Pick 1 Starter Veteran, 1 Starter Newcomer, 1 Secret Veteran, and 1 Secret Newcomer

[Forget Me Not]

Starter Vet - Mario
Starter Newcomer - Olimar & Pikmin
Secret Vet - Ness
Secret Newcomer - R.O.B.

 

[F@lc0-san]

Starter Veteran: Mario
Starter Newcomer: Pokemon Trainer
Secret Veteran: Toon Link(He's basicley Young Link with a new model so)
Secret Newcomer: Wolf

 

[mas369]

Starter Veteran: Link (Old Melee main, One of my favorite video game characters)
Starter Newcomer: Ike (Great Ether sold me)
Secret Veteran: Marth (Current Melee main)
Secret Newcomer: R.O.B. (I hate myself)

 

[Someguy13]

Starter veteran: Sheik
Starter Newcomer: Pit
Secret veteran: Falco
Secret Newcomer: Sonic

 

[SuupahRyu]

Starter Veteran: Kirby
Starter Newcomer: Lucas
Secret Veteran: Ness
Secret Newcomer: Wolf

 

[Andromeda]

Starter Veteran: Fox
Starter Newcomer: Lucas
Secret Veteran: Falco
Secret Newcomer: Lucario

 

[thisismatt]

Really hard...

These are impulse picks, and I really didn't put too much thought into them, they're just what I think from what I can remember seeing from them.

Starter Vet - Kirby
Starter Newcomer - Pit
Hidden Vet - Ness
Hidden Newcomer - Solid Snake

 

[m3cadet]

Ice Climbers
Pokemon Trainer
Jigglypuff
Snake

 

[drengist]

Starter veteran: Fox
Starter newcomer: PT
Secret veteran: Marth
Secret newcomer: Wolf

 

[Aesk]

Starter Veteran: Bowser
Starter Newcomer: Diddy Kong
Secret Veteran: Falco
Secret Newcomer: Sonic

 

[Phoenix_Dark]

Starter veteran: Zelda
Starter newcomer: Zero Suit Samus
Secret veteran: Marth
Secret newcomer: Sonic

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

Starter Veteran: Samus
Starter Newcomer: King Dedede
Secret Veteran: Ness
Secret Newcomer: R.O.B.

...or something

 

[Zoolander]

Starting Veteran - Samus
Starting Newcomer - Diddy Kong
Hidden Veteran - Luigi
Hidden Newcomer - Snake

 

[captainfalcon_rulez]

Starter Veteran: Mario
Starter Newcomer: Ike/Pokemon Trainer
Secret Veteran:Captain Falcon
Secret Newcomer: Lucario/Wolf

 

[relaxedexcorcist]

Starter Veteran: Samus
Starter Newcomer: Pit
Secret Veteran: Marth/Luigi (I don't like the hidden veterans that much)
Secret Newcomer: Sonic

 

[ARX-7 Arbalest]

Starting Vet: Link
Starting Newcomer: Ike
Secret Vet: Captain Falcon
Secret Newcomer: Lucario

 

[A Link to the Snitch]

Kirby
Wario
Captain Falcon
Toon Link

 

[FlyinG ShoosteR]

hmmm...

starting vet: Fox
starting new: King Dedede
secret vet: Luigi
secret new: Lucario

 

[The Burrito of Time]

Starter Veteran: Link
Starter Newcomer: Ike
Secret Veteran: Marth
Secret Newcomer: Toon Link

 

[A Link to the Snitch]

Scratch that, Ness over Captain Falcon.

 

[TheLastHero]

Starter Veteran: Samus
Starter Newcomer: Olimar
Secret Veteran: Ganondorf
Secret Newcomer: Snake

Very awesome. =]