stixie
Smash Apprentice
Not a professional player by any means but I AM at 6.4M GSP and I play A LOT of on/off line games. This is my OPINION of our current game status.
Last edited:
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Well... so Yoshi I could be completely wrong about. I don't play the character and I pretty much block everyone who does LOLSuprisingly not that bad.
However Yoshi is obviously not mid tier, Sonic and Zelda should swap, Lucas is a little overrated and isn't high tier, and Sheik and Zelda aren't high tier QUITE yet (Though sheik is close). Oh and Cloud should be on the lower end of High tier instead of a higher end and R.O.B might be a tier below but on the higher end.
There's some other stuff like Jiggs and especially Villy being too low and other stuff like that and I can get into detail on why I feel like each char deserves a different place but I'm a little busy rn.
I disagree slightly with your placement of anyone but Little Mac in the bottom tier. Obviously you might say I'm a bit biased, but in my experience of playing them I've matched up pretty well against Kirby, DK, KKR, Corrin, Plant, Ridley, Jigs, and Isabelle. And on that note, DK should definately be a bit higher. He can move.Suprisingly not that bad.
However Yoshi is obviously not mid tier, Sonic and Zelda should swap, Lucas is a little overrated and isn't high tier, and Sheik and Zelda aren't high tier QUITE yet (Though sheik is close). Oh and Cloud should be on the lower end of High tier instead of a higher end and R.O.B might be a tier below but on the higher end.
There's some other stuff like Jiggs and especially Villy being too low and other stuff like that and I can get into detail on why I feel like each char deserves a different place but I'm a little busy rn.
For reference, here's my ORDERED tier list:
View attachment 265218
Doc as low tier?? Hm... I mean... true he doesn't have that great of results but it's weird to think of him as low tier.i think dr. Mario still needs to be a low tier, hitting hard(er) as a truck and getting new combos are awesome but he’s had the same issues as prepatch. I think he can def be mid tier if I see another breakout but until now he’s probably top of low
Definitely don’t see Isabelle as terribly designed, i don’t like it and i think the yellow dog is still below average but probably the lower end of low tier
I agree with everything you said but the characters in the tiers below him are just.................... worse.I feel like Doc just hits harder and that alone isn't enough to make him 'good'. He lacks the speed and general mobility regular Mario offers, lacks the spin dair (Which is way better than Doc's mid air stomp) and is just a bit laggier overall. His recovery is also booty. While Mario may not hit 'as hard' as Doc, his combo game is so much better that it offsets the difference in damage per hit. I'd agree that Doc is low tier MAYBE able to slip into low Mid but that's about as high as he can go right now.