DarthEnderX
Smash Hero
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2014
- Messages
- 8,541
Playing it now. The voting pisses me off.One thing about Square, they did a nice job on Triangle Strategy, anyone here played it?
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Playing it now. The voting pisses me off.One thing about Square, they did a nice job on Triangle Strategy, anyone here played it?
They may just simply not be in high demand.there is something i am curious about i remember sakurai stated he didnt Takamaru and Ayumi due to them being japanese exclusive characters but now that its no longer the case why they havent been added yet?
I guess Shovel Knight and Cuphead.Which indie characters may have another chance to become a fighter?
Well Ayumi's has already been said, it was that she was specifically considered for the retro spot for Melee, which is no longer an allocated spot on rosters. Like if ICs weren't added when they were added, there's a good chance we wouldn't have them at all. And a remake that sounds like it, unfortunately, didn't do all that great will probably also fall short of moving the needle a requisite amount for playability. But if she gets an actual new game she's in a good spot.there is something i am curious about i remember sakurai stated he didnt Takamaru and Ayumi due to them being japanese exclusive characters but now that its no longer the case why they havent been added yet?
Well if Ayumi was in Melee it would've been the retro spot, that was what Sakurai was referring to. And that spot was for an original character.On that note; I was thinking that if Ayumi was in Melee, she’d be a semi-clone using Peach and Zelda’s moves.
I think all the ones currently in the game have a shot, though some have better odds than others. Other than Sakuna, who was fortunate to get attention. Some people will raise Touhou, and I think the chances for that are overrated, but it's certainly not inconceivable.Which indie characters may have another chance to become a fighter?
I've done this for you, because I have nothing better to do. The results are surprising, as I feel like we have mostly exhausted the list already, with most of the franchises being already represented, and the others being games that don't exactly match up with a good character to work with, unless the sound of the game "GOLF" sounds worthy of a character slot. I'm skipping all but two of those generic sports games, but the rest are the list of games with no playable character in Smash listed as being published by Nintendo, in order from most sales to least:A good exercise is to sift through Wikipedia's list of best-selling NES games, crossing out all third parties and games/series already repped by PCs in Smash, and then seeing what's left (with the reminder that sales charts should be taken with a grain of salt and aren't the only thing to consider of course).
Yeah I've looked through all of these lists myself, but haven't taken the time to write it all out. I would definitely be interested to see the handhelds, but don't feel obligated of course. The handhelds do hold some interesting items like Golden Sun, Rhythm Heaven, Nintendogs, and more, so you might have fun with it.I've done this for you, because I have nothing better to do. The results are surprising, as I feel like we have mostly exhausted the list already, with most of the franchises being already represented, and the others being games that don't exactly match up with a good character to work with, unless the sound of the game "GOLF" sounds worthy of a character slot. I'm skipping all but two of those generic sports games, but the rest are the list of games with no playable character in Smash listed as being published by Nintendo, in order from most sales to least:
1 - Tetris
2 - Exitebike
3 - Kung-Fu (NOTE: Game is a port of Kung-Fu Master, a game Nintendo did not orignally make)
4 - Ice Hockey
5 - Pro Wrestling
6 - R.C. Pro-Arm (NOTE: Was developed by Rare)
7 - F-1 Race (NOTE: Was developed by HAL Labs)
8 - Popeye
That's it, as far as the NES goes. The only ones left are an Exitebiker, an Ice Hockey player, or one of the Pro Wrestler characters.
Because I have even more time, I think I'll do the rest of the home consoles. Moving to the SNES:
1 - Killer Instinct (NOTE: Was developed by Rare)
2 - Super Mario RPG
3 - Pilotwings
4 - SimCity (I know this is technically third party, but we still got an assist trophy of one of the guys from here, so...)
5 - Super Scope 6
6 - Derby Stalion (NOTE: Was made by ASCII Corporation, which is not afflicted with Nintendo)
So, yeah, not much left here either. Only Pilotwings and Super Scope 6 are real contenders, unless they are willing to let Dr. Wright free from his Assist Trophy status (not likely), Super scope 6 also has a problem of basically not having any characters, unless they use the announcer lady who relayed instructions to you from a side-screen.
Continuing onto the N64, and wow, did Nintendo publish a lot of licened content here. There's two freakin' Star Wars games here, for crying out loud. I'm getting rid of those this time around, leaving us with:
1 - Wave Race 64
2 - 1080° Snowboarding
3 - Exitebike 64
4 - Cruis'n USA (Note: Was a port of a joint colab with Midway Games)
5 - F-1 World Grand Prix (Note: Developed by Paradigm Entertainment, not assoscated with Nintendo otherwise)
For the GameCube, we already exhausted the list. The only game that Nintendo published that isn't playable in Smash, if you want to be technical, is Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles, which might count if Cloud does it for you.
Going into the Wii, the only thing left is Big Brain Academy: Wii Degree, if you are willing to let the Miis represent an asortment of "Wii" games like Wii Sports and Wii Play.
For the WiiU, the only games remaining are Nintendo Land, and Lego City Undercover, which hopefully I don't have to tell you about.
For those with eyes for the future, here's the Switch results:
1 - Ring Fit Adventure
2 - 1-2 Switch
3 - Clubhouse Games: 51 Worldwide Classics
4 - Miitopia (Maybe covered by Miis)
5 - Nintendo Labo Toy-Con 01: Variety Kit
6 - Big Brain Academy: Brain vs. Brain
7 - Astral Chain
8 - Marvel Ultimate Alliance 3: The Black Order (Hopefully, I don't have to explain why this isn't good)
9 - Game Builder Garage
That's it for home consoles. If you want this sort of thing for handhelds, let me know and I'll find the time.
Despite how much of a dumpster fire Balan Wonderworld ended up being, I nevertheless like Balan's design. I am kinda hoping that the IP doesn't get written off completely as a result of this setback (if Squenix could revive Final Fantasy XIV, I don't see why not).The problem is that Naka has had such a history of dubious behavior (just look up how he acted during Sonic X-Treme's development) that even with Square Enix's recent string of PR incompetence, it still feels more likely that the latter is the more innocent party in all this.
Yeah, the failure of Balan Wonderworld is somewhat rooted in SE not really understanding the appeal of platformers, but most of it lies in Naka's outdated instincts and stubborn refusal to embrace any sort of genuine complexity in his game design.
As others have pointed out, Nintendo first-party properties have the advantage. Could Hatsune Miku or Clippy qualify? Maybe. But it seems far unlikely that they'd be considered.i dont see the problem with the addition of Visual Novel, Virtual Pet, Hatsune Miku and Clippy from Microsoft.
i do think what defines something as being video game is:
being a playable electronic program + being a form of entertainment
also the fact that we did have Pictochat and Miiverse stages and Mario Paint and Vince assist trophies shows that these kind of contents dont break the rules.
You sure about that? I'm not seeing him. Maybe you got him mixed up with StarTropics being listed in the Chronicle (which still go un-referenced in the Japanese version due to Brawl's Chronicles being region-based).Mike jones at least was a sticker on brawl
I mean, for whatever it's worth, Kid Icarus: Of Myths and Monsters did eventually come to the Japanese 3DS's Virtual Console (after Brawl, granted), so it's not like past America-only releases couldn't come to Japan. However, I guess Japan's never seeing StarTropics for much the same reason that America's never seeing the older Fire Emblem games: StarTropics is a text-heavy game, and Nintendo doesn't seem all that willing to devote resources towards editing and localizing decades-old roms (unless it's a limited release of the first Fire Emblem..... for whatever sick reason).It's more like they don't want to completely alienate their home audience by acknowledging games that were never published in Japan. Likewise they sure as hell aren't gonna reference Captain N when it never even aired in Japan lol
The only real exceptions are like, Elite Beat Agents, and the Kid Icarus Of Myths and Monsters sticker in Brawl. But both of those are attached to IPs that do have a Japanese presence anyways.
For what it's worth, Takamaru did stop being a Japan-only character well before Smash4 or the WiiU Virtual Console. He was featured in Samurai Warriors 3, not just as a playable character, but also having his own game mode that essentially remade The Mysterious Murasame Castle (incidentally, this would be yet another instance of Nintendo letting Koei Tecmo use their IPs, maybe the earliest of what would eventually be many).Same with Takamaru, new game-wise. As it stands, Takamaru is probably a case of a VC release not being high-profile enough to satisfy the actual concerns Sakurai had, which was a lack of familiarity with the character/series.
I've been to Japan. Trust me, the sheer reach that Touhou has in Nintendo's homeland can not be exaggerated (and having an overseas presence can only help).Some people will raise Touhou, and I think the chances for that are overrated, but it's certainly not inconceivable.
What? You don't think golfer in red shirt and black pants who vaguely resembles Mario wouldn't make an awesome Smash Fighter? XDThe results are surprising, as I feel like we have mostly exhausted the list already, with most of the franchises being already represented, and the others being games that don't exactly match up with a good character to work with, unless the sound of the game "GOLF" sounds worthy of a character slot.
