Blaster1235
Smash Rookie
- Joined
- Dec 17, 2017
- Messages
- 2
S: Vish, Moon, Mango, PPMD
A: DJ Nintendo, Westballz, Armada, Webs, Wobbles
B: Phil, Lovage, Blur
C: Scar, HMW, Slime
D: D1, Tafo, Fendy
F: Toph, Hugs, Ken, Prog, Fauster
Reasonings:
Vish: Very professional, focuses on the gameplay, gives great insight to what's happening
Moon/Mango: Naturally funny, great personalities
PPMD: Expansive game knowledge and describes the match well
DJ Nintendo: Great all around commentator
Westballz: Doesn't commentate much but he's on the list because he makes commentary interesting and makes astute observations
Armada: Similar to PPMD but talks a bit slow because English is his second language
Webs: Solid all around, focuses on gameplay
Wobbles: Intelligent commentator, also game focused
Phil: A little too casual but talks fast and is interesting
Lovage: Knowledgeable, but a bit boring and dull
Blur: Average all around
Scar: Never focuses on the match, goes off topic way too much. Completely distracting from gameplay. Still is C tier because of personality and humor, but Mango/Moon do that better.
HMW: Solid, but resorts to same talking points over and over. For example, at the start of every set, "so what do you think of the matchup? I think Marth lowkey wins."
Slime: Funny, but tries a little too hard to be funny and doesn't know much about the game.
D1: Feels fake, like he's putting on a show or trying too hard to sound professional. Doesn't seem genuine, and is quite boring. But could be a lot worse.
Tafo: Perhaps the most boring and dull commentator. Makes a lot of mistakes too. But he focuses on analyzing the match at hand which is good.
Fendy: Generally obnoxious and gets really excited at random times
Toph: Irritating, talks over people, thinks he's funny but he's not, extremely biased. Was very disrespectful to players in the past while on the mic.
Ken/Hugs: See Kings of Cali Mango vs PPMD. Also, "it can go either way."
Prog: Has the same issues as D1, only worse. Extremely dull and boring as well.
Fauster: Probably the worst commentator of all time. So many great moments and combo's are ruined by him screaming into the mic. Please end this man's career.
Feel free to agree/disagree, these are just my personal opinions.
A: DJ Nintendo, Westballz, Armada, Webs, Wobbles
B: Phil, Lovage, Blur
C: Scar, HMW, Slime
D: D1, Tafo, Fendy
F: Toph, Hugs, Ken, Prog, Fauster
Reasonings:
Vish: Very professional, focuses on the gameplay, gives great insight to what's happening
Moon/Mango: Naturally funny, great personalities
PPMD: Expansive game knowledge and describes the match well
DJ Nintendo: Great all around commentator
Westballz: Doesn't commentate much but he's on the list because he makes commentary interesting and makes astute observations
Armada: Similar to PPMD but talks a bit slow because English is his second language
Webs: Solid all around, focuses on gameplay
Wobbles: Intelligent commentator, also game focused
Phil: A little too casual but talks fast and is interesting
Lovage: Knowledgeable, but a bit boring and dull
Blur: Average all around
Scar: Never focuses on the match, goes off topic way too much. Completely distracting from gameplay. Still is C tier because of personality and humor, but Mango/Moon do that better.
HMW: Solid, but resorts to same talking points over and over. For example, at the start of every set, "so what do you think of the matchup? I think Marth lowkey wins."
Slime: Funny, but tries a little too hard to be funny and doesn't know much about the game.
D1: Feels fake, like he's putting on a show or trying too hard to sound professional. Doesn't seem genuine, and is quite boring. But could be a lot worse.
Tafo: Perhaps the most boring and dull commentator. Makes a lot of mistakes too. But he focuses on analyzing the match at hand which is good.
Fendy: Generally obnoxious and gets really excited at random times
Toph: Irritating, talks over people, thinks he's funny but he's not, extremely biased. Was very disrespectful to players in the past while on the mic.
Ken/Hugs: See Kings of Cali Mango vs PPMD. Also, "it can go either way."
Prog: Has the same issues as D1, only worse. Extremely dull and boring as well.
Fauster: Probably the worst commentator of all time. So many great moments and combo's are ruined by him screaming into the mic. Please end this man's career.
Feel free to agree/disagree, these are just my personal opinions.
Last edited: