmed by now.
Diddy + Dixie tag-team: Diddy should probably stay separate from Dixie, but the pairing would also be cool, another duo would be cool.
King K. Rool: He has a ton of moveset potential, using things from all his appearances.
Takamaru: I think he has a bit of potential, but I prefer other retros over him.
Ridley: I personally think he is too big, but I won't make it a bad thing as all of your rosters have him.
Krystal: She'd be cool, the first SF rep that isn't a clone.
Mewtwo: Awesome! Mewtwo could definitely return to the fray with Psystrike and his Mega Evos.
Little Mac: Sorry, I just don't see any potential in a guy that only punches.
Isaac: Just read about him, and he sounds awesome. Then again, it's the Smashboards thread we're talking about, so yeah.
Shulk: He'd be okay, not very unique but not bland either.
Saki: See Shulk.
Mach Rider: See Shulk again.
Balloon Fighter: How exactly would he work? And don't forget Villager's move.
Duck Hunt Dog: He'd be really cool, especially with the concept WiiLuvU "leaked" (Hunter shoots ducks down, dog collects them and uses them in battle)
Sukapon: See Shulk for the 3rd time. :p
Lip: One of the most unique characters I've seen.
Pac-Man: Would be very unique. And seeing him with Mario, Sonic and Mega Man would be plain awesome.
Simon Belmont: Wow, you keep seeing Shulk. This is no exception!
Overall: 7/10

Tepig2000's roster:



Petey Piranha: He'd be awesome, and something tells me he'd play like Ivysaur. And he's my main.
Kamek: Awesome, I dig wizardish characters.
Ashley: Cool, but her and Kamek in the same roster = clones.
Waluigi: Epic! All that sports stuff, I just hope he gets in!
Dixie Kong: I'd consider her a semi-clone, but she'd be an awesome semi-clone (if there are any)
King K. Rool: He has a ton of moveset potential, using things from all his appearances.
DK Jr.: Wait, what? I don't think so.
Meowth: WHY DIDN'T HE GET IN IN THE FIRST PLACE? HE'D BE AWESOME!
Deoxys: I'd say Deoxys would be cool, especially with it's other forms.
Midna: Pikachu, Ice Climbers... We need a darkness user, and Midna fits the bill perfectly.
Yarn Kirby: YES YES YES YES YES!!!
Ridley: I personally think he is too big, but I won't make it a bad thing as all of your rosters have him.
Space Pirate: I don't think so.
Matthew: Either him or Isaac, both would be pure awesome.
Lip: One of the most unique characters I've seen.
Chrom: Newest lord, deserves a spot.
Lucina: Maybe a Marth clone, but she could also be really unique.
Starfy: He'd be cool, but I just don't see him in Smash.
Shulk: He'd be okay, not very unique but not bland either.
Palutena: She'd actually be really cool, I'd prefer another KI character but that's bias.
Little Mac: Sorry, I just don't see any potential in a guy that only punches.
Krystal: She'd be cool, the first SF rep that isn't a clone. But wait, you cut Falco and Wolf for her?
Overall: 8.5/10

And...

Tepig2000 wins!!!
 
Fortanono

Fortanono

Smash Ace
Joined
Sep 24, 2013
Messages
893
Well, I solved the predicament of posting it too early by editing. And sorry about that, Keybladeguy.
 
Z

Zigzagar

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Aug 7, 2013
Messages
225
Fortanono said:
And now it's time for...
Keybladeguy vs. Tepig2000!

Keybladeguy's roster:


Toad: Honestly, I just don't see much potential in Toad, for some reason. Not to mention the fact that he's been deconfirmed by now.
Diddy + Dixie tag-team: Diddy should probably stay separate from Dixie, but the pairing would also be cool, another duo would be cool.
King K. Rool: He has a ton of moveset potential, using things from all his appearances.
Takamaru: I think he has a bit of potential, but I prefer other retros over him.
Ridley: I personally think he is too big, but I won't make it a bad thing as all of your rosters have him.
Krystal: She'd be cool, the first SF rep that isn't a clone.
Mewtwo: Awesome! Mewtwo could definitely return to the fray with Psystrike and his Mega Evos.
Little Mac: Sorry, I just don't see any potential in a guy that only punches.
Isaac: Just read about him, and he sounds awesome. Then again, it's the Smashboards thread we're talking about, so yeah.
Shulk: He'd be okay, not very unique but not bland either.
Saki: See Shulk.
Mach Rider: See Shulk again.
Balloon Fighter: How exactly would he work? And don't forget Villager's move.
Duck Hunt Dog: He'd be really cool, especially with the concept WiiLuvU "leaked" (Hunter shoots ducks down, dog collects them and uses them in battle)
Sukapon: See Shulk for the 3rd time. :p
Lip: One of the most unique characters I've seen.
Pac-Man: Would be very unique. And seeing him with Mario, Sonic and Mega Man would be plain awesome.
Simon Belmont: Wow, you keep seeing Shulk. This is no exception!
Overall: 7/10

Tepig2000's roster:



Petey Piranha: He'd be awesome, and something tells me he'd play like Ivysaur. And he's my main.
Kamek: Awesome, I dig wizardish characters.
Ashley: Cool, but her and Kamek in the same roster = clones.
Waluigi: Epic! All that sports stuff, I just hope he gets in!
Dixie Kong: I'd consider her a semi-clone, but she'd be an awesome semi-clone (if there are any)
King K. Rool: He has a ton of moveset potential, using things from all his appearances.
DK Jr.: Wait, what? I don't think so.
Meowth: WHY DIDN'T HE GET IN IN THE FIRST PLACE? HE'D BE AWESOME!
Deoxys: I'd say Deoxys would be cool, especially with it's other forms.
Midna: Pikachu, Ice Climbers... We need a darkness user, and Midna fits the bill perfectly.
Yarn Kirby: YES YES YES YES YES!!!
Ridley: I personally think he is too big, but I won't make it a bad thing as all of your rosters have him.
Space Pirate: I don't think so.
Matthew: Either him or Isaac, both would be pure awesome.
Lip: One of the most unique characters I've seen.
Chrom: Newest lord, deserves a spot.
Lucina: Maybe a Marth clone, but she could also be really unique.
Starfy: He'd be cool, but I just don't see him in Smash.
Shulk: He'd be okay, not very unique but not bland either.
Palutena: She'd actually be really cool, I'd prefer another KI character but that's bias.
Little Mac: Sorry, I just don't see any potential in a guy that only punches.
Krystal: She'd be cool, the first SF rep that isn't a clone. But wait, you cut Falco and Wolf for her?
Overall: 8.5/10

And...

Tepig2000 wins!!!
Click to expand...
I find weird choices in both rosters
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom