Wonder Red
Popularity: A bit early to say, but the sales figures have been disappointing. Wonderful 101 got some decent promotion and the game got pretty good reviews, but if nobody plays it that probably doesn't matter.
Design: Well... I guess it's a little like Pikmin? If they want to represent the game play that way. It's not the easiest to implement at any rate.
3rd party: He's not a Nintendo-owned character, and we know not just any 3rd party gets in. Wonder Red up there with giants like Sonic and Mega Man, and perhaps Pac-Man? Doesn't seem right to me.
Marketing: I feel like if he were going to be in the game, they would've revealed him by now to help hype the game. They want the game to sell. It was one of the "big titles" coming out in the second half of 2013, following Pikmin 3. Helping to boost its sales would help the Wii U and it needs it. I think secrecy about the roster would lose out to marketing in this case. He doesn't even have to be ready to be shown in playable form - he'd just need screen shots and a trailer.
It's pretty clear that the roster reveals are being used as part of Nintendo's marketing* so Wonder Red not being revealed back in September basically rules him out for me.
Wonder Red chances: 0.5%
Wonder Red want: 30%
Meh, I'd rather see plenty of other 3rd parties. I played the demo and I couldn't really get into it.
Oh... I need to say more?
Ridley
I'm just going to talk about what has changed.
In my opinion... nothing much really. I don't see why people think the Pyrosphere matters so much for Ridley. What does the Pyrosphere tell us that we didn't already know?
- The Metroid series in Smash will be taking many of its cues from Other M. Wait, we already knew that because of Samus's new look. As of yet the Other M influence has not been shown to be more than superficial, however.
- There will be a stage in a setting that's associated with Ridley. Many important places in Metroid are associated with Ridley. Norfair was Ridley's turf too. This doesn't tell us that Ridley's a stage hazard or a boss or playable. What I would assume, however, is that if Ridley was playable, his "home stage" would definitely be the Pyrosphere.
- Sakurai did make a comment about Samus seeing an old enemy at any time. It's doubtful he was referring to anyone but Ridley, given the setting. But it's still a pretty vague statement. If Ridley were playable, he could make that statement. If Ridley were a boss and you fought him on the Pyrosphere (which is possible), he could make that statement. If Ridley were a stage hazard, he could make that statement. If Ridley were not in the game at all, he could make that statement (just "setting the mood" about the Pyrosphere, rather than hinting at anything).
- I will concede, however, that the statement is more consistent with two of those things: Ridley being a stage hazard and Ridley being a playable character. It definitely is the least likely that Ridley's not in the game at all.
There has also been some less Metroid specific information. Namely, I'm a little bit more optimistic about the roster size given the pace of character reveals. This doesn't affect any single character by a large amount though.
In the end, I rate him about where I did last time.
Ridley chances: 71%
Ridley want: 100%
Duh.
Sukapon prediction: 1.7%
It'll be... low. I'm just throwing a number out randomly.
Nominations:
Sheik x5
*I know, we didn't get a Pokemon yet this week. However:
1. There are still two more screenshots this week. I don't think anyone will say it doesn't count as part of the pattern if a Pokemon is revealed this week, or even next week.
2. Just because it's being used for marketing doesn't mean that they HAVE to use it. Even if we don't see a Pokemon reveal this month, that doesn't mean it was wrong to think it was more likely to happen. The reveals for Olimar, Luigi, Toon Link and Sonic being so close to the releases of Pikmin 3, Mario & Luigi: Dream Team, Wind Waker HD, and Sonic: Lost Worlds can hardly be dismissed as a coincidence. The timing has some flexibility there as well (as seen with Sonic).
Point is: Sakurai not being
perfectly predictable =/= OMG SAKURAI IS SOOO UNPREDICTABLE