ZOMBIES! Mafia - Who Survived the Apocalypse?

[Xivii]

It's still weird that Mac claims to have jailed Moira N1 when clearly her action went through. The only explanation would be that No Lynch is lying about receiving the armor.

You mean he. When a hydra consist of a male and female you should use the dominant pronoun.

 

[Wots All This Then?]

It's still weird that Mac claims to have jailed Moira N1 when clearly her action went through. The only explanation would be that No Lynch is lying about receiving the armor.

Red herring game, I'm just saying...

You mean he. When a hydra consist of a male and female you should use the dominant pronoun.

Rake, is that you?

 

[Moira]

I had a huge post typed up and then realized that my theory came crashing down due to Rake's track on Gorf.

If Rockin flips mafia, then Mac is clear. That leaves WATT/Circus/Ranmaru/No Lynch as "Possible redirector/janitor" and based on the information/reads I would say that WATT/Ranmaru hold the final scum. If No lynch is lying like Circus suggested, then that does poise a hypothetical inconsistency. One I do not believe because if that slot is scum, I am personally really unhappy with a certain move the Soup side did to "gain sympathy". *The replace out shenanigans* Plus my Zen meta is almost flawless, I do not think I have misread him in a game yet. *One game that was close was Ryker, but that's because he was being a butt*

@ Xivii : If we are talking about dominance in this hydra, you should use she. Sang has pretty much been in charge all game haha.

 

[Ashemu]

if this was a red herring game it's a pretty horribly designed one since there are random functional power roles like rakes and mine

 

[Xivii]

Epic Rap Battles of history. Did I link that earlier? I actually really liked that game. It should have taught people to stop relying on PRs to solve the game. And yet here we are still doing it.

 

[Moira]

Plus Scum-Zen, would just let me be lynched>protect me. He loves seeing me lynched when we are on opposing sides. Unless he is toying with my heart-strings.

Though, Soup acting like he didn't know what I was talking about at first regarding my gift does give me some sort of pause. Sang said she did not get that at all but I told her it was more than likely him derping. I am going to converse with Sang about this.

 

[Xivii]

lol I don't enjoy it, I just can't ****ing stand having to play against you.

 

[Wots All This Then?]

if this was a red herring game it's a pretty horribly designed one since there are random functional power roles like rakes and mine

That's a good point, though in a true **** game I wouldn't put it past a mod to put in functional Tracker in an otherwise all red-herring PR-fest with Neighborizer for some actual help figuring out the ****storm that would no doubt happen.

It would be ******* modding to the highest degree though, not without more checks in place.

 

[Circus]

Epic Rap Battles of history. Did I link that earlier? I actually really liked that game. It should have taught people to stop relying on PRs to solve the game. And yet here we are still doing it.

I was actually going to point to that game as a reason for why this is not a red herring set-up. And we can therefor assume that the PRs themselves are relatively reliable. It is some of the players claiming them that are not.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

and since males are OBVIOUSLY dominant...

sorry it was too easy

 

[Circus]

That's a good point, though in a true **** game I wouldn't put it past a mod to put in functional Tracker in an otherwise all red-herring PR-fest with Neighborizer for some actual help figuring out the ****storm that would no doubt happen.

It would be ******* modding to the highest degree though, not without more checks in place.

The Inventor role is also legit though.

It is more likely that we are dealing with liars than that we are dealing with faulty roles, let's just agree.

 

[Ashemu]

oh my god can we not do the ironic misogyny thing in an actual honest & innocent ongoing mafia game

 

[Moira]

I actually laughed at that one to be honest haha.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

oh and hell yea ERB maf hosted by YA BOY ****in teachin all y'all mofos a lesson about scumhuntin ya dig

 

[Moira]

@ #HBC | Mac : You mentioned my bringing up the 10.2.1 set-up and that is because I thought it would be too lobsided for town to be against 4 anti-town factions in a 9.3.1 setup. Just way wonky but it seems this may be the case with a damn re-director/bus-driver in the mix.

 

[Wots All This Then?]

The Inventor role is also legit though.

It is more likely that we are dealing with liars than that we are dealing with faulty roles, let's just agree.

Does that mean the shovel-stripper pole worked?

If so then it's far less likely. If any role was going to be total bull**** on the mod-side of things it'd be Inventor.

