• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Casual Tier List

Xandercosm

Smash Lord
Joined
Jun 23, 2015
Messages
1,425
Location
the nearest neutron star!
NNID
vineto
I think it might be fun to come up with a casual tier list. Everyone make your own tier lists and we'll see what characters people agree are the best/worst in casual play. Have fun!

Here's mine:

S::4bowser::4ganondorf::4falcon::4littlemac:
A::4charizard::4dk::4sonic::4myfriends::4dedede::4mario::4ness::4cloud::4feroy:
B::4jigglypuff::4wario2::4villager::rosalina::4shulk::4mewtwo::4kirby::4link::4tlink:
C::4samus::4luigi::4lucario::4metaknight::4megaman::4yoshi::4rob::4bowserjr::4fox::4gaw::4pacman:
D::4zss::4pikachu::4peach::4falco::4duckhunt::4marth::4lucina::4lucas::4darkpit::4pit:
F::4greninja::4zelda::4drmario::4ryu::4wiifit::4palutena::4robinm::4olimar::4sheik:

That's my rough first draft. Tell me if I missed any characters.
 
Last edited:

ryuu seika

Smash Master
Joined
Jul 21, 2010
Messages
4,743
Location
Amidst the abounding light of heaven!
Ganondorf is good in casual play but not Falcon good, I'd bump him down to high A. Bowser, on the other hand, is a wall and totally deserves his placement. DK should probably swap places with Shulk, if only because of how spammable his extra good counter is and the fact that DK never seems to be that much of a threat.
Yoshi can lose a tier for how bad the Wii U and 3DS versions are at handling non-90 degree angles of the stick and MetaKnight can join him in D for his terrible hitboxes (simply atrocious), while BJr can probably move up to top of C. Speaking of moving up in C, Pikach and Lucina can join the bottom of that tier as both are pretty newbie friendly and decent fighters.
Oh and Ness should be about C also due to how quickly he dies if you get past his wall of B moves.

Mostly a decent list though.
 

FamilyTeam

This strength serves more than me alone.
Joined
Nov 15, 2015
Messages
2,332
Location
South America
NNID
MontanaCity
I'm going to make a massively different list, but still basing it off on another kind of casual mentality: Prioritizing the character itself first, then taking into consideration how they actually play.
To make a casual tier list, you need to take a lot into consideration: How easy a character is, how strong are their moves, how easily they can be abused (like camping or spamming, which in general inexperienced players can't deal with) how good is their recovery, how good they look, their gender, what series they come from, what weapons they use, how big they are, and pretty much every single ridiculous reason you can think of.
People legit think Peach from Melee is the worst character in the game because it's Peach. And she's a girl. And a princess. And wears pink. That automatically means she's weak and thus can't compare to the likes of Bowser or Kirby or hyuuugh I can't stand saying this crap even ironically.
Using that logic, to me, a tier list a casual would make would look like this:

