+/- Of Brawl

[Goopygoo]

+R.O.B.
+Soundtrack
+SSE
+Final Smashes
+Stage Builder

-New Target Test >:L

 

[metahunter]

BEST
-SSE
-35+ charectors
-varaity of new playing styles (PT,olemer,snake)
-stage creator
-online play
-co-op on every thing

WORST
-not 40+ charectors
-slowed down gameplay
-no board the platforms
-only 5 target tests
-no bowser jr

 

[Scicky]

+Almost everything

-No Geno
-Mewtwo being gone

 

[JustKindaBoredUKno]

+ Lucario. I've wanted him since day one.
+ the amazing music.
+ online play (good only because of accessibility to friends further away)
+ sse (they needed a more advanced storyline)
+ final smashes

- the ending of sse
- many popular requested characters not getting PC spots
- sonic's role in sse (mario+ sonic fight scene... who wouldn't have loved that?)
- online play (in that wi-fi isn't all too reliable... and has caused us this much delay because of it)
- more floaty. Now, i in no way shape or form want melee 2.0 but i would have preffered a faster pace is all

 

[retro gamer 6]

+ sides of brawl

1. kirby's buffed :D
2. co-op modes in 1 player mode
3. final smashes
4. online battles
5. balanced gameplay

- sides of brawl

1. the 35 character roster. it should've been 40 to 45.
2. no isaac
3. clones like marth, falco , and jigglypuff are back. WE DON'T NEED THEM! >
4. marth isn't nerfed enough.
5. some most wanted characters didn't make it. darn you sakurai!

its still a great game, but it could've been better. lets hope for a SSB4.

 

[J0™]

+Roster
+Music
+Online
+Game&Watch is back
+Cool 1-player additions

-EU release date (and the lack of it)
-EU release date (and the lack of it)
-EU release date (and the lack of it)
-EU release date (and the lack of it)
-No Steven Seagal D:

 

[MysticKenji]

stuff

Marth and Jiggs aren't clones >_<

 

[The Overlord]

+ Third Party Characters (Sonic & Snake)
+ SSE
+ My Music (And all the music in it)
+ Stage Builder
+ Assist Trophies

- Delays, delays, and more delays
- Less than 36 PC's
- Features like Masterpieces taking up time of development, resulting in less PC's
- Mewtwo not being a PC
- Bonsly

 

[Flaming_Wuzzle]

+ More interesting characters
The inclusion of characters like Olimar, Snake, and Pokemon Trainer, since they don't really do all of their fighting directly, definitely makes for something different from what we had in Melee.

+ Soundtrack
280+ tracks, and a lot of it is good, at the very least.

+ Bigger, more involved single-player
It may not be the incredibly epic story that some people were hoping for, but I'm glad there's an actual plot now, and that you can't just sit down and go through the Adventure mode like you could before.

+ Stage Builder
Anyone that complains that the stages aren't good enough, time to make your own. Granted, you can't do anything as creative as WarioWare or Pictochat, but actually being able to create stages now is nice.


-/+ ROB's inclusion
A lot of you don't like him. I was like that, thinking "Why did they put ROB on the roster? He's gonna suck...", but then I actually saw him in action, and now I feel differently about him.

-/+ 35 characters
While I wanted to see a bigger roster than that (around 40-45), 35 is nice too.


- Cloned Final Smashes
Was it too much to ask to have some sort of difference other than "oh this Landmaster isn't there as long but it's more powerful"? I mean, Wolf could have summoned the Wolfens to fire on the stage for a bit, a la the second part of the Corneria stage in Melee's Adventure mode, but more powerful and focused.

- Would have liked to see Sukapon on the roster
Some sort of nod to Nintendo's first try at a fighting game other than a sticker, preferably a playable character.

- Toon Link is a clone of Link
While it would have been foolish to think he WOULDN'T be a clone of Link in some form (seeing as they are different forms of the same character), I also expected Toon Link to have things from Wind Waker/Phantom Hourglass like the Deku Leaf.

 

[Zevox]

+ Subspace Emissary
+ Stage Builder
+ Newcomers (sans Wolf & Toon Link)
+ Sonic! (Yes, this statement is redundant with the third in this list, and that is intentional.)
+ Soundtrack (Holy **** that thing is huge!)

(Runner ups: Assist Trophies, Final Smashes, Wifi.)

- Return of clones (especially Ganondorf).
- Toon Link (redundant w/ Link) & Wolf (hate the character, wanted Krystal instead).
- Luigified clones have same Final Smash when they could easily have had different ones.
- Mewtwo's exclusion.
- Target Test reduced to 5 stages rather than being character-specific.

(Runner ups: Lack of Mega Man, could have used more past stages.)