1) Eggz
2) Juce
3) Jonny
4/5) Foos/Ratking
6) Ryan
7) Cat
8) Binx
9) Alien
10) Brick
Mine is pretty similar to Allen's. Prior to Manifest I was gonna end up giving Jonny 2, but then that Eugene tournament Jesse got 2nd, and Manifest he was the highest placing non-Eggz Oregonian; Jesse stepped it up back to his normal self so I went with him; while Jonny kinda pooped the bed at Manifest.
Me and Foos is close in my eyes. Ultimately doesn't matter. Over the last month I beat him the times we have faced each other in tournament. We had the same results at manifest, generally lose to similar people in Oregon (I think he beats Jonny and I don't, but I beat him.).
Putting Ryan at 6 for the time being, he might be getting switched to 7. Generally over the last month, and especially at Manifest though, he REALLY impressed me. Really stoked on how good he is getting, and hope he doesn't quit when Jonny does (seeing as they mostly play together or whatever.).
Keeping Cat where I had him in my pre-Manifest list. He didn't make it out of pools, while 2/3 people below him did. His results have been really pretty solid the last month though. Also he has been working really hard for his final placement on the Oregon PR, He was in attendance at all tournaments in this update period, and wont become inactive until the next update, so I am leaving him on, despite him leaving this week.
Binx is 8, there was only 1 Oregon tournament he has results from in the period, and they weren't outstanding. He obviously is still a good player, but he's gotta come through when it counts. Also not breaking pools didn't help show anything else to base his placement on. I think with what he has had to offer in terms of results, 8 is a pretty generous placement.
Allen at 9. Not a lot to say on that. I think it is pretty fair despite all things. Allen did well at Manifest, I think he just needs to get more consistent, and show up more in Oregon, and he will go up for sure.
It was a toss up between Brick and Bird for the 10 spot. I actually wanted to place Brick even higher, but had trouble Justifying it. I think if he shows up though next update period, he will skyrocket if he keeps this **** up. There was a million reasons I wanted to place him higher than 10, but I had a hard time making that judgement call. I think Bird is a better player technically at this point than Brick, and possibly has a better understanding of the game (whatever the **** that means.), but Brick has been able to play his character completely to his advantage, ****ing up, and coming close to ****ing up, most of the players in the 1-5 spots at some point in time. Bird hasn't really come close to accomplishing some of the **** Brick has, even though from playing them both, I feel like Bird has a better handle on the game than Brick, Brick has the results to say otherwise.
I will post more detailed argument probably later. I really don't even want to think about melee until the next tournament though. the last 2 months, and then this weekend have burned me the **** out. Break time is needed to reflect on all I have learned.