My thinking is that the "2014" release date isn't a definitive thing. Heck, it even says "Planned release: 2014" on the Dojo. PLANNED!!!
The "2014" release date could just be Nintendo's thing, or the hopeful/earliest expected release date of both/either game.
If Nintendo and Namco Bandai were really expecting this game to come out, it would just say "Release Date: 2014" on the Dojo.
Melee wasn't really delayed, and if it was it wasn't by much. Melee was released a month after the launch of the Gamecube in NA, two months in JP, and not even a month in EU.
The NA release date of the GCN was delayed hardcore. That is part of the reason the GCN was such a gigantic commercial bomb. The Xbox came out a few days before, and the PS2 had already taken any market Nintendo could have had, especially since Nintendo's marketing direction was awful back then (despite having what IMO is probably their 2nd best home console).
And yes, Melee was suppose to be a Japanese GCN launch title, but it wasn't, because it was delayed over 2 months.
This game won't release in 2015 like you suggest it should.
Games. GAMES. GAMES!!!! There are TWO forthcoming Smash games, and Namco Bandai is making them to be different games. Last I checked, two games are much harder to make then one, unless we got some bullcrap version thing going on like with Pokémahnzs.
Thinking and wanting it to release in 2015 is just needless and stupid, there's a difference between cleaning the game up and nitpicking the game to perfection, which they won't do.
"A delayed game may eventually become good; a bad game is bad forever." -Shigeru Miyamoto
Nintendo can't afford to delay it to 2015 right now,
Then why did Nintendo afford to hold off Mario Kart 8 and DKC: Tropical Freeze to 2014=???
Last I checked, Mario Kart is a bigger and better seller than Smash. Mario Kart Wii sold more than 3 times as many copies as Brawl.
Also, how can you accurately forecast Q4 2014 right now=??? I'm not even sure we can accurately Q4 2013 right now, given how the Xbox One and PS4 basically have dreadful launch titles and literally nothing to work with, and judging by what I'm hearing, those consoles are a giant mess right now.
I'd say Nintendo has a lot of time, actually, since the whole DRM dealio may have screwed over both Microsoft and Sony.
Delaying games won't always make them perfect, it can make them better, but there's no reason to delay the game beyond what it needs to, especially considering both the 3DS and Wii U are very capable of being patched.
There's what I was looking for. I knew you'd save the knockout punch for the end silly billy.
While I am perfectly okay with this, ultimately, in release date forecasting I don't see Namco Bandai or Nintendo being happy with this. On top of that, from what I can tell of the early 2015, that looks to be a weak spot for the PS4 and Xbox One potentially. Saving Smash, Pokémon Wii U, or Zelda Wii U for then might be a good idea.