Idea: Classic Versions of characters

[D-idara]

Well yea I guess brawl meta knight. Especially since you cant die in that game.

Yea some of the people I know just want each smash game to be melee. Even though imo melee is the best smash game each one needs to be different.

Scratch that, the insult was also directed at you.

But Brawl was just Melee for babies.

There's only 2 unique games. The first 2.

lolno, Brawl was amazing, it's a full-fledged Smash game and deserves to be respected, people like you shouldn't be allowed to play games.

 

[smashbro29]

You're kidding, right?... please tell me you're kidding

Only half kidding, they did just take the Melee engine and make it slow.

Scratch that, the insult was also directed at you.


lolno, Brawl was amazing, it's a full-fledged Smash game and deserves to be respected, people like you shouldn't be allowed to play games.

There's lots of stuff to do and neat new items and modes and all that stuff but the base engine? Absolutely horrid.

 

[Cap'nChreest]

Scratch that, the insult was also directed at you.

Psshhhhh.... yea yea just 'cause I like melee more than brawl means that I hate new things. yup.

 

[josh bones]

Only half kidding, they did just take the Melee engine and make it slow.


There's lots of stuff to do and neat new items and modes and all that stuff but the base engine? Absolutely horrid.

Brawl is as good as toilet paper COMPETIITIVELY, which is less than 10% of the sales. The casuals eat items and stry mode up.

 

[D-idara]

Brawl is as good as toilet paper COMPETIITIVELY, which is less than 10% of the sales. The casuals eat items and stry mode up.

I love how on this forum people call everyone who isn't a competitive player 'casual' :D It's so funny seeing them all use those terms on every single thread to feel bigger than the others. Well let me tell you, there's a lot of hardcore gamers who'd rather play with Items and there's A CRAPTON of hardcore players that love a good story mode. Games nowadays can't just be multiplayer or single player, you need to please both sides.

 

[josh bones]

I love how on this forum people call everyone who isn't a competitive player 'casual' :D It's so funny seeing them all use those terms on every single thread to feel bigger than the others. Well let me tell you, there's a lot of hardcore gamers who'd rather play with Items and there's A CRAPTON of hardcore players that love a good story mode. Games nowadays can't just be multiplayer or single player, you need to please both sides.

Umm.....I know that, smashbro thinks the people who play with no items and fox only are the only people who buy the game.

 

[lordvaati]

Or perhaps people should just stop viewing camps of the Smash fan base in Black&White from both sides?

 

[CrossoverMan]

At least the Brawl versions had more original attributes. Falco in Melee was just too much like Fox, but slower, and had a slightly different blaster.

 

[Wanderer from Roseyard]

Sounds like a bit of a mess. Characters should have exactly one polished set of moves as their arsenal. Things like stance changes or "classic versions" would just show indecision on the designers' part.

 

[smashbro29]

Brawl is as good as toilet paper COMPETIITIVELY, which is less than 10% of the sales. The casuals eat items and stry mode up.

Even not being competitive, the engine is much much worse. It's just Melee but in slo-mo.

Getting way off topic though.

 

[666blaziken]

Having alternate movesets would be a pain to balance out, and it would be hard to do because the mechanics are different than in previous games, so even if fox had his melee moveset, he won't be able to do wave shine. In addition, focusing on this would be like creating 4 times the amount of characters and giving less emphasis on the new characters, and it would be awkward to have the 64 characters to have only 3 B moves. If anything, they should just add the alternate costumes. If Sakurai wants the characters to be more like their melee counterparts, then he can just choose to make them that way.

 

[DraginHikari]

This devolved into the normal brawl/melee bickering session even quicker then normal...

Honestly I don't really see the point of a 'classic' mode so to speak, nor do I see the developers going out of their way to create seperate moveset alterations for a mode like this. Could I see the possiblely of different costumes based on previous games. I suppose it's possible but I am still very doubtful.

 

[---]

This thread quickly turned into a flaming fest.

If you wish to discuss past movesets of a certain character, please use their respective Confirmed/Unconfirmed Veteran forum.