infiniteV115
Smash Hero
If you make a post that includes some bad logic and you include a conclusion in that post which you came to from both the logic in the post and outside of the post (ie 'more reasoning to what they said than you could pick up on'), people have every right to tell you that your logic is bad.Your logic is not what you said, your logic is the train of thought you had, which you won't know for certain unless they tell you. People can have more reasoning to what they said than you could pick up on.
This discussion is getting silly. All of it stemmed from you assuming that 'your logic' meant 'all your logic' when it should be blatantly obvious to you that 'by your logic' posts are referring to the logic used in your posts and nothing else. -.-
If people are making 'by your logic posts', they are addressing the logic you used in your post and nothing more, regardless of whether the conclusion you came to was reasonable or not. If the conclusion you come to is correct but people are making 'by your logic' posts, that should tell you that you should include more of your reasoning and not just a tidbit, because the other people on the forum only have the tidbit to go off of.