Mario_and_Sonic_Guy's Roster Prediction

[Mario & Sonic Guy]

I did have a prediction on what Brawl's roster could be. The roster is sorted by franchises.

Mario
Luigi
Peach
Bowser / Giga Bowser (use Final Smash)
Toad
Bowser Jr. / Shadow Mario
Waluigi​

Donkey Kong
Diddy Kong
King K. Rool​

Link
Zelda / Sheik
Ganondorf / Ganon (use Final Smash)
Wolf Link and Midna
Wind Waker Link​

Samus / Zero Suit Samus
Ridley / Omega Ridley (must touch Phazon)​

Yoshi​

Kirby
Meta Knight
King Dedede​

Fox
Falco
Wolf o' Donnell
Krystal​

Pikachu
Jigglypuff
Mewtwo
PKMN Trainer (Squirtle, Ivysaur, Charizard)
Gardevoir
Lucario​

Captain Falcon
Black Shadow​

Ness​

Ice Climbers​

Mr. Game & Watch​

Marth
Roy
Ike​

Wario​

Pit​

Animal Crosser​

Pikmin

Captain Olimar​

Golden Sun

Isaac​

Solid Snake​

Sonic the Hedgehog​

Rayman​

Note: I couldn't see any official threads where you post your rosters.

 

[Cinder]

One, I might havta create a roster thread so everyone can post
Two, the list is okay...like Lucario, not sure about Waluigi...

 

[Kirby knight]

Yay more character roaster fun.

First of all Toad has been deconfirmed and Waluigi is so unimportant if even Toad couldn't make it as a playable character Waluigi won't be either. I mean at least Toad had his own game.

And please you'd have to be a Roy Fanboy to think he'd be returning. He's not as popular as the other two lords mentioned. Not to mention brings nothing unique that hasn't already been brought. Roy did have a ranged sword in his game; Ike however steals that unique quality from him. He's not likely to return.

Other likely FE character to be in are. Mikaya, Black Knight, Sigurd and Hector. Personally I'm a fan of Mikaya she brings a completely different style of fighting to the Fire Emblem franchise (Light Magic). Not to mention she as a much needed female perspective on a male dominated franchise.

And Eww at Rayman, Megaman would be a better choice over him I think...

-Knight

 

[Xanderous]

Rayman? Are you serious? Originated on Playstation and continues to suck Rayman?
MegaMan is still the only logical 3rd party char other than Sonic.

 

[raphtmarqui]

I like the icons...

 

[raphtmarqui]

And i like the Isaac

 

[Caael]

No simon and no FE girls.

But otherwise it's pretty good. Nice one.

 

[Zevox]

Hm. Well, theres a lot of good to it (K Rool and Isaac, very nice), but also some bad. First theres the Mario roster - Toad and Waluigi are as minor as Mario characters come (Toad is a dime-a-dozen lackey of Peach, Waluigi hasn't even been in any real Mario game, he exists solely as filler for the party games). Then theres Star Fox having four characters, which is doubtful since its a fairly small franchise which is already past its pinnacle of popularity. Then theres the Fire Emblem roster with Roy, who is a pretty poor choice for a rep now that he can't serve as an add. And lastly theres Rayman, whose presence over the likes of Mega Man, Bomber Man, or even Pac Man stupefies me.

Personally I also dislike Midna being with Wolf Link - why people want her to be riding him in Brawl rather than fighting on her own I'll never quite understand - but thats just a personal preference thing.

Drop Toad, Waluigi, either Falco or Wolf, Roy, and Rayman, and add someone in Roy's place (see the list Kirby Knight gave), and perhaps someone in Rayman's place, and I'd be good with it.

Zevox

 

[Darthkirby707]

I did have a prediction on what Brawl's roster could be. The roster is sorted by franchises.

Mario
Luigi
Peach
Bowser / Giga Bowser (use Final Smash)
Toad (I doubt it, he's Peach's attack, and hasn't been a main character in any games really...)
Bowser Jr. / Shadow Mario
Waluigi (No. He is simply a filler character for the Mario Party, Kart, etc. games. He hasn't been in any of the real Mario games, and has no personality whatsoever, unlike Wario who has two of his own series)​

Donkey Kong
Diddy Kong
King K. Rool​

Link
Zelda / Sheik
Ganondorf / Ganon (use Final Smash) (You might want to put whether you think Ganondorf will use a sword or not, as that does make a big difference to his moveset)
Wolf Link and Midna (I don't think Midna/Wolf Link will be in, but I do adknowledge his chances.)
Wind Waker Link (Now this I agree with, WW would make a worthy replacement to Young Link, and wouldn't be a clone.​

Samus / Zero Suit Samus
Ridley / Omega Ridley (must touch Phazon) (Not sure about the phazon thing, but I agree Ridley should be in Brawl)​

Yoshi​

Kirby
Meta Knight
King Dedede (THANK YOU. Dedede should definately be in Brawl, it breaks my heart when I see rosters without him)​

