• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Mind Over Meta #22 - Playing Alone

LiteralGrill

Smokin' Hot~
Joined
Dec 9, 2012
Messages
5,976
Location
Wisconsin
Mind Over Meta is a weekly series of articles on /r/SSBPM, the Project M subreddit. Written by several different authors, this series covers many of the mental aspects of playing smash and other subjects related specifically to Project M. This week user orangegluon wrote about Playing Alone. The original article can be found here, and to read the rest of the series check out the Mind Over Meta Archive. Sit down, read, and enjoy.

---​

Goin' Solo

Project M is great at tournaments or with lots of friends, when there’s a big pool of people you can play against and a variety of styles to learn and beat. But many don’t always have that luxury. Maybe tournaments aren’t happening 24 hours a day, or none of your friends enjoy Project M, or it just happens to be a weekend where your friends aren’t free to hang out with you. Then how exactly can we enjoy Project M whenever there’s no one for us to spar with?

Welp, we can’t. Project M is over. Pack it up, we’re done.

Not really. We can still play Project M alone. In most cases it’s not as fun, but despite this there are still ways to make the most of your opportunity to play Project M by yourself.

”Only Road That I Have Ever Known”

Throughout the last 5 years, Smash has often been a rather lonesome game for me. In high school, my friends were not very good at Smash, so they didn’t like playing against me when they couldn’t keep up very well. And even if they wanted to play, we were so busy most of the time that it was never practical to even entertain the thought of having a training partner.

My game of choice for the most part was Super Smash Brothers Melee earlier on, and the only local Smash scene I knew of was based on Brawl. On top of that, I didn’t know much about that scene, so I was shy and reluctant to go try out the scene. As a result, I withdrew and had to just play Melee on my own.

I did not learn of Project M until college, so the content I could have access to in Melee was much more restricted; fewer characters, fewer stages, and less single-player-specific content. I was becoming interested in the competitive scene by this point, so I would only play on 6 different stages and against about one out of 4 different characters usually.

I’ll tell you, this was better than nothing. But it was boring, and I often would just play this way because there was nothing better to do. Seeing the intensity of competition ruined my enjoyment of item matches on Rainbow Cruise against CPUs. I was set in a “tournament” path, but I believed that Super Smash Brothers was not popular enough for me to ever enter a tournament. So I was playing a constricted way and not having fun, for the sake of playing Smash.

But then I go to college. There’s a Smash Brothers scene, much bigger than I could have imagined here. And it’s even bigger than my school, it extends to the whole town! Over time I learn more about the local players, big and small, and become friends with the people in my scene. And I learn about Project M.

Project M was a weak success among my friends for a short time after I heard about it, but it was clear that my friends, especially those who were better at Melee, were not interested or even disliked the game. I naively thought I was building a Project M interest among my friends, but I was fooling myself. And as Melee became less and less enjoyable, I found myself playing Project M alone more and more, a full circle.

My point in this story is that I understand the frustration of playing Smash alone. As a result, I learned a few things that helped me continue to play, even when every instinct or intuition should suggest I stop and do better things with my time. And I’d like to share these things with you.

Choo Choo - The Train

I found when I came to college, my Melee Luigi did relatively well against Fox players, Falco players, and Captain Falcon players. My friends were quite surprised by how well I did against them. But prior to experience against real players, I’d managed to give myself an edge in these matchup somehow, to where I felt quite confident against these high tier characters.

Here’s how: the two years of Melee alone turned out to be lots of training for the opponents I would face later on. During those two years, I had not only learned to wavedash, L-cancel, and mash Luigi’s down-B like it stole my house, but knowing that Fox, Falco, and Falcon were common characters competitively, I learned how to chaingrab and edgeguard these characters to some degree.

Playing alone is, as might be obvious, an opportunity to learn and hone technical skills. “Hitting the lab,” or “labbing it,” as it is colloquially termed, is the process of taking time alone to improve at specific technical points. There’s a lot of facets to what you can do “in the lab,” so I want to take a note about a few of the possibilities.

