• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

TourneyPlay4 Melee Commentary Team discussion

Eggz

Smash Hero
Joined
Sep 16, 2005
Messages
8,277
Location
Combo Status Island
After the last TP having really ****in gay commentary for the most part (with exceptions from kira and noobking from what ive heard. **** you guys and your math though), I talked to GC Guy and I'll be helping him in forming the official TP4 commentary team for Melee.

I really doubt all of this will end up happening, but lets at least decide on 6 concrete commentators who we will 100% like to hear.
My goal here is numbers for TourneyPlay to be able to use to further increase numbers and add more money to the table. So if I seem a bit excessive with my elaboration of methods, just take it more as guidelines. Basically I'm really ****ing adamant about the vid side of tourneyplay4 not ****ing up.


So as far as Melee commentary goes, this is tentatively how I'd like to form things.
I want 4 or 5 people who can acknowledge that there needs to be a balance in the serious play-by-play/completely inattentive babble about nothing spectrum, as well as 1 or 2 joke fodder *****es who the other commentators can clown on (kline?) whenever they try to be clever in between matches.

*There will be 6 people officially on the team, and they pretty much run the booth as they see fit when they're on the job. There should be an active team of at least 2, but no more than 3 at a time, excluding any "guests" you want to bring in for a bit.

Active team runs the booth. You can invite guest commentators, swap out with whoever (make sure everyone else on the active team approves). Basically decide amongst yourselves who will have the majority of the duty during what time period. If you need a break, swap out. If you have a tournament match, swap out. But please just make sure not to overload the booth with people. Excessive chatter clogging the mic with noise could make people exit the stream.

*There are to be no more than 3 people in the commentary booth without consent of the majority of the active commentary team. But please be wise about who you let back there, and don't be afraid to kick anyone out or say no. Dr.Mario12 will need to go back there frequently to run the livestream itself, so keep that in mind.

*One of the active booth team needs to keep at least a semi-attentive eye on the livestream chat. ONLY boot people who are being spammy. Raw numbers are VERY important in attracting sponsors, so high numbers in the feed data will help aid that cause.

*Do NOT get caught up completely in the livestream chat and ignore the match. You are a commentator. Not a sissywagon *****fart. This happened on several occasions at TP3, though I'm sure people were tired.

*If you need liquor, weed, or energy drinks, and aren't noobking, ask me and I'll see what I can do. Just try to refrain from being too profane/blatant about it in the case of anyone official or nubile is watching. As long as you keep the livestream interesting and keep pulling people in, I don't care how you do it, and I won't beat your *** (vicariously through noobking and/or kage)


I nominate Noobking as an official commentator.

Thoughts anyone?
 

C!Z

Smash Lord
Joined
Sep 25, 2006
Messages
1,781
Location
Princeton, NJ
Listen to the matches I commentated on, the only one on your blog that I did though was you vs Kira. Decide if you listen to them, eh lol I know you probably won't.
 

KAOSTAR

the Ascended One
Joined
May 20, 2008
Messages
8,084
Location
The Wash: Lake City
aight If its for the team Im down.

but dont get too offensive as I am your equal and will kill you lol.

Also-TBH ciz, the macD noobking match I felt you did a poor job(i didnt see/hear any others). You just didnt seem all that into the match. But The last time we did commentary in oregon I thought you were alot better. I just think you need the right group with you and ppl wll laugh at **** you say.

Pick from these and should be fine

eggz ciz vish toph kaos rohins SW special canadian noobking
 

Kira-

Smash Champion
Joined
Nov 3, 2008
Messages
2,859
Location
Socal
imo

nobody wants "real" commentary. they just want to be entertained

you dont even have to talk about the match much, just say things here and there. we dont need to know that "marth missed the edgeguard so now he's getting ***** for it" we can all see that on the dam screen.

just talk **** about the players n stuff while you're watching the match, as long as you're still paying attention to the match and not completely ignoring it you're doing fine



for example, listening to Lucky talk on the norcal livestream for that SLO trip was the best because it made me pay attention. he'd mention when tigerbombz did something incredible or when lovage got fukd up or something, but he could just talk about pokemon and everyone on the livestream chat would respond because it was entertaining. that's all you really need from a smash commentator

so even though noobking did the "best" job commentating i dont think that's what people really want
 

debaser

Smash Lord
Joined
Mar 22, 2007
Messages
1,124
Location
Oregon
I love real commentary and I liked noobking's commentary.

Entertaining commentary is good sometimes too depending on the person (Waffles) but great commentators are both at the same time, like Wife, Sliq, Phil and Lucky for the brief time he commentated.

My favorite commentary ever was Mango commentating his match against Shroomed.

I'm really not picky about commentary, it's interesting enough just to hear the ambiance and different people's perspective and attitude, but I will say this: never let MacD and Sky commentate ever again. that just made me uncomfortable and sad.
 

