Bad Idea Mafia 2018: Hot, Hot Summer Shootout! — Game Over! Who kept cool in the land of heated conversations?

[vaanrose]

what happened to this reaction?

Rule 10 is "Be nice to other players and don't insult them!"

That was my tongue-in-cheek way of expressing disapproval with Shish's quickbang

 

[Coricus]

what kind of dice did you use?

Split second decision making based on nothing, LOL

Although thinking on it I do have a tux colored set of unused D&D dice with little dragons on them that might have helped in retrospect. Too bad I'll probably forget to ever use the D20 for Mafia LOL

 

[#HBC | Kary]

That was my tongue-in-cheek way of expressing disapproval with Shish's quickbang

okay. It doesn't really read as joking to me but I'll take your word for it.

Did you learn anything from Day 1 or is there nothing there?

 

[vaanrose]

okay. It doesn't really read as joking to me but I'll take your word for it.

Did you learn anything from Day 1 or is there nothing there?

The disapproval was real, just the method of expressing it was a joke.

Day 1 was over before I even showed up, so I wasn't able to talk with anybody. But it was pointed out that mafia wins the moment town runs out of guns, which means they don't actually need to achieve majority, just take out all our shooters. That's probably why they took out Shish instead of firing blindly into the town, especially since Shish would have been an easy target for town to misbang, imo.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

Split second decision making based on nothing, LOL

Although thinking on it I do have a tux colored set of unused D&D dice with little dragons on them that might have helped in retrospect. Too bad I'll probably forget to ever use the D20 for Mafia LOL

Okie dokie. One last thing. Do you always end your sentences with "LOL" ? It's not something I recall from last time.

 

[Coricus]

Okie dokie. One last thing. Do you always end your sentences with "LOL" ? It's not something I recall from last time.

It varies. Tends to come out a lot less when I'm focused on something and this game has a lot less meat to the roles to keep an eye on, so that probably factors.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

But it was pointed out that mafia wins the moment town runs out of guns,

where? thanks.

 

[vaanrose]

where? thanks.

So it was actually pre-game, but I hadn't read it til I was going through the thread yesterday.

Does the game auto end as a Mafia win if all Just Some Townies die?

Yep.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

For clarity: if town has no more shooters, they can't kill any more mafia, meaning mafia would nightkill without repercussions until achieving parity with town. So, town losing all shooters naturally extrapolates to a mafia win, and therefore the game ends immediately when that occurs.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

aight good talk

Vote: Yellowlord

 

[Natz~]

yo back

had some fun~

can see i didn't really miss much :V

aight good talk

Vote: Yellowlord

uuuuuuuuh theres no lynch :V only day vigs

if ya wanna get someone killed ya gotta shoot them

 

[Natz~]

speaking of which we only got 4 guns yikes

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Also I see vaan has a crush on Natz~.

Ummm... How?

[USER=288353]Illuminati confirmed.

Opo's already part of this game, so I guess that's not false :V

As someone with Asperger's, I take offense to that...

I am sorry.

She definitely didn't mean it that way because she'd be offending herself too.

Also, hi everyone.

 

[Maven89]

All bombs should claim. Bombs don’t go off at night so there’s no theat for the mafia killing then

 

[Fire Emblemier]

All bombs should claim. Bombs don’t go off at night so there’s no theat for the mafia killing then

If all bomb's claim it makes it much easier for mafia to target those with guns. Having the mafia kill them at night is better than the townies or cops as it both defuses a threat against town without it backfiring, and makes trying to kill the vigs a little harder. It does run the risk of town or even the day mafia guy shooting a bomb though. Thinking on it both options are risky though.

 

[Maven89]

If all bomb's claim it makes it much easier for mafia to target those with guns. Having the mafia kill them at night is better than the townies or cops as it both defuses a threat against town without it backfiring, and makes trying to kill the vigs a little harder. It does run the risk of town or even the day mafia guy shooting a bomb though. Thinking on it both options are risky though.

There’s only one mafia with a gun and him targeting the bombs out him

 

[Natz~]

There’s only one mafia with a gun and him targeting the bombs out him

3 townies dead for 1 mafia? i'll ****ing pass thankie

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

All bombs should claim. Bombs don’t go off at night so there’s no theat for the mafia killing then

Can’t really prove it without dying during the day, which means my “shut up until I have proof” playstyle really doesn’t work here so...

Yo.

If all bomb's claim it makes it much easier for mafia to target those with guns. Having the mafia kill them at night is better than the townies or cops as it both defuses a threat against town without it backfiring, and makes trying to kill the vigs a little harder. It does run the risk of town or even the day mafia guy shooting a bomb though. Thinking on it both options are risky though.

A bomb revealing itself would be safer than a bomb being quiet.

Mafia has no point killing them at night because they’re not able to blow up at night and are neither cops nor day vigs. It’s essentially a waste of a kill.