Dr. Wright, while alluding to SimCity's creator Will Wright, seems to nevertheless be Nintendo's own original character. This is likely why he can even appear in Smash as an Assist Trophy (though even if he were to become a playable character, I guess the bigger issue would be what could be done for a home stage..... or hell, any amount of series content that wouldn't leave Wright envious of ROB).1 - Killer Instinct (NOTE: Was developed by Rare)
2 - Super Mario RPG
3 - Pilotwings
4 - SimCity (I know this is technically third party, but we still got an assist trophy of one of the guys from here, so...)
5 - Super Scope 6
6 - Derby Stalion (NOTE: Was made by ASCII Corporation, which is not afflicted with Nintendo)
So, yeah, not much left here either. Only Pilotwings and Super Scope 6 are real contenders, unless they are willing to let Dr. Wright free from his Assist Trophy status (not likely), Super scope 6 also has a problem of basically not having any characters, unless they use the announcer lady who relayed instructions to you from a side-screen.
nah. this last smash cycle has made it pretty clear that sakurai doesnt get to go behind the scenes for all games. botw, odyssey, 3 houses? sure. xb2 and arms? nope.pretty sure sakurai is aware of the games that has yet to be announced way before any of us
I think Reimu would be the most likely due to long history and popularity in japan and still has worldwide audience.Which indie characters may have another chance to become a fighter?
It's very easy to convince your party members howeverPlaying it now. The voting pisses me off.
A Nintendo fighter game that isn't Smash but more akin to a tradional fighting game would cover pretty much this. Think Pokken, but not limited to only Pokemon.
LOL!
This is pretty funny but actually I could get behind a Tekken x Nintendo fighter.
I did not find that to be the case. I was forced down a story branch I absolutely did NOT want to take because I was completely unable to get even a single person to change their vote.It's very easy to convince your party members however
Kung-Fu and Popeye of course being 4th party titles.I've done this for you, because I have nothing better to do. The results are surprising, as I feel like we have mostly exhausted the list already, with most of the franchises being already represented, and the others being games that don't exactly match up with a good character to work with, unless the sound of the game "GOLF" sounds worthy of a character slot. I'm skipping all but two of those generic sports games, but the rest are the list of games with no playable character in Smash listed as being published by Nintendo, in order from most sales to least:
1 - Tetris
2 - Exitebike
3 - Kung-Fu (NOTE: Game is a port of Kung-Fu Master, a game Nintendo did not orignally make)
4 - Ice Hockey
5 - Pro Wrestling
6 - R.C. Pro-Arm (NOTE: Was developed by Rare)
7 - F-1 Race (NOTE: Was developed by HAL Labs)
8 - Popeye
They literally just announced a new Kunio game:I know Double Dragon is fairly more known by western gamers, but the River City/Kunio has more legacy (The spirit event says much).
You can sometimes walk around the area outside to gain extra information from villagers and soldiers to gain your allies' favor. The game kinda tells you so, but the pacing can be quite slow in the story telling so yeah, I imagine most are just happy to actually play when those phases happen.I did not find that to be the case. I was forced down a story branch I absolutely did NOT want to take because I was completely unable to get even a single person to change their vote.
Warner Bros. Discovery is reportedly interested in selling its gaming studios and IP licenses. Xbox, Sony, and EA are supposedly among the handful interested in making a deal. https://t.co/JPczMIazg9 pic.twitter.com/m5f6YKufYz
— ComicBook.com (@ComicBook) April 29, 2022
Here is a question if we do get a horror rep would you prefer it being the villain who is suppose to be the horror or the protagonist of the game?
Tbh I think Pyramid Head and Nemesis do Better job at representing a horror character than the protagonist of the games.
I'm aware, but clearly that doesn't seem to count, which is understandable.For what it's worth, Takamaru did stop being a Japan-only character well before Smash4 or the WiiU Virtual Console. He was featured in Samurai Warriors 3, not just as a playable character, but also having his own game mode that essentially remade The Mysterious Murasame Castle (incidentally, this would be yet another instance of Nintendo letting Koei Tecmo use their IPs, maybe the earliest of what would eventually be many).
And were Smash only dealing with Japan, I wouldn't have those concerns. Outside Japan, Touhou's presence is mostly localized to fan circles on the internet, which is very different than other big series, and casts a distorted and falsely favorable picture of its magnitude overseas.I've been to Japan. Trust me, the sheer reach that Touhou has in Nintendo's homeland can not be exaggerated (and having an overseas presence can only help).
