I personally love it. Contrary to popular opinion I loved SSE, it actually had a story! Sure it's repetitive and different but it's very much like some of the older Kirby games but with different characters. The cutscenes are amazing too and I was really surprised by the plot twist near the end. Plus if you're a perfectionist SSE will keep you busy for a LONG time.
As much as I thought it was dumb to have Fox, Falco AND Wolf I have found out, thankfully, that they are all different in their own ways. Sure their B-moves are SIMILAR but they're all different, and their A moves are fairly different as well. I'm glad they're not exact clones like some of the characters from SSBM.
As far as replay value goes whoever said there wasn't much obviously never saw the Challenges. Some of the ones I'm going to be working on for a while are beating Classic, All Star and 100-man brawl with all characters.
The stage builder is a cool idea but I felt very limited while creating my two stages (I unlocked all the extra parts). I wanted to have the same amount of stage building capabilities that went into all the other stages but oh well it's a pretty cool feature and I'm glad it's in there.
So all in all it's definitely the best game out for the Wii right now and I'm not disappointed at all with it. Let those who hate it hate it, they don't know what they're missing out on. I'm confident that Brawl will be more competitive AND fun than SSBM ever was.
Love,
Fox Makenshi