First, I should mention that in general Project M CPUs are unrealistic, in that they often do very fast reactions most humans would not do, and paradoxically often fall off the stage in stupid ways. However, they are programmed to DI in random ways, which is great for learning how to follow up on DI for your combos and techniques.

For players who are still quite new at the game and not yet familiar with all the basic techniques (aerial attacks, recoveries, grabs, etc), playing against CPUs in Project M is great practice! I highly recommend you use this low-pressure high-focus environment to your advantage. It was only through this kind of play against low-level CPUs that I made a habit of using the C-stick for aerials, and trying to sweetspot recoveries. I have at least two friends who are currently looking to learn the game, and I’ve seen marked improvements after they take initiative to play against CPUs or use training mode (remember: C-stick attacks are possible in PM’s training mode, while they are not in Melee’s!) when no one else is around.

Classic and All-Star modes are also great to master the basic attacks and familiarize yourself with the game. Similarly, events are an engaging way to get more and more familiar with the controller and techniques. I’ll admit, Project M requires an intimidating amount of technique and understanding to experience it fully, but the resources of the game like these extra 1-player modes make it easy to quickly grasp the basics.

For players already familiar with the game, use time alone to grind out tech skill. I only learned to wavedash by practicing it alone and then forcing myself to apply it poorly and then more effectively against increasingly higher level CPUs. The level-9 AI in Project M can do a few rather advanced tactics themselves, so playing against them is a good way to compare your progress to your goals. As I said before, these are low-pressure contexts, so you can just waveshine/wavebounce/wavecheat/whatever against the level CPU you choose, or just use training mode.

Although CPUs are more human-like in PM than in Melee, they are still not perfect substitutes. However, there is one way I’ve learned to abuse the AI: practicing chaingrabs. During chaingrabs, CPUs are mostly helpless except for how they DI (just like humans), and this is largely true in Melee as well. At the least, you can practice learning the rhythms for chaingrabs, and use the CPU’s random-ish behavior to practice tech chases and follow ups on basic combos.

The Project M Dev Team put effort into building these resources to maximize your training, so take advantage of them!

Expedition

I want to mention one other personal experience of mine. When I started playing Project M and realized that my friends were generally not interested, I took time to try and learn the game a bit better. With 41 characters to use and play against, there’s a lot to take in, so I broke it down a bit at a time.

For hours, I would set a CPU to level 9, and set both our character icons to “Random.” Then I would select a random stage, and just play out the match, regardless of who I get and what the stage was.

This type of play was fun and engaging, because I had no idea what I was going to get, and often once I got it, I didn’t know what it was. Sure, I’d read or seen some things about the various characters but once a Lucario is in your hands for the first time, the feeling of exploration is unbelievable. “You can throw Spirit Bombs?! And you can mash A forever and just win!?”

Playing random-random battles against CPUs is both informative and entertaining, whether or not you have a main character by that point. It’s especially helpful for players new to Project M (preferably with some competitive experience in another Smash) to explore the game in some way. There’s a lot of content in PM, and you’re likely to see just about every character in tournaments. Playing as and against essentially the whole CSS can teach you enough to understand the basics of every character you’ll fight in brackets.

Maybe randomizing everything isn’t your style, but in Project M, I highly encourage you to spend time, if you have not already in the past, just learning the game character by character (perhaps in a more systematic way than I did). For more information on playing a large variety of characters outside of brackets, you might check our previous MoM on the topic.

Brakes on the Train?

While I’ve just extolled several ways to play PM by yourself, largely against CPUs, there are some cautions I must address.

As I mentioned earlier, CPUs in Smash are notoriously - non-human. Training against them builds bad habits, just by the nature of trying to replace human play with computers. I’m largely a casualty of this fact; by playing against Melee CPUs essentially exclusively, I never learned or even heard of a neutral game until college. Watching youtube videos didn’t teach me fundamentals or neutral game, it just taught me that people scream when you do combos and knees, and that’s all I took with me. I didn’t learn how to deal with pressure by lasers, shines, projectiles, speed, swords, or anything else, just how to chaingrab three characters more or less. I’m a weaker player for it.