S:
:4ganondorf::4bowser::4charizard::4littlemac::4falcon::4cloud::4myfriends::4feroy:
A:
:4villager::4dk::4mewtwo::4link::4duckhunt::4megaman::4luigi::4mario::4sonic::4metaknight::4lucario:
B:
:4kirby::4gaw::4samus::4dedede::4shulk::4rob::4falco::4fox::4greninja:
C:
:4darkpit::4pit::4drmario::4robinm:
D:
:4lucina::4marth::4pikachu::4bowserjr::4olimar::4pacman:
E:
:4ryu::4zss::4diddy::4tlink::4peach::rosalina::4zelda::4sheik::4palutena::4ness::4lucas::4jigglypuff::4wiifit:
:4ganondorf:'s Smashes and Specials are ridiculously strong. Inexperienced players can't dodge nor combo efficiently, and Ganondorf can't easily be KO'd with regular moves alone, so he is basically uncounterable. The exact same things happen with :4bowser:and :4charizard:, however, since not every single one of their Specials is a kill move, they're lower.
:4littlemac: and :4falcon: are extremely fast and have extremely large potential to output damage. Mac is higher because he's easier to play, and KO Punch is almost always a 1HKO.
:4cloud:Cloud's sword is MASSIVE so he's awesome. He also has really rad hair, comes from one of the most popular FF games, and is easy to play. Insta top tier.
:4feroy: has a sword that can spontaneously combust, and he wears cool red and blue armour and has wild red hair. Some random Johnny also probably will hear from the Internets that Roy's Neutral Special can 1HKO and tell his friends, which means he's automatically god-like and thus people will spam that move trying to get the maximum charged hit thinking it's easy. HOWEVER, :4myfriends:looks all buff in this game, which automatically means he's stronger.
:4villager:spamming is so easy with this dude!
:4dk: is a gorilla and Neutral Special is a charge-up move, so of course he's strong.
:4mewtwo: is a legendary and "THE MOST POWERFUL POKEMON IN THE WORLD!" (not really) and a Gen 1 Pokemon, gotta be strong.
:4link:is massively cool, has very strong Smashes and can spam easily.
:4duckhunt: probably wouldn't be played much because he's such a bizarre character, but once someone picks him up and notices you can camp with him, and, of course, camping is uncouterable, he'd be held as one of the best characters in the game.
:4megaman: is strong and is Megaman.
:4luigi:is the same as Mario but his Down Special isn't useless, right, right?!
:4mario:is really fast and you can just spam fireballs and Smashes and win. Too bad his Down Special is useless, right?
:4sonic:is even faster and you can just spam Specials and Smashes and win. Too bad his games are worse than Mario's, right?
:4metaknight:has a cool sword, voice and mask, too bad he actually takes skill to play, eh?
:4lucario:has aura which is awesome and he is so strong and such a cool Pokemon!
:4kirby::GCD::GCB:
:4gaw::GCR::GCB: until you get a 9.
:4samus:spam, but she's slow and a woman!
:4dedede:
spam, but he's slow and a fat penguin!
:4shulk:
he has a totally rad massive sword with a lightsabre inside! Too bad he's so slow!
:4rob:is a robot that fires big lasers and looks really creepy and cool.
:4falco:is rad, his Down Special makes people trip, you can spam lasers to stun people, but he runs so slow!
:4fox:he's the exact same thing as Falco, except he runs faster but his laser doesn't stun! Awww!
:4greninja:he's the best Gen 6 starter, but how the hell do you use him, you can't spam anything properly!
:4darkpit:what the hell is this anime character? At least he looks cool, unlike :4pit:! What anime did they escape from, seriously?! And they both play exactly the same, I assure you there's no difference at all!
:4drmario:is strong, but he almost can't recover when compared to Mario, and his pills are harder to aim so I can't spam! Awwwwww!
:4robinm:there are too many damn anime characters in this game! This dude has some weird bent sword, and you can spam his magic but not nearly as easily as the others! UUUUUGH!
:4lucina:who the hell is this anime woman?! I know she's really fast and strong and easy to use, but she's an anime woman, and I can't even spam with her!
:4marth:what?! This is the exact same thing as the other anime woman but she hits even weaker! I can't deal more damage with her at all! This woman sucks in comparison to the other anime woman! Why does she exist if I can't deal more damage with her? Why does the tip of her sword shines when you swing it, it doesn't make any sense!
:4pikachu:it's a Pikachu, no way he's stronger than the strongest Pokemon ever, :4mewtwo:, or the second strongest, :4charizard:.
:4bowserjr:it's a baby! And how on Earth are you supposed to spam with his projectiles?!
:4olimar:how in bloody hell do you use him?
:4pacman:I hate all of these complicated characters that have these projectiles you can't spam!
:4ryu:people say Shoryuken kills early, but I don't see it! They say it's an "input" Shoryuken, but I input :GCU::GCB: like you're supposed to and it's so weak!
:4zss: another woman I can't spam with!
:4diddy:his moves are so weak and you can't recover!
:4tlink:it's Link, but a child! How on earth is he in the roster when Link is clearly a much better character!
:4peach::4zelda:they're princesses, they must be so weak!
:rosalina:atleast I can use the other stupid princesses!
:4sheik:weakest man in the game! I can't spam and his Smashes all suck!
:4palutena:a damn anime woman that I can't use and it's really hard to spam with her!
:4ness::4lucas:they're children! And how the hell do you recover with them?!
:4jigglypuff:it'd a female balloon, of course it sucks! Down Special does nothing, it literally puts you to sleep!
:4wiifit:IT'S A DAMN YOGA TEACHER, THIS SUCKS!
Well... actually this looks more like "What would a tier list look like if an 8 year old made one", but I guess they count as casuals?
 

