Yes! Communism is the answer! No, not really. Equal rights don't mean special rights for black people and diminished rights for whites.
I fail to see even a tangential relevance of Communism here. I'm not talking about property redistribution. I'm talking about de facto segregation in housing. I'm talking about segregated majority black and/or Hispanic schools that have no windows, no air conditioning, old textbooks, no computers, and inadequate space. I'm talking about employment discrimination, where a white convicted felon is more likely to receive a call back than a black man with a clean record. I'm talking about how more whites use drugs than blacks, but far more blacks are in prison for drug offenses. Not all of these things are the result of conscious actions by people. I'm not saying there's a big white conspiracy to keep black people down. But that doesn't remove the significance of those problems.
If you were actually paying attention, you would have seen my point was that there
isn't equality between blacks and whites, so what black people and white people can and can't say (socially, not legally) is irrelevant in the face of those much more important problems.
I care more with the fact that it is a federal offence for one group of people to say something but not another (hate laws).
That is not what hate laws are. At least not in the US.
Hate laws are only tangentially related to speech. What they're really about is a certain kind of criminal intent. Just like 1st vs. 2nd degree murder laws have to do with intent. The fact that someone said "******" is only relevant in so far as it establishes the intent. Just as knowing that someone had said they were going to kill so-and-so several days before the murder is relevant in establishing that it was premeditated murder. Or they have other reasons to believe you prepared beforehand. For example, if you had just bought a gun the week before the murder. It is not illegal to buy a gun, but doing that a week before murdering someone is going to increase your sentence since it will be evidence for premeditation.
You can only be charged with a hate crime if you have committed a crime, and they have reason to believe it was hate motivated. You are free to say the n-word all you like. It is not a federal offense to say it. It is a (more serious) federal offense to assault or murder a black person simply because they are black. Whether or not you said the n-word is only relevant, as I said, in so far as it can establish that you murdered them because they were black. It is not necessary that you say that, they could establish it some other way. And just because you used the word does not mean that it will be necessarily considered a hate crime (if you had some other motive, that would probably take precedence).
Maybe you don't think that attacking or murdering someone just because they belong to a certain group should be illegal, but that's a topic for another thread. However, in either case, hate crime laws do not make it illegal to say anything (in the US).
Someone isn't necessarily evoking the history behind the word when they use it.
They might not intend to, but they don't have a choice. Sorry. We would have to forget history in order for them to be able to avoid it.
Why not? "Did you see that trailer trash?" "That man looks like trailer trash." "Look at those straw haired, trailer trash whores!"
You can legally use it casually. But it will be considered very offensive. And you can't call someone trailer trash casually and expect them not to be offended either. So what's your point?
You don't have the right to not be offended, quite the opposite, you have the right to be offended and to voice your opinion about it no matter how offensive your opinion is.
I'm not talking about legal rights. I don't know why you keep bringing it up as if I'm saying you don't have the legal right to say these words.
You can say it. But it'll be considered offensive, and it's not socially acceptable. Black people can use the n-word without the same social consequences (and gay people can use "***got"). Tough. You're not a member of the group, so when you use them it's not the same context. Tough. And that's what you're complaining about. But it's a stupid complaint.
For the reasons I explained, it is less often offensive when someone gay uses the word "***got". It is more socially acceptable. That has nothing to do with legal rights. And the original topic had nothing to do with legal rights either. Quit acting like your rights are being taken away. They're not.
Hate crimes are complete bull. They place special emphasis on specific peoples and give them special rights. This goes against the equality spoken of in the Declaration of Independence and is anathema to it.
1. I don't even know why you're talking about hate crimes. That wasn't the subject of the discussion. I mentioned them, but I wasn't talking about hate crime
laws.
I would have to agree that gay people being attacked simply for being gay is bull****. My point was that complaining about the fact that we can use words that are used to demean us without it being as socially frowned upon is pretty **** trivial compared to the fact that in some places you might get murdered for being gay.
2. Hate crimes do not give black people special rights. Hate crime laws apply to people of any race. If you are attacked simply because you are white, your attacker could be charged with a hate crime.
However, more black people are victims of hate crimes than white people, so they benefit more from the laws. But notice that they only benefit more because they are targeted more. In other words, they're in a worse off position. The same thing applies to hate crimes based on religion (also protects Christians), nationality, gender (also protects men), sexual orientation (also protects straight people), etc. But as I said, we can take this to a new thread if you want to discuss it more.
Because as I said above, hate crimes are not what the discussion was about. The discussion was about why it was
socially (not legally) more acceptable for black people to say the n-word, while it is usually socially unacceptable for people of other races to do so.