Playing alone is great for certain things, but you must, must, must know what you’re doing and what you’re trying to learn. As I said before, playing modes like Classic Mode in 1-player is great to teach you the game, build endurance, and expose yourself to battle. But CPUs don’t flinch, DI consistently, use a proper neutral game, or apply most other facets of playing tournaments. Some CPUs like Fox will pressure you hard, but they also frequently Illusion to their death.

At every level of play, I recommend you learn about the neutral game more and more, either by playing against humans or learning about it from the dozens of resources on the internet. This is the pivotal skill that separates chumps and champs, regardless of how much tech skill you learn. Playing a pseudo-neutral game against CPUs helps to learn the basics of it (i.e., spacing and continuously adjusting yourself in response to where the CPU goes to learn how to react to opponents). However, as I said before, your human opponents will show different movement patterns from what you’ll generally see in Project M, so be aware!

The other caution I’d like to issue is in avoiding burnout. Frequently, I would find myself bored and tired of playing Smash for so long by myself. There’s only so many hours in a day for so many days that you can play alone without wearing down your resolve. And in a game like Smash, it’s important to make sure you don’t waste your enthusiasm; it’s an amazing game, but getting tired of the game even for an hour leaves a sour taste in your mouth for days or up to months. Here’s a few things I recommend you do to avoid this sort of burnout:
  • Don’t play for too long at once. The way you wear yourself down is in playing continuously for a long time while your boredom builds up and you don’t notice. Then you suddenly realize how bored you are, and it’s hard to come back to the game afterward.
  • Play other modes. Grinding waveshines for 6 hours is draining. If you don’t have fun with the game at least periodically, you end up feeling mentally tired. Unless you’re at a level where playing against CPUs can make you worse, it may be fun to try some of the event matches or All-Star Mode, just some fun little challenges to give yourself a break by doing something less intensive in Smash

  • Play other games. All work and no play makes Jack a mindless Smashbot. Other games, from slapping in Mario Kart to going outside and playing basketball, will keep your mind refreshed. If you just spend all day staring at Smash while missile canceling for hours ad nauseum, Doing other things really helps to recover from that kind of mental stress.

  • Have your life. You have other obligations to take care of, so prioritize things that matter more than practicing Smash. I’ve found that after life kicks in and I take long breaks from the game, I come back to PM refreshed and ready to learn again. On top of that, when you’re busy with obligations, PM feels like a sweet reward to play, and even boring tech skill practice can be refreshing.
As long as you’re aware of your developing habits and you make sure not to fatigue yourself, you should be able to benefit and improve your game even without others to play against.

Lonely, But Not Lost

Playing alone is tough sometimes, but there are still always things you can do to help your tournament performance later. Anything from exploring Project M to practicing highly-specific tech skill by yourself is a good use of single-player play.

Even when things look bleak for your local community, the world is always changing, and you don’t know if your efforts will pay off. I certainly may have just been lucky that Smash erupted the way it did, and all my efforts just before it did had some kind of payoff. But I made those efforts, despite having no one to share the game with, for the same reason almost everyone in the Smash community has done anything:

It’s for love of the game.

And that’s all you need to find the game rewarding. Just love the game.

While playing with others is still always more fun than alone, I hope that this article helps you make the most of the times you’re stuck playing by yourself.

---​

SmashCapps hopes people enjoyed this piece and can use it to maximize their alone time with Smash. To keep up with all things Smash follow him on Twitter
 
Joined
Mar 26, 2015
Messages
667
Location
D-D-D-DUELING IN THE SHADOW REALM
NNID
MasterIcarus7
Second! Yes. But for real tho. This is actually my problem. No siblings, my friends rely on me only to use MY house as a venue. It is really hard to go through this and this guide helped. Thank you for showing me this resource SmashCapps
 

B0gu5

Smash Rookie
Joined
Jun 7, 2015
Messages
2
Thank you for this. Since I've gone home from college this summer I've had NOBODY to practice/play with and it's frustrating.The burnout has been starting to become real, and I keep wondering why I continue to beat up Lv9 CPU Fox and slowly increase that L-Cancel % more consistently, but you just gave me my answer and that is I frickin' love Project M so much!!!
 