Xandercosm

Smash Lord
Joined
Jun 23, 2015
Messages
1,425
Location
the nearest neutron star!
NNID
vineto
Ganondorf is good in casual play but not Falcon good, I'd bump him down to high A. Bowser, on the other hand, is a wall and totally deserves his placement. DK should probably swap places with Shulk, if only because of how spammable his extra good counter is and the fact that DK never seems to be that much of a threat.
Yoshi can lose a tier for how bad the Wii U and 3DS versions are at handling non-90 degree angles of the stick and MetaKnight can join him in D for his terrible hitboxes (simply atrocious), while BJr can probably move up to top of C. Speaking of moving up in C, Pikach and Lucina can join the bottom of that tier as both are pretty newbie friendly and decent fighters.
Oh and Ness should be about C also due to how quickly he dies if you get past his wall of B moves.

Mostly a decent list though.
Why do you say "Meta Knight has bad hitboxes"?
 
Last edited:

FamilyTeam

This strength serves more than me alone.
Joined
Nov 15, 2015
Messages
2,332
Location
South America
NNID
MontanaCity
Because you need a certain level of finesse to use him.
Finesse not being a quality most people who don't play this game seriously have.
That's why they think Peach and Marth sucks, they don't understand how her items work nor that you have to hit with the tip of the bloody sword.
 

Xandercosm

Smash Lord
Joined
Jun 23, 2015
Messages
1,425
Location
the nearest neutron star!
NNID
vineto
Because you need a certain level of finesse to use him.
Finesse not being a quality most people who don't play this game seriously have.
That's why they think Peach and Marth sucks, they don't understand how her items work nor that you have to hit with the tip of the bloody sword.
I get it.

I liked your casual character descriptions, by the way. My favorite is Marth's... :smirk:
 

FamilyTeam

This strength serves more than me alone.
Joined
Nov 15, 2015
Messages
2,332
Location
South America
NNID
MontanaCity
New Yeah, Lucina is basically Marth for n00bs, hence why she should be rated noticeably higher here out of the two.
Sadly, little 8 year Johnny probably would look at Lucina and never use her since she's an anime girl from some game he's never heard of, really.
 

ZephyrYoshi

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Aug 31, 2014
Messages
252
NNID
Smashwidget
speaking as someone who remembers their casual days (and is still semi-casual), I favored characters with strong smashes over pretty much anything else.
Casual players also don't really know how to properly shield or roll. I really think Lucario would be at least A+ tier since he gets stronger with damage.

Jigglypuff is bottom-tier if you don't know how to space or if you don't know what rest does.


Sadly, little 8 year Johnny probably would look at Lucina and never use her since she's an anime girl from some game he's never heard of, really.
little 10 year old me had never heard of any of the series in Brawl outside of Mario and Pokemon. I still used the characters because I liked how they played.
 
Last edited:

FamilyTeam

This strength serves more than me alone.
Joined
Nov 15, 2015
Messages
2,332
Location
South America
NNID
MontanaCity
little 10 year old me had never heard of any of the series in Brawl outside of Mario and Pokemon. I still used the characters because I liked how they played.
Some of us were less averse to the idea of playing some character we didn't know, some of us weren't. I actually liked the characters I had no idea where they came from (Mr. G&W, Cpt. Falcon, Ness), but some of my friends wouldn't even look twice at characters like Marth or Ice Climbers.
 

