We talked about that one
That's easily fake in so many levels
Yes C9 is king k rool
The biggest mistakes are porkey and samurai goroh they haven't had a game in years
No decidueye nor lycanroc is the second one they have higher odds than mimikyu of getting in I see mimikyu as a pokeball assist more than playable
Medusa is not likely at all especially since that game is phased out sakurai is not making any new ones I feel there's another rep from kid Icarus it would be viridi
Captain toad Is most likely missing too since he had a ton of promotion before and after the roster was finalized
The only reason I can't complain about the roster is due to Ridley, king k rool, geno and sora being on it.
But the biggest key of them all why it's fake by default every single one of suposive full rosters they are always wrong the ones with only a couple of characters are sometimes correct.
The only leak so far that holds water is the Ridley is the E3 reveal and Simon, ice climbers and no cuts leak and that's only because the person who claimed it has ben correct before (not always)
Yeah Samurai Goroh and especially Porky are really weird choices.. but there are more really weird choices on there (like Geno & Mallow team (maybe the Nintendo twitter really hinted at something by asking the question?) Snake returning is also something almost everyone isn't expecting). It almost makes it feel like it could be real, cuz let's be honest - pretty much all rosters had some characters that felt really weird since at least Brawl.
Lycanroc would be strange because he's quadrupedal.. they could make it work, but I can't really see them doing it, since it would still look weird either way. The Midnight form could work, though (but would they really just use 1 form?).
I've always felt the most obvious choices for a Gen 7 rep were Incineroar and Decidueye.. but Lycanroc does have a chance. Same with Mimikyu, though. I'm not a fan of it, but it's a pretty big deal for a lot of people. I wouldn't say seeing Mimikyu on a roster would make it fake at all, especially since atm it's also a "not as obvious choice" as for example Decidueye, which most fans atm see as the most likely newcomer for Pokemon.
Yeah, Medusa is not likely. Same with Viridi, though. Kid Icarus is completely overrepped as a series with 3 characters, even if one of them is a clone. Of course Sakurai could still do it, since it's one of the games he worked on.
Another thing with this leak is that after the images got deleted from reddit the original poster just posted the name of all the characters and a little text at the end:
"heroes vs villains theme is intentional, it'll make more sense at e3".
Of course anyone could and already came up with such ideas, but I wouldn't say it's impossible for Sakurai to choose such a theme, especially since we had no heavies join in Smash4 and Ridley and K. Rool being extremely popular characters.
Yeah it's weird that there's no (captain) Toad, but it's not like he's a shoo-in character. Toad was always missing in Smash, since he's a pretty important and very often playable character of Nintendos main franchise. Maybe all the Captain Toad stuff came too late, or Sakurai doesn't think it would make sense to have him jump. Of course there are always ways to make it work, but Sakurai loves being true to the real games as well. The character still has a pretty decent chance to appear in the game imo, but him not being in it also doesn't disconfirm a roster.
Also, there was a Brawl full roster leak from someone on gamefaqs way before the game came out. I was there when it happened and when we found out that it was true (really sad times since I had already hoped for K. Rool or Dixie).
Not saying this is a real leak, and it probably isn't since it would be too good to be true (imo, even though I'd only get Dixie and K. Rool, lol), but it does have that weird flair around it to at least have the possibility of being true.