If you haven't read this, please do so. It's very important.
http://smashboards.com/showthread.php?t=128574
The three biggest mistakes made by new posters are: Posting their idea in the wrong room, posting spam, and posting something that already exists or is common knowledge. The moderators try their best to keep the boards clean of duplicate/unnecessary threads and keep an eye for spam posts.
I doubt you've made the first mistake, but regardless, I don't see much of a point to several of these topics, referring to "What if..." and "It should be like this..." topics. If I were a moderator, I would want to lock any and all "What if..." topics. Your "Status for each character" topic could probably be deduced by either simple guesswork or by searching the forum; just a couple of days ago there was a topic about what weight percentages sent people flying.
Things like your "Weak Link" are a little better, but they don't add really anything to the discussion. Basically, you're just asking a question, and letting it open up from there. I'd prefer to see a topic where it says "This is my opinion....[2 paragraphs later].... what do you think?" with lots of details and reasons, and maybe it'd be better under the Specific Character Link forum (although the way you asked it, it's better here).
- Recommendations for good threads
...
→ Finally, post a topic that people can actually discuss.
Just asking questions on this forum will not get you a good reputation. And furthermore, reputation DOES play a part on the internet; forums were made to get rid of anonymity. I now know your name, and if I see a topic with your name as the creator, I know what to expect.
