Realistic (i hope) roster

[PsychoIncarnate]

I'm pretty sure if Muddy Mole gets in, he's gonna be a AT...

Sakurai mentioned him once maybe being in the game but I don't think he said he was playable...People only assumed that because it was before AT's were announced.

 

[Cinder]

Yeah.....that's it!!!

*whistles and looks away*


EDIT:

Good idea. I may do it myself.

EDIT 2:

Nobody else do it. I actually am going to stupid quote sig myself. LOL

EDIT 3: Dogone you. Oh well....

Edit 4: (LOL) But you can't see it in yours.

Uhh...I can see it...the bottom's chopped off, but you can see the text...teehee

@Caael: yeah, I was wondering about Muddymole myself...and yeah, Isaac is better...

 

[hungrybum]

I tought Muddy Mole was underated and needed more representation, Isaac.... I don't know him so i did'nt know if i needed to add him... i'm just quite messed up i don't even know if he is golden sun or advance wars

 

[hungrybum]

I guess i will change muddy mole for isaac then since muddy mole has more chances of beeing an AT

 

[Caael]

Isaac had 2 mentions on the Poll as well.

 

[mario-man]

Uhh...I can see it...the bottom's chopped off, but you can see the text...teehee

I can't. How can you see it?

 

[pokemega32]

You STILL have Meowth instead of Mewtwo on there?

Why would Sakurai use an idiot anime villain, when there's Mewtwo?

 

[Cinder]

I can't. How can you see it?

Different computer sizes? IDK, all I know is that I see it...not sure why you can't...I'm not that tech-saavy...

@Pokemega: Mewtwo > Meowth, like you said...just reiterating it...why do people want Meowth, anyway?

 

[hungrybum]

There are both in on my list, meowth just as the priority cuz mewtwo could be replaced by gardevoir or worse darkrai

 

[mario-man]

@ Cinder

What's your resolution set to??

 

[Cinder]

@ Cinder

What's your resolution set to??

1024x768, but I'm using a small flat-screen TV as a monitor (maybe 18-24 inches?)

 

[BigRick]

I'm sorry but this roster is far from being realistic.

For example, you talk about Black Shadow when you already seen that Samurai Goroh didn't make the cut.

 

[Cinder]

There are both in on my list, meowth just as the priority cuz mewtwo could be replaced by gardevoir or worse darkrai

I restate my question: why do people want Meowth? And I don't think M2's goin' anywhere...they're gonna improve it...big time...

 

[mario-man]

1024x768, but I'm using a small flat-screen TV as a monitor (maybe 18-24 inches?)

Funny, that's what mine is set to.....WTC is goin on here?!?!
_____________________________________________________


That's the guy I was thinking of....Samurai Goroh!!! Not C. Olimar....S. Goroh. I'm so proud of myself. LOL

 

[thejbr12]

I'm sorry but this roster is far from being realistic.

For example, you talk about Black Shadow when you already seen that Samurai Goroh didn't make the cut.

So if Kraid isn't in then Ridley can't be? And since Andross is an AT, Wolf is out?

And this roster is very realistic because it's so short. He takes barely any risks and, if anything, will be wrong because extra characters will get in.

There will almost surely be at least one more representitive from Starfox.

 

[MysticKenji]

Once again...

MEWTWO > MEOWTH

Also, where's Shiek and Zamus???

 

[CORRUPTiON]

If pac man gets in, I'm not buying the game.

 

[thejbr12]

If pac man gets in, I'm not buying the game.

Really? If my neighbor's dog (whom I really don't like) got in I'd still buy it!

 

[BigRick]

So if Kraid isn't in then Ridley can't be? And since Andross is an AT, Wolf is out?

And this roster is very realistic because it's so short. He takes barely any risks and, if anything, will be wrong because extra characters will get in.

There will almost surely be at least one more representitive from Starfox.

Bad examples buddy. From the character polls, Ridley is more popular than Kraid and Wolf is more popular than Andross.

Taking no risks? lol

- Geno is risky cause he belongs to Squaresoft even though he was in a Mario game... he's like a 2nd and a half party character

- Paper Mario is also a risky choice, got nothing against the idea though

- Then he's thinking about Vaati being in the game, while he already has 4 other Zelda chars

- He also adds Meowth, but he isn't that important and he didn't even make the cut in melee... Moreover, a new pokémon char, Pokémon Trainer has already been added to the game. Lucario has chances cause he's very popular but it's still a risky choice

- The Mother situation is very complicated, so I don't think that Sakurai will cut Ness so that the Smash vets don't get mad. He might add 1 other character and it has more chances to be Lucas because he's the protagonist.

- Krystal is another risky move. Sakurai might simply stick with Fox and Falco.

- Your putting in King K. Rool, but also King Dedede... they kinda share the ''evil king'' gimmick so it's risky to have em both

- Then there's Black Shadow and Pico... Goroh was the most popular F-zero char suggestion after Falcon and ended up as an AT.

- Animal Crossing generic human? Very risky... because he has no character! You might say the same for Pokémon Trainer, but you don't play as him, you play as the Pokémon.

- More than 2 FE characters is also taking a risk.

- Talking about Pac Man or Megaman making in the game is also taking a risk, the number of 3rd parties hasn't been confirmed yet.