Fox
Falco
Wolf o' Donnell
Krystal​

Pikachu
Jigglypuff
Mewtwo
PKMN Trainer (Squirtle, Ivysaur, Charizard)
Gardevoir (A bit too many pokemon, but I do know of Gardevoir's popularity in Japan... just wondering, was Gardevoir on Sakurai's poll?)
Lucario​

Captain Falcon
Black Shadow​

Ness (I'm sad to say it, but I do think Ness will be replaced by Lucas...)​

Ice Climbers​

Mr. Game & Watch​

Marth
Roy (Sorry, but Roy was a clone and just used to market his games. There are many characters deserving this spot- Sigurd, Hector, Black Knight, etc.
Ike​

Wario​

Pit​

Animal Crosser​

Pikmin

Captain Olimar (Once again, THANK YOU)​

Golden Sun

Isaac​

Solid Snake​

Sonic the Hedgehog​

Rayman (I do like Rayman, but Megaman, Pacman, Bomberman, and many others are more deserving of the spot.)​

Note: I couldn't see any official threads where you post your rosters.

I just put my opinions on some of the characters, I'm in parentheses.

 

[Pieman0920]

Mario Series: As said, Toad has been deconfirme. Waluigi is also kinda a worthless character, and has never shown up in any canon game. (I also find it weird that he's never shown up in the Wario series) Bowser Jr. Could get in, but I doubt he'll have anything to do with Shadow Mario.

DK series: Lose King K. Rool...Not going to happen.

Zelda Series: I think we'll either get Midna, or maybe WWL, but not both, but that's how I see it. There isn't really a chance of Wolf Link teamed up with Midna at the same time though.

Metroid Series: I don't get the must touch phazon thing, but the roster is alright. Seems lacking compared to other things, but that's just the way Metroid is with its lack of characters. In reality though, the other series will have less than you put in most of them, so it balances out though.

Yoshi Series: Fine.

Kirby Series: Good.

Star Fox Series: It's Wolf or Falco, not both. I personally don't know who's the best for the job as they both have pros and cons, but there's no way both will make it in. Krystal should be a shoe in though.


Pokemon Series: Lose Gardevoir. It's just a random generic Pokemon, wih no claim to fame. Personally, I see Darkrai as a major contender, but most others don't see that, so I'm not going to push that.

F-Zero Series: No to Black Shadow. He's just not worth it.

Earthbound Series: Alright.

Ice Climber Series: Not much you could do here, eh?

Game & Watch Series: Ditto.

Fire Emblem Series: Roy? You honestly think he'll be back? Anyways, I'd put my money on Micaiah being there along with Ike and Math. Three sword users of the same basic style for the same series is pushin it.

Wario Series: Good

Kid Icarus: Good

Animal Crossing Series: Eh? I still believe that we will get Tom Nook, but it's alright to expect we'll get the standard human.

Pikmin Series: Good

Golden Sun Series: Good.

Metal Gear Solid: Good

Sonic Series: Meh

Rayman Series: Huh? This guy won't make it in. No way. Megaman is a much mroe sage bet, or none at all.

 

[Pit 42]

No Waluigi, No wolf Link/ Midna, no WW Link, No Gardevouir, forgetting Lucas, No AC character, and NO RAYMAN.

 

[MysticKenji]

Toad is VERY unlikely
Waluigi...I hope not.
Lose Omega Ridley
I don't think we'll have both Wolf and Falco
Add Lucas to Mother reps
Lose Roy and replace with Micaiah, Sigurd, BK, or Hector
Lose Rayman and replace with Megaman

@darthkirby

Yes, Gardevoir was on Sakurai's poll

 

[Legolastom]

I would give this a 3 out of 10... my main reasons:

1. Rayman
2. Waluigi
3. Rayman
4. King K rool
5. Rayman
6. Rayman

...

And thats just the characters you included don't get me started on the ones you didn't.

But seriously... Rayman!? WHY!

 

[User33]

I'd give it a 4/10

-1 for Waluigi
-1 for Toad
-1 for King K. Rool
-1 for too many Pokemon
-1 for poor FE choices
-1 for Rayman

 

[HipsterKid]

I think Gardevoir at least has a chance of making it into Brawl because it WAS on Sakurai's poll and it is very popular in Japan.

Not to say that'd make it playable but at least an appearance is notable. :/

I'm personally hoping for it to be playable. :]

Besides, we could use all the females [although it being female can be debated] we can get.

 

[:034:]

Rayman? Are you serious? Originated on Playstation and continues to suck Rayman?
MegaMan is still the only logical 3rd party char other than Sonic.

QFT.

I'm also doubtful about Waluigi. Six Mario reps might be pushing it.. But then again, Pokémon has six reps and that's fine. I don't think Waluigi would be a good Mario rep though. Also doubtful Falco AND Wolf. Four Star Fox reps... No. Absolutely not. I'm not even gonna mention Rayman.

But for the rest, this list is pretty solid. I'd suggest replacing Roy, but that's just opinion.