Melee or Brawl? And why

[Hakkat]

What do you guys think? I like melee, although I used to like brawl, I like melee because:

1. Mewtwo, Roy, Young Link, Pichu, Dr. Mario
2. Requires more skill than brawl by far
3. Awesome/fun event matches (more than Brawl IMO)
4. More balanced
5. Tiers didn't seem to matter as much
6. Adventure Mode rocked
7. Classic Mode was better
8. Collecting Trophies was more fun (IMO)
9. Characters were less spammable (MK is spammable in brawl)
10. NO TRIPPING!!!!! :D
11. Overall much better gameplay

More reasons but these were the main ones I thought of. Please don't hate me if you love brawl. I did like stage creating and music but it can't beat Melee's gameplay. Thoughts? And I am aware that this is mostly opinion but still it's fun to share opinions (also an opinion, )

 

[Hakkat]

Btw I posted this on Melee because I like Melee better and I didn't know where to post it, sorry if it's in the wrong place...

 

[The 2t]

Well I have my doubts that anyone here is going to prefer brawl :\ lol

 

[Ziodyne]

Brawl's amazing

Look at all the amazing things about Brawl:
1) Floaty physics
2) ****ty movement options
3) Tripping
4) Captain Falcon has the most amazing combos ever, including:
- D-throw -> nothing

Definitely would be okay spending a weekend playing brawl. no regr3ts

 

[AppleAppleAZ]

Should post this in Brawl discussion. Change the title to "Why did you stick to Brawl?".

I'd actually be really interested in that thread.

 

[Engo]

yoooo this thread's gonna be dope!

 

[RockinRudy]

Brawl = Single Button Mode.​

​

 

[Puca Readabook]

Yeah i really can't understand why some people prefer brawl over melee....it doesn't make sense...

 

[Hakkat]

Brawl = Single Button Mode.​

​

Lol. I wouldn't go THAT far, but it sure takes a lot less skill. But that was hilarious.

 

[Hakkat]

Should post this in Brawl discussion. Change the title to "Why did you stick to Brawl?".

I'd actually be really interested in that thread.

That's a pretty good idea. You should do it though because it was your idea. Although there is one thing I absolutely love about Brawl:
FLOATINESS! Yeah, no. It's Custom Stages. Kinda the only reason I would want to play, even if it is rather limited I have made some cool ones. Still, I play Melee so much more. I also like the actual stages in melee better

 

[Massive]

IT'S BACK GUYS!

THIS TOPIC IS BACK AGAIN!

 

[pokemongeof]

This question is easy to answer. Been answered when everyone saw a problem with brawl.

 

[Puca Readabook]

I feel as though every brawl player doesn't know what their missing...

 

[Teczer0]

Brawl and Melee comparison threads are not allowed anywhere on the boards.