 

[Ashemu]

looking at the claims
mac - well if rockin is town hes probably legit on some level, also why does he go out of his way to claim a conflict with moira
moira - role confirmed, could be fabricator or just scum with a townie role though
watt - was targeted by a kill
gorf - was seen targeting watt, result that saw a kill does not add up
rake - confirmed by gorf, i guess plausible scum if you think mafia has both a tracker and a watcher

if rockin really was scum then gorf has the shakiest claim imo - voyeur could just be something he made up on the spot since he was caught targeting watt but didn't want to risk being outed as a real doc. only then that doesnt make sense because there's no way to account for mac's action failing. auuuugh

 

[Circus]

I'm not seeing anything hard leading to a redirector/bus driver. I think that concept muddies the waters until we actually have a reason to suspect something more complicated than just certain slots lying.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

dude i seriously doubt it's a case of there DEFINITELY being a liar (even though at this point if there is it's almost certainly watt) moreso than the redirector just screwing wit us hardcore. i do believe a vast majority of our claims so far, this just feels like a game of "throw the PR's in and see how they mesh" and i am surprised that @marshy was the one who approved of this game

 

[Circus]

Does that mean the shovel-stripper pole worked?

It means the stripper pole shovel exists.

 

[Xivii]

Y'know what if mafia didn't even have communication with each other. (They are zombies after all). Would again explain why Ruy thought there was another faction, not knowing who is mates were.

 

[Moira]

How is GorfScum with RakeTown tracking him to WATT??? N1?

 

[Ashemu]

thats stupid and also would probably make me scum

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

tbh it may have just been a mod error that I saw watt being targeted for death. i will confirm this asap cuz in hindsight it IS weird that i saw it, but it was specified to me as a kill ATTEMPT, which is what puts me at pause. like i said, it just as easily points to a redirecting role as it does to a mod error but... like ash said AUUUGH

 

[ranmaru]

Why say that now and not before when ashemu asked you ...

 

[Xivii]

thats stupid and also would probably make me scum

scumbag .

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

it gets on my nerves when threads become ninja heaven

 

[Wots All This Then?]

It means the stripper pole shovel exists.

I don't care if it exists, I'm more interested in if it WORKS. Red-herring inventor giving out stuff at random that does nothing would be the easiest thing in the world, and I believe we've seen it before in Gigabots(?). Some game I played had someone making laser shooting inventions, I don't remember if they worked but I don't think they did.

 

[Moira]

Attempt you say? So maybe your results aren't that sketch and actually you may have saw more than you think you did.

 

[Ashemu]

ive come to the conclusion that rolegaming is going to get us all of **** nowhere and were best off re-reading tomorrow and just lynching the scummiest guy. unfortunately im left with like 0 motivation to do this myself

 

[Moira]

I don't care if it exists, I'm more interested in if it WORKS. Red-herring inventor giving out stuff at random that does nothing would be the easiest thing in the world, and I believe we've seen it before in Gigabots(?). Some game I played had someone making laser shooting inventions, I don't remember if they worked but I don't think they did.

Are you a jester? Or like some variation of something that needs to die to win because your play this game highly constitutes this. I mean with a zombie game maybe you need to die.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Why say that now and not before when ashemu asked you ...

are you talking to me? if so why on EARTH would i up and assume that it's a mod error? it's usually never something i even consider till things just don't add up. i still don't think it is cuz of the wording of it being an attempt but like yea. go ahead and keep tryna find a reason to call me scum bro

 

[Wots All This Then?]

Y'know what if mafia didn't even have communication with each other. (They are zombies after all). Would again explain why Ruy thought there was another faction, not knowing who is mates were.

Oh hell no, not Kefka vs. Koopa communication wifom. That's literally the only awful trait this game didn't already have going for it D:<

 

[Wots All This Then?]

Also Orbo just woke up(?), and I can only assume his reaction to this **** show is going to be something like:

 

[ranmaru]

are you talking to me? if so why on EARTH would i up and assume that it's a mod error? it's usually never something i even consider till things just don't add up. i still don't think it is cuz of the wording of it being an attempt but like yea. go ahead and keep tryna find a reason to call me scum bro

I'm just wondering what made you consider saying that now instead of before.

 

[ranmaru]

also, i'm gonna peace it

nite thread

 

[Wots All This Then?]

I'm calling that a shift-change. Orbo this is all your problem now lol

 

[Wots All This Then?]

EBWOP: nvm he's just up for duty. I'm still peacing it though.

 

[Rockin]

I was about to say that I was going to try and catch up, but I'm really unsure if I got hammered or not.

It'd suck if I did, but eh.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

By do Duff HN kid six f JD but f HN f


**** this game