Kira-

Smash Champion
Joined
Nov 3, 2008
Messages
2,859
Location
Socal
meh aright, i guess it's just my personal taste then

never let MacD and Sky commentate ever again. that just made me uncomfortable and sad.
loool get *****



edit - also i always thought the best commentator was ezynjay
 

MacD

Banned via Administration
Joined
Jun 28, 2007
Messages
6,891
Location
probably on a platform
uh oh, i screwed up or something

i know i get distracted and go off on random ****

though i do hate when all people say is what's going on, it's like i can see that and don't need you to tell me fox missed his upsmash out of shield or missed his tech
 

Eggz

Smash Hero
Joined
Sep 16, 2005
Messages
8,277
Location
Combo Status Island
imo

nobody wants "real" commentary. they just want to be entertained

you dont even have to talk about the match much, just say things here and there. we dont need to know that "marth missed the edgeguard so now he's getting ***** for it" we can all see that on the dam screen.

just talk **** about the players n stuff while you're watching the match, as long as you're still paying attention to the match and not completely ignoring it you're doing fine



for example, listening to Lucky talk on the norcal livestream for that SLO trip was the best because it made me pay attention. he'd mention when tigerbombz did something incredible or when lovage got fukd up or something, but he could just talk about pokemon and everyone on the livestream chat would respond because it was entertaining. that's all you really need from a smash commentator

so even though noobking did the "best" job commentating i dont think that's what people really want
i agree with you nearly 100%
noobking is pretty much the only playbyplay style commentator i really like, as he only points out the really tight **** and is excited about it, analyzes the players styles and the matchup history between them, etc.

i want like all OOS that come to be commentating doe
 

KAOSTAR

the Ascended One
Joined
May 20, 2008
Messages
8,084
Location
The Wash: Lake City
Well def just put noobking on the vip commentary list.

he does good ****. I watched the mm last night and I felt like he told me more than what happened.
 

Eggz

Smash Hero
Joined
Sep 16, 2005
Messages
8,277
Location
Combo Status Island
i clearly stated that i will pile people on the mic until spacial limitations are pushed in the form of knocking tables over

who from california is 100% coming?
 

Adam M!

Smash Lord
Joined
Aug 20, 2009
Messages
1,462
i'm 90%, 100 if someone would actually tell me how many setups / how well run the tournament was

but the more people are ***s about that, the less i care about actually going cuz i save money anyway
 

KAOSTAR

the Ascended One
Joined
May 20, 2008
Messages
8,084
Location
The Wash: Lake City
We had I think 20 setups but and it ran fine. We have access to an easy ten more if needed.

the venue was spacious and there was a nearby seattle center food court.

Didnt watch the brawl bracket but the melee bracket ran smoothly. We got thru it with no problems and werent crunched for time.

Also there was a decent amount of friendlys even tho the tvs were suppose to be all tourney.

Hangin out after and b4 tourneys in WA always ****. We kno how to party.
 

Adam M!

Smash Lord
Joined
Aug 20, 2009
Messages
1,462
now was that so hard lol

i hope GC is providing TVs or something cuz it looks like TP4 should be fairly bigger than TP3
 

Kira-

Smash Champion
Joined
Nov 3, 2008
Messages
2,859
Location
Socal
now was that so hard lol

i hope GC is providing TVs or something cuz it looks like TP4 should be fairly bigger than TP3
HOW CAN Y OU TELL


tp3 was **** but maybe moreso because we were out of state and we got to play pretty much whoever we wanted at any time. and smashing at vish's place whenever we weren't at the venue was SO legit, it was the perfect smashfest house. comfy couches, good places to sleep, plenty of seats, perfect amount of setups, amazing food within walking distance, chill people and good smashers

but the same thing applies to you so you'll be good
 

Adam M!

Smash Lord
Joined
Aug 20, 2009
Messages
1,462
***!

hey silent wolf / eggz tell me when it's okay to buy tickets
 

Eggz

Smash Hero
Joined
Sep 16, 2005
Messages
8,277
Location
Combo Status Island
yeah dates 100% confirmed, so getdat

GC has 10 TVs that he provides, and I think he rents a couple.
Then between us smashers we have like 30 that could be brought if I come down on people hard enough
 

Adam M!

Smash Lord
Joined
Aug 20, 2009
Messages
1,462
oh. i only mentioned it because i remember you making a post saying not to buy them for a month or so until the date's confirmed

so i'm assuming the date's now confirmed

didn't see eggz' post as i was posting
 

Eggz

Smash Hero
Joined
Sep 16, 2005
Messages
8,277
Location
Combo Status Island
If the venue (which said 100% we have it) somehow ****s us over, we have a fallback venue planned already, so no matter what its on vday weekend
 

Eggz

Smash Hero
Joined
Sep 16, 2005
Messages
8,277
Location
Combo Status Island
I'm pretty sure if we HAVE to fall back on GC, he would rent one of the neighboring things out for the weekend.

Thats just speculation, and this scenario is EXTREMELY unlikely, but just to make sure people know theres no reason not to buy tickets
 
Top Bottom