And shooting a known bomb during the day does nothing but incriminate oneself as bombs bring a random townie with them.

 

[Natz~]

actaully, no thats FOUR townies dead for 1 mafia

cause we need a gun to kill the mafia ******* putting out that townie as well, so he des the next night

thats the game right there if the bombs claim

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

actaully, no thats FOUR townies dead for 1 mafia

cause we need a gun to kill the mafia ******* putting out that townie as well, so he des the next night

thats the game right there if the bombs claim

No, it’s three.

The bomb, the person killed in the explosion and the night kill.

 

[Natz~]

Can’t really prove it without dying during the day, which means my “shut up until I have proof” playstyle really doesn’t work here so...

Yo.


A bomb revealing itself would be safer than a bomb being quiet.

Mafia has no point killing them at night because they’re not able to blow up at night and are neither cops nor day vigs. It’s essentially a waste of a kill.

And shooting a known bomb during the day does nothing but incriminate oneself as bombs bring a random townie with them.

uni think before ya out yourself dude -.-

you revealing could of just now cost us the game if the mafia gun man shoots you

cause then you die, someone else dies, the mafia kills, and one off us guns has to reveal themselves to shoot the guy who shot ya

way a go dude ya lost us the game :V

 

[Natz~]

No, it’s three.

The bomb, the person killed in the explosion and the night kill.

ya not counting the next night, where someone has to shoot your killer

their outed and dies the next night putting mafia one more step closer to victory

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

uni think before ya out yourself dude -.-

you revealing could of just now cost us the game if the mafia gun man shoots you

cause then you die, someone else dies, the mafia kills, and one off us guns has to reveal themselves to shoot the guy who shot ya

way a go dude ya lost us the game :V

Did I?

If the mafia with a gun shoots me, you guys can take them out the next day, which removes the possibility of them ending a phase early.

 

[Natz~]

Did I?

If the mafia with a gun shoots me, you guys can take them out the next day, which removes the possibility of them ending a phase early.

and the guy who shoots them? wheres his protection? they become revealed in the flavor :V meaning mafia has a clear shot to killing another of our gun

ya outing yourself literally gave away the possiblity of removing 3 of 4 of our guns that remain

meaning we only have 1 gun to kill two mafia

and the moment he shoots? hes revealed by the flavor and he dies the next night

ya lost us the gun dimwit

 

[Fire Emblemier]

Also the Hotfather could easily claim that they're a bomb and look town on a cop check, meaning that if 3 people claim bomb, there's only a 1/3 possibility of them dying, while also having the possible reward of killing 2 townies that day, if town chooses poorly.

Even the vanilla mafia member could easily claim bomb, just running the risk of a cop check, but they're not guaranteed to be checked if the cops rather check one of the actual bombs or someone else completely unrelated.

 

[Natz~]

ah so uni being dumb could just be an example of him lying off his ass :V

 

[LoneKonWolf]

Lets ignore this for now and focus more on other matters. . .

 

[Natz~]

i didn't know ya wanted to talk about that konnie :V

 

[LoneKonWolf]

Don't. If you do I'm disowning you.

 

[Natz~]

k~k~

so what are your thoughts then?

 

[LoneKonWolf]

Curiosity more or less. I assume you think the same?

 

[Natz~]

......no :V

 

[LoneKonWolf]

Sigh. . . .

 

[Deleted member]

What is going on?

Either way....

Bonne journée tout le monde!

 

[Natz~]

well....fire has been more or less on point with me :V
uni i think is an idiot or lying his ass off
shimachu is dead
kary kinda pushed us off for good reason
shish is also dead
maven is maven
your a konnie
oppo is weird to not see him pop up at all
i am me~
vaan is vaan
woomy protects me out of worry
yellow is kinda avoiding things
and AmericanDJ exists and lurk

 

[LoneKonWolf]

What is going on?

Either way....

Bonne journée tout le monde!

Nothing of your concern. Outsider.

 

[Deleted member]

Nothing of your concern. Outsider.

I have a pass.

 

[LoneKonWolf]

well....fire has been more or less on point with me :V
uni i think is an idiot or lying his *** off
shimachu is dead
kary kinda pushed us off for good reason
shish is also dead
maven is maven
your a konnie
oppo is weird to not see him pop up at all
i am me~
vaan is vaan
woomy protects me out of worry
yellow is kinda avoiding things
and AmericanDJ exists and lurk

Hm. . . Alright then have the ones lurking come out to say a few words then

That means you Opossum and Yellowlord .

 

[LoneKonWolf]

I have a pass.

Congratulations. The same phrase echos.

 

[Maven89]

There are two bombs, if more than two claim we have a guaranteed scum in the mix that we can narrow down to. Otherwise we have the potential of shooting a bomb and gaining nothing. I still want all the bombs to claim