WinterShorts

The best NEOH Yoshi
Joined
Apr 5, 2014
Messages
1,777
Location
Akron
NNID
Jelwshuman
3DS FC
4382-2513-9345
So from one quick look, I'm seeing it as the worst characters are S-tier and vice-versa, mostly. I mean I'm seeing Shiek, considered one of the best characters in the game if not the best, is now considered the worst, and Bowser, who not really one of the worst chars but is still low-tier, is the best character in the game on your list (Now that we can all agree on :p)
 

blackghost

Smash Champion
Joined
Jul 9, 2015
Messages
2,249
That's moot when you bring every item in the vicinity to you with the press of a button.
basically this. looking at these lists im a litle surprised that villager and palutena are both so low. in a 4 person ffa with items palutena has a reflector and a counter. thats extrmely valuable. plus her usmash and fsmash are huge thats a huge plus. a lot of players ted to underestimate causual players they do know defensive specials are amzing in items.
for me personally
in s tier is rosalina, ganon, bowser, lil mac, cloud, fox, ike, and villager and roy. heavy hitters, high wieght or item control are the top factors in a free for all.
 

Kurri ★

#PlayUNIST
Joined
Nov 22, 2014
Messages
11,026
Location
Palm Beach FL
Switch FC
7334-0298-1902
I don't see how a casual tier list would be anymore different than a regular one. The top tiers still have more options than the bottom ones and once the player knows how to get around the various gimmicks of items it's pretty much whatever.

Anyways:

S: :4zss::4palutena:
F: Everyone else
 

MarioMeteor

Smash Hero
Joined
Nov 27, 2014
Messages
8,340
Location
New Orleans
NNID
BGenius23
3DS FC
0662-2900-1492
You're right! How silly of me to put the Goddess of Light, Lady Palutena, in S tier with Zero Suit Samus. Obviously she should be put in SSS+ tier due to her divinity.
If divinity alone gets you to SSS+ then Rosalina must be in SSSSS in tier.
 

NewFoundAbility

Banned via Warnings
Joined
Jan 3, 2015
Messages
105
Location
Dublin, CA 94568, bowing down before the Jlfksjlfl
NNID
NewFoundAbility
I personally would say:4pikachu: should not be on there/is not much a casual character (compared to 64 and Brawl's version), as it didn't appeal to me personally to play him on a casual level.
While I would bump :4robinm:/:4robinf: up to A or S, as I love the moveset, it really is fun to use when goofing around.

Also, you forgot to put :4zss:on the list as a potential B or A, because I picked her up during a friendly a few days ago and I honestly found her kind of fun for a while. The only thing I don't like his her Dair -- I'd rather her Down-Air be like Lucario's imho. But that's just me
 

Xandercosm

Smash Lord
Joined
Jun 23, 2015
Messages
1,425
Location
the nearest neutron star!
NNID
vineto
You're right! How silly of me to put the Goddess of Light, Lady Palutena, in S tier with Zero Suit Samus. Obviously she should be put in SSS+ tier due to her divinity.
Funny. Palutena is pretty bad in casual play, at least from what I've seen. She's very light, so characters like Bowser and Ganondorf kill her super early, her recovery is hard to control, and I don't feel like casual players would care much for her specials.
 

wedl!!

Goddess of Storms
Joined
Jan 2, 2014
Messages
2,159
Location
Soul Realm
NNID
Plushies4Ever
But... they do ****loads of damage and are big and fast.

Plus, he's heavy and lives long. You don't need Ryu's inputs for him to do work against bad players.
 

TyDye

Crash Bandicoot for Smash!
Joined
Jan 25, 2016
Messages
264
Location
Hartland, Wisconsin
So from one quick look, I'm seeing it as the worst characters are S-tier and vice-versa, mostly. I mean I'm seeing Shiek, considered one of the best characters in the game if not the best, is now considered the worst, and Bowser, who not really one of the worst chars but is still low-tier, is the best character in the game on your list (Now that we can all agree on :p)
At least in my experience. Casual / New players tend to lean towards heavy hitters. In Smash 4 Ike, Little Mac, Cloud. And stay away from characters with higher learning curves such as Jigglypuff or Shulk saying that they are garbage characters. So for the most part yea, you just flip the legitimate tier list.
 