Pixel_

Smash Ace
Joined
Mar 28, 2015
Messages
881
lol, I rarely have anyone to play with for SSB4, but absolutely nobody will play Project M with me.

Liked.
 

Cyre

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Oct 12, 2014
Messages
114
Very nice read, inspiring really. I'm unfortunately living in a place where everyone likes melee or smash 4 and no one even tosses a glance at pm. While I like smash 4, when I get to play PM, I end up giggling like a school girl and no other competitive title gives me that. Your final section really made me feel better about putting more time into the game as-well.

Thanks for typing up the piece.
 

badangadang

Smash Apprentice
Joined
May 30, 2013
Messages
121
Very nice read, inspiring really. I'm unfortunately living in a place where everyone likes melee or smash 4 and no one even tosses a glance at pm. While I like smash 4, when I get to play PM, I end up giggling like a school girl and no other competitive title gives me that. Your final section really made me feel better about putting more time into the game as-well.
It feels really boring and unrewarding for a while, playing a game no one else likes. But if you have fun playing it, and you know that others out there also do, it makes it easier to keep at it. No one plays me at local tournaments in Dragonball Z Budokai Tenkaichi 3, or in Pokemon Puzzle League, so I still know that feeling any time I pick those games up. Although I don't really play those games much anymore due to largely time constraints, but still.
 

HalcyonDays

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Nov 3, 2014
Messages
191
As someone who has previously spent months playing Project M without another soul in sight, I can really resonate with this.

Once I finally did find a scene, if only for a little while though, I found that the time I spent "in the lab" alone for months actually helped somewhat with a pure focus on getting tech skill down, and I wasn't too shabby with strategic fundamentals either.

There are still things to gain, even if you train alone.

This said, if you haven't found a scene yet, do your best to research and find one near you, or find like-minded people who're willing to learn more about the game, just like you.
 

badangadang

Smash Apprentice
Joined
May 30, 2013
Messages
121
Thank you for this. Since I've gone home from college this summer I've had NOBODY to practice/play with and it's frustrating.The burnout has been starting to become real, and I keep wondering why I continue to beat up Lv9 CPU Fox and slowly increase that L-Cancel % more consistently, but you just gave me my answer and that is I frickin' love Project M so much!!!
Don't overdo it with beating up those CPUs. When you start to feel burned out, it's time to change things up a bit, for your own mental state. Seeing that L-cancel percent rise over time is a definite, concrete goal and helps a lot in keeping yourself burned out, and the article probably should have mentioned that with the other features, but yeah.

Fox is strangely engaging to play against because he's so aggressive and flashy while DI-ing relatively well, so you can't just braindead shield->chaingrab->aerial. Just be sure to remember he's just 1 of 41 common characters, so don't get too caught up just fighting against Foxes as you train.
 

badangadang

Smash Apprentice
Joined
May 30, 2013
Messages
121
This said, if you haven't found a scene yet, do your best to research and find one near you, or find like-minded people who're willing to learn more about the game, just like you.
It doesn't matter how good a person is when you're trying to build or join a scene. If the person wants to play and enjoys playing, they're worth playing with in your scene. End of story.

Finding people requires being open, persistent, and accommodating to other players. If you intimidate people, they will leave, and if you patronize them, they will leave.

The best way to get casuals into competitive play is by letting them have fun their way and letting them watch you have fun your way.
 

Βearzor

Smash Cadet
Joined
Jun 4, 2015
Messages
26
Location
Las Vegas, Nevada
I'm sitting here trying to find an opponent on Smash Ladder for like 4 hours and failing. This article couldn't come at a better time! I'm gonna practice some technical skills. Thank you.
 

Kerpy Derp

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Feb 21, 2015
Messages
97
Location
Chef Kowasaki's diner
NNID
Kerpy Derp
3DS FC
3136-7596-2766
Don't overdo it with beating up those CPUs. When you start to feel burned out, it's time to change things up a bit, for your own mental state. Seeing that L-cancel percent rise over time is a definite, concrete goal and helps a lot in keeping yourself burned out, and the article probably should have mentioned that with the other features, but yeah.

