He's partially right with the cause having some significance but, he's completely ignoring anything I say and just being way too adamant to talk to so, I'm not going to bother with him anymore.
I'll put it this way:
You both were being difficult. Now there IS a difference between the two techniques. The difference?
The SJR/ISJR has the attack done
as late as possible with at least one frame to buffer. What does this mean?
Well, if Bowser's klaw hop is done instead, sure, it has an easier timing, but an
earlier timing to boot. Essentially, this means the hitboxes come out earlier with a klaw hop than an ISJR. Sometimes this would be a good thing, but in Bowser's case, it really isn't. Why? Because the lower to the ground for Bowser, the higher of a chance he'll hit the opponent unless the opponent jumps into the ****, aka is being a moron. =P This amounts to... klaw hopping making it a LOT harder to hit grounded opponents, mainly because the aerials are performed a bit sooner, but the bit sooner is enough to make it sometimes not effective in hitting the opponent.
AKA, the ONLY difference that matters is the overall result... which in this case, is having one method have the move, and thus the hitboxes, come out later than the other, as well as being done closer to the ground.
Basically, both of you are both right and wrong.
Oh, and I made that little essay above not JUST for this argument, but also to clear up the difference in the future since some people were wondering the difference too. The aerial timing is... the only main thing to take note of really. O.o Plus you can klaw hop without doing an aerial or air dodge.
P.S. I agree that 3xSwords was putting up a HORRIBLE argument, by pointing out the thing that doesn't matter between the techniques(how you do them, which doesn't matter too much in the end, just that the klaw hop is somewhat easier), and not the main, crucial difference(s), aka the results. >.>; I say it should still be included in the ISJR list though, with its current footnote, for completion's sake. It won't make much difference with Bowser anyways, so... =/
-------------------------------------------
Judge Judy: We already know. No offense, but we already have the request, and we know you want a vid of Mario. This takes time, since we all pretty much suck at doing this for now. >.>; Patience, patience, patience please.