He was already btw.If Microsoft buys, can we make Batman the next meme Smash request?
Another thing I'd like to mention on this is that I think Wave Race would have had a serious chance at Smash, if only more people were familiar with the characters from that game (and maybe also if Blue Storm did better). Undervalued series. And I don't think it's that hard to come up with a moveset involving the jetskis, perhaps filled out with other water-based moves. At least Ryota is an obvious choice for the rep and you could maaaybe reference 1080 also if you really wanted to. Total long shot at this point, but it's neat to imagine at least...1 - Wave Race 64
2 - 1080° Snowboarding
3 - Exitebike 64
I feel like it depends - a lot of horror games are villain-centric, and Pyramid Head and Nemesis would do a good job with representing their franchises (though Leon, Jill, Chris, or Claire could also work), but to give a Nintendo-owned example, there's Eternal Darkness - either the hero (Alexandra Roivas) or the villain (Pious Augustus) could work for that. (one might be a college student while the other is an armoured skeleton, but thanks to the game's magic system, they'd have a lot of overlap in terms of moves)Here is a question if we do get a horror rep would you prefer it being the villain who is suppose to be the horror or the protagonist of the game?
Tbh I think Pyramid Head and Nemesis do Better job at representing a horror character than the protagonist of the games.
I did all that. Still nothing.You can sometimes walk around the area outside to gain extra information from villagers and soldiers to gain your allies' favor. The game kinda tells you so, but the pacing can be quite slow in the story telling so yeah, I imagine most are just happy to actually play when those phases happen.
Yes.If Microsoft buys, can we make Batman the next meme Smash request?
I did all that. Still nothing.
The only thing I could have done was grind out convictions by doing the mock battles over and over again.
Yes.
I would love that!Microsoft buy Netherrealm and Mortal kombat and we're getting Mortal kombat X Killer instinct.
I’m getting Deja Vu from this. Last time this happened they were like “no wait they make too much money for us” and backed away.Warner Bros. Discovery is reportedly interested in selling its gaming studios and IP licenses. Xbox, Sony, and EA are supposedly among the handful interested in making a deal. https://t.co/JPczMIazg9 pic.twitter.com/m5f6YKufYz
— ComicBook.com (@ComicBook) April 29, 2022
If Microsoft buys, can we make Batman the next meme Smash request?
I remember that as well. That is why I am surprised they are doing this again.I’m getting Deja Vu from this. Last time this happened they were like “no wait they make too much money for us” and backed away.
I’m getting Deja Vu from this. Last time this happened they were like “no wait they make too much money for us” and backed away.
I remember that as well. That is why I am surprised they are doing this again.
Basically what the audience said: from what I can tell, Warner Bros/Discovery are still trying to figure out what to do with themselves post-merger. For example, DC is getting restructed, and more recently it was announced TNT and TMS are cutting back on original content (assuming I'm remembering that right). Considering there were reports of getting rid of the games division even BEFORE the merger happened, it's not THAT surprising...Given the supposed big changes occurring after the Discovery merger with WB, the games division being offloaded doesn't feel entirely out of the question.
visualizing yellow checkmarks on Ryu Hayabusa, Kunio, Arthur and Bill Rizervisualizing yellow checkmarks on Ryu Hayabusa, Billy Lee, and Bill Rizer
Cause Final Fantasy already has a Fighter.Though, I don't know why the Black Mage has a yellow checkmark.
Oh yeah. I forgot about Arthur. Though, at least he has a checkmark at all.visualizing yellow checkmarks on Ryu Hayabusa, Kunio, Arthur and Bill Rizer
Yeah but the fighters are Cloud and Sephiroth, not the Black Mage.Cause Final Fantasy already has a Fighter.
buying a company for the talent would be foolish. theres no guarantee that the people working there would stayPast Netherrealm, you get talented devs like Rocksteady, Avalanche, and Monolith (the other one), but companies other than like, Nintendo, are now more in it for the IP than the talent. And IP-wise, the only big gaming name is Mortal Kombat.
NLG, Bluepoint and Housemarque are sweatingbuying a company for the talent would be foolish. theres no guarantee that the people working there would stay
Nintendo: WHAT YOU SAY, BOY!?!?buying a company for the talent would be foolish. theres no guarantee that the people working there would stay
well Now I’m wondering if Nintendo ever have bought a company for the people working thereNintendo: WHAT YOU SAY, BOY!?!?