Mario sells because it's the same, not dispite of it.
Golden Sun... I know the original team isn't coming back. Camelot barely had the budget for 2 games, much less 3. DD was only made because of widespread fan demand, and Camelot was burned-out from making the first two. Then they ultimately got burned when it undersold. A few years ago, Camelot had a petition going on if they should make GS4, and last I heard, it flopped pretty hard. Personally, I find the lack of integrity to making GS4 to be pathetic. I don't want people unsure if they want to make a game doing so, I want confidence. I want them to want to make the game.
By the same I meant many uninformed people consider Mario Kart, Mario Strikers and Mario Bros. to be "Just another" Mario game!
Yea, I wouldn't want Camelot to make another Golden Sun game against their will. Make it with confidence, make it with belief and make it with happiness. Seriously just give Golden Sun to another developer who is willing to reinvigorate the series, if they themselves do not believe they can or do not want to.
Camelot themselves did not have a petition going, it was a fan made petition and that kind of flopped considering many GS fans didn't even know about it!
Nintendo needs to take charge as in the end, the franchise and the characters are owned by them. Camelot just has the rights to game as the developers whereas the IP stands in Nintendo's realm. I want developers to make Golden Sun 4 with all of their hearts because the game will then turn out good, not half-baked!
A satisfying but late game is much better than a rushed and forced game in my opinion.