Fox is strangely engaging to play against because he's so aggressive and flashy while DI-ing relatively well, so you can't just braindead shield->chaingrab->aerial. Just be sure to remember he's just 1 of 41 common characters, so don't get too caught up just fighting against Foxes as you train.
Personally I can sometimes get burned out really fast because of the freakin spacies they gonna be shinin till I am literally crying sometimes I think those guys need to take chill pills.
 

Benny P

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Dec 10, 2014
Messages
465
Location
Coming Soon
Personally I can sometimes get burned out really fast because of the freakin spacies they gonna be shinin till I am literally crying sometimes I think those guys need to take chill pills.
start maining dr mario, and you can give em the pills
 

B0gu5

Smash Rookie
Joined
Jun 7, 2015
Messages
2
Don't overdo it with beating up those CPUs. When you start to feel burned out, it's time to change things up a bit, for your own mental state. Seeing that L-cancel percent rise over time is a definite, concrete goal and helps a lot in keeping yourself burned out, and the article probably should have mentioned that with the other features, but yeah.

Fox is strangely engaging to play against because he's so aggressive and flashy while DI-ing relatively well, so you can't just braindead shield->chaingrab->aerial. Just be sure to remember he's just 1 of 41 common characters, so don't get too caught up just fighting against Foxes as you train.
I know, its just that Fox is the only one who actually puts up a fight. Everyone else just SD's (Falco, after westballz multishining forever lol) or does literally nothing effective enough to fight like a real player. I like playing Fox cause it really forces me to work on my spacing with wavedashes and dash dances, cause if i mess up, I get up smashed and die. Just basic stuff I have to learn, cause I am a really new player to smash in general. I just started playing in the fall for the first time (that was Brawl haha) and not really skillfully until I found out about PM (this February) That's when I realized the game was so deep and so much was needed to be learned (and practiced) and i have come so far in just these few months, but I hope to keep improving!
 

Kotastic

Smash Ace
Joined
Mar 21, 2015
Messages
540
Location
California
NNID
Kotastic
3DS FC
3368-4107-1072
Thank you SO much for posting this article! I can relate basically everything to this guy. I feel like I'm a very technical player as I can double fair and wavedash consistently as marth, but I don't know how to setup for intense combos. I know how to double SH lasers, waveshine (kinda), double-shine, SHHFL + shine consistently, but I really don't know how to DI much, etc. None of my friends are that great in Smash and I can destroy them across all games, making it not very fun for us and we often had to include random factors like pokeballs. Don't get me wrong, they can mean great times but it's certainly not my ideal setup.

I remember my neutral game was horrible when I was playing Smash4 3DS For Glory. I would get destroyed by people with strong neutrals and pressures and them constantly shielding my DA and me not adapting to it. I suppose the neutral game video can help me out a lot haha.
 
Last edited:

Rachman

be water my friend
Joined
Mar 22, 2015
Messages
229
Location
FL
PM AI Di randomly? Do they tech randomly? Is this all CPU levels or just level 9?
 

Keeshu

Smash Ace
Joined
Jun 30, 2013
Messages
778
Location
Lurking in the darkness.....
I just glanced at the article.
I gotta say, Melee CPUs are absolutely horrid. Brawls were better (Enough to make you want to bother with side stepping, and not just attack whenever the enemy gets close). I haven't messed with Wii U's CPUs yet. However, the Amiibos are absolutely amazing as they usually learn the better moves, and change up tactics from battle to battle if they start to not do well.
Even though Amiibos are amazing, and no one in my town could come close to beating them (they have a hard time with just regular level 9s), I will agree that they aren't perfect. Especially if you're trying to get better at using any projectile character. CPUs in all the games are very stupid about projectiles, so you can usually camp and stay away until they can be KOd.

Eh, I'll continue to practice in case some tourney player does come in my town. *shrug*
 
Top Bottom