 

[Cinder]

If pac man gets in, I'm not buying the game.

Whoa...don't you think that's a little extreme? True, even President Bush is more likely than Pac-Man, but not buying Brawl over it? Besides, we may not even know until it's too late...and I don't want Pichu, big deal...if it's in...well *runs hand along knife* Sakurai's gonna regret it, especially if Lucario's sacrificed...but I'll still play...

 

[nobletoast]

I do really like that roster. I would take out a fire emblem character and add a swordsman who brings a real different flavour to smash and representing a new franchise....Isaac. Ray 01 would be nice to add as well. Pico over Black Shadow anyday.

As for Pacman or MegaMan i think it will be mega man. I prefer pacman but i dont rate his chances...it a win win situation there.

Geno over paper Mario as well.

I'd rate this roster around 8.5/10 for Lip and 3 Fire Emblem characters over newer franchises such as Custom Robo and Golden Sun.

Edit: I moronicaly skim read the pokemon section and misread Meowth think it was Mewtwo. I think this warrants to lower the score to 8/10. I hardly hate the charater but Mewtwo is more important, popular, has an established fanbase with smashers and moveset that with a little tweeking would play really well.

 

[hungrybum]

Should i delete pac-man or not? I know that he is iconic but he would'nt be suitable for a fighting game and for the King Dedede and K.Rool argument one thing... King Dedede is the SELF-proclaimed king of dreamland while K.Rool is not only a king but also a pirate + K.Rool has voluntary followers unlike Dedede. For Meowth and Mewtwo I think that both will get in but Mewtwo isn't guarenteed until Gardevoir and/or Darkrai are confirmed not beeing playable since they are both psychic/dark pokemon. Krystal is a new representative of the star fox series and has a lot of chances since people now want more female characters. For Geno I say you are right, he is some kind of weird 2nd party character but i still think he'll make it cuz its outstanding popularity. For LoZ characters you say that 4 characters is enough but its was important enough to have 4 representatives in melee so why not one more for brawl.

 

[hungrybum]

I'd rate this roster around 8.5/10 for Lip and 3 Fire Emblem characters over newer franchises such as Custom Robo and Golden Sun.
.

also... Isaac was already in the roster in the other section

 

[nobletoast]

If K Rool and Deedee both being kings is grounds to remove on then so is removing Diddy and Donkey for both being monkeys and Link and Ike for both being swordsman.

Being a king isnt a very specific thing to a character...unlike for example being a young boy with a stripy jumper with psi powers and originating from the same franchise*. Both them being kings isnt a legitimate argument for removing K Rool or DeeDee. And isnt Bowser also king of the koopas? Not sure myself.



*im open to the idea of both Ness and Lucas if they were vastly different in the way they played and wasnt having a 'diss' at the mother/earthbound franchise

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

King Koopa anyone?

 

[thejbr12]

Bad examples buddy. From the character polls, Ridley is more popular than Kraid and Wolf is more popular than Andross.

Taking no risks? lol

- Geno is risky cause he belongs to Squaresoft even though he was in a Mario game... he's like a 2nd and a half party character

- Paper Mario is also a risky choice, got nothing against the idea though

- Then he's thinking about Vaati being in the game, while he already has 4 other Zelda chars

- He also adds Meowth, but he isn't that important and he didn't even make the cut in melee... Moreover, a new pokémon char, Pokémon Trainer has already been added to the game. Lucario has chances cause he's very popular but it's still a risky choice

- The Mother situation is very complicated, so I don't think that Sakurai will cut Ness so that the Smash vets don't get mad. He might add 1 other character and it has more chances to be Lucas because he's the protagonist.

- Krystal is another risky move. Sakurai might simply stick with Fox and Falco.

- Your putting in King K. Rool, but also King Dedede... they kinda share the ''evil king'' gimmick so it's risky to have em both

- Then there's Black Shadow and Pico... Goroh was the most popular F-zero char suggestion after Falcon and ended up as an AT.

- Animal Crossing generic human? Very risky... because he has no character! You might say the same for Pokémon Trainer, but you don't play as him, you play as the Pokémon.

- More than 2 FE characters is also taking a risk.

- Talking about Pac Man or Megaman making in the game is also taking a risk, the number of 3rd parties hasn't been confirmed yet.

Wow, I'll tell ya, I read your post and I couldn't figure out what I had done. Then I realized, I got this thread mixed up with GamingBoy's predictions http://smashboards.com/showthread.php?t=118500&page=2

You see, I was flipping back and forth between the two and I guess I got confused. So yeah, BigRick, I agree with most of what you said, lol. Thanks for putting me in my place, haha. You're right, a lot of this list is risky, especially the length (GamingBoy's is only 36 which, while very short, takes no risks because there are no characters on there with any less than, say, a 90% chance).

One thing I still disagree with you on is Black Shadow. My examples of Ridley and Wolf were to point out that Black Shadow is not out of Brawl because Goroh is an AT. I don’t even think Goroh was on the poll, whereas Shadow was http://smashboards.com/showthread.php?t=71872

Sorry for wasting your time before with that whole "risky" thing...

 

[Enigma14]

You know what sucks? when everyone just bashes a thread just because their character isn't on it. IF EVERYONE'S WANTED character(s) was there, there would be like 100 PC slots!