Eggm
Smash Hero
We relaly should lol, md/va counts as one..
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Spending 9 outta 12 months in a state usually constitutes a residency. Also, I'd rather go to an NJ tournament and I actively compete in NJ an and am a member of a NJ-based crew. So I guess I should be considered an NJ smasher too.Last I checked, I was still in charge of NJ's list, not JFox or anyone else.................
I see no reason to put LK on PA's list if he's completely irrelevant to PA. Given a chance to go an NJ tourny or a PA tourny, he'd pick the NJ tourny, and he's going to actively compete in NJ and is in an NJ based crew. Going to college in PA =/= resident of PA.
ChumpMoney, I'm free during that day on Wednesday, and I think teh_spamerer can come over.
Last I checked, you were never solely in charge of NJ's list.Last I checked, I was still in charge of NJ's list, not JFox or anyone else.................
This list was created by Reik, Sadaharu Inui, and AlexanderTriad. (6/22/07)
That would be fair for pretty much everyone except For those in Central and Western PA. Those in shippensburg and Pittsburgh have their locals and for them to travel on a regular basis would involve upwards of 2 hours for ship and like 4 for pitt for our usual NJ tournaments.Do we really need concrete rules if everyone agrees on an exception? I mean if no one is going to complain in our community who cares? Who else besides us looks at it lol, Anyways we should seriously fuse the NJ/PA rankings that would be an awesome list to try and work our way up as a community, we could also compete for best region that way with md/va. xDD
I aint no joining no ractangerlar staateNJ/PA should fuse so its like Md/va lol. Now THAT would b a competitive power rankings list. xD
At least we can pump our own gas and turn left.I aint no joining no ractangerlar staate
You sure cared enough about it to post about the issue, only to say you don't and "walk away." Don't care? Don't post.Uhhhhh. I thought it was alreaady decided that where a person competes decides what list they are on.
So if Reik and LK compete in NJ and not PA then doesn't that justify what list they are on?
And wouldn't that make the most sense anyway?
But ummm ultimately. I don't think LK and Reik even give a ****.
And you know something else?
Neither do I.
*walks out of thread
roflmao, I say stuff like that sometimes. uh ohz, I need to catch up in points. WoZ, did you add $500 to the prize pot of singles AND the prize pot of doubles or $250 to