Moveset-Tier List

[Z1GMA]

You are a Smash Character (no specific one).
If you lost just 1 of all maneuvers in your moveset, which one would be the most devastating to lose?

Make a Tier List and put the moves that'd be the most devastating to lose at the top, and the moves you're less worried about losing at the bottom.

e.g. Losing one of your tilts wouldn't be as devastating as losing your shield, since you've got other attacks that *could* work in the same situation.

The Tiers:
TOP
HIGH
MIDDLE
LOW

The maneuvers:
One of my tilts.
One of my aerials.
One of my smashes.
Jab
Dash Attack
Grab
Dash Grab
Ability to Dash.
Ability to Fast Fall.
One of by B-moves.
Recovery (Up+B)
Spot Dodge
Air Dodge
One of my rolls.
Shield
Double Jump
Initial Jump
Move (left/right)
Ledge Grab

This is a test to see what maneuver(s) ppl think is the most important.
Good luck and have fun.

(I first posted this in the Pool Room, but there's noone there. Ever.)

 

[Lemonwater]

Top
-My most telegraphed and laggy smash attack

Bottom
-Everything else

 

[moneyfrenzy]

I think losing recovery would basically ruin you

 

[Lemonwater]

Okay, serious list time according to my usual playstyle, in no particular order other than tier levels...

Top Tier
-Jumps and up+B (if said special is a recovery)
-Shield
-Ledge grab
-Spotdodge
-Airdodge
-Moving

High Tier
-Grab and dash grab (and OOS grab and Z-air)
-Dash
-Jab
-Fastfall
-Tilts

Middle Tier
-Aerials
-Nonrecovery specials
-Dash attack

Bottom Tier
-Roll
-Smash attacks

 

[Z1GMA]

Top Tier
Moving (Left / Right)
Shield
B Recovery
Ledge Grab
Double Jump

High Tier
Grab
Dash Grab
Dash
Jab

Middle Tier
Airdodge
Spotdodge
Back Roll
Forward Roll
Dash Attack
Initial jump
Fastfall

Low Tier
1 Nonrecovery B-move
1 Tilt
1 Aerial
1 Smash

 

[Dr. James Rustles]

I think losing recovery would basically ruin you

If every character lost their Up-B, I bet Yoshi would move up to at least B tier.