FamilyTeam

This strength serves more than me alone.
Joined
Nov 15, 2015
Messages
2,332
Location
South America
NNID
MontanaCity
Another example I'll use is that, in a casual's eyes, the Ice Climbers are useless. If you don't know how to use them, they're basically a really complicated character with double the hitbox of a regular one, a recovery awkward to use, and in case your partner dies, you're left with someone with not horizontal recovery that can't hold much ground on its own.
 

marteen_

Smash Cadet
Joined
Jan 19, 2016
Messages
33
Location
Maryland
NNID
martinthelee
Kirby should be higher. No casual knows how to oppose the power of Rock Kirby.

The Pits, Wario, and Bowser Jr should also be up there because casuals think Side Bs like those are godlike approach moves.

I think everyone forgets that many casual players spam the **** out of their specials too.
 
Last edited:

FamilyTeam

This strength serves more than me alone.
Joined
Nov 15, 2015
Messages
2,332
Location
South America
NNID
MontanaCity
No casual knows how to oppose the power of Rock Kirby.
That is extremely true.
If only you could grab Kirby out of his Down B, eh? Too bad we didn't knew this when we weren't serious about the game.
 

monado_man

Smash Rookie
Joined
Jan 27, 2016
Messages
1
Location
Houston
Kirby should be higher. No casual knows how to oppose the power of Rock Kirby.
Definitely. Its insane how much casuals use rock kirby, or really any move that shoots them quickly to the ground and attacks (there might be a a technical term for moves like this, but whatever), also kirby has his down-b hammer, which has lots of damage and knock back, so casuals love it. Kirby should really be at least A tier.
 

blackghost

Smash Champion
Joined
Jul 9, 2015
Messages
2,249
At least in my experience. Casual / New players tend to lean towards heavy hitters. In Smash 4 Ike, Little Mac, Cloud. And stay away from characters with higher learning curves such as Jigglypuff or Shulk saying that they are garbage characters. So for the most part yea, you just flip the legitimate tier list.
well causuals and hardcore agree on those characters then. but i'd argue and counter is amaing in ffa/casual play. and shulk (currently) has the best counter.
causuals also (in my experience) want a character with recovery ability. lil mac dies wehen getting hit once with a vafriety of items offstag.
thier are cuausals out there that use stage, assist trophy,pkemon, and item knowledge better than half the tournment players i've seen don't think mac would be a high tier. he dies too easily in the choas.
 

Tizio Random

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Sep 7, 2015
Messages
478
Location
Italy
NNID
TizioRandom
Switch FC
SW 1700 2165 1827
I made this like yesterday lol

S Tier is godly in FFAs because of powerful smashes + range and heavyweights aside from Mac but he has super armor and stupidly spammable strong attacks. Gradually this merits will become less and less prominent, aside from characters like RosaLuma that has gravitational pull + two characters and WFT that can just camp with Sun Salutation.
 

Xandercosm

Smash Lord
Joined
Jun 23, 2015
Messages
1,425
Location
the nearest neutron star!
NNID
vineto
At least in my experience. Casual / New players tend to lean towards heavy hitters. In Smash 4 Ike, Little Mac, Cloud. And stay away from characters with higher learning curves such as Jigglypuff or Shulk saying that they are garbage characters. So for the most part yea, you just flip the legitimate tier list.
But Shulk and Jigglypuff are garbage...
 

TyDye

Crash Bandicoot for Smash!
Joined
Jan 25, 2016
Messages
264
Location
Hartland, Wisconsin
Well, I think she's very fun and unique. However, I quite honestly think she's the worst character in competitive play.
Which is fine.

I have seen plenty of players take low tiered characters and stomp their way through tournament. Tier list are nothing more than a suggestion on which characters have the most potential to do well in tournament. Based on which characters players have placed highest with in said tournaments; which is why tier list are always changing. If a character isn't used in tournament they will automatically be considered low tier.However in the hands of a player who as mastered that character, any character can be used at tournament level and beat top tier characters.

Hell Puff was considered one of the worst characters in Melee until Mango and Hungrybox started using her. Now she is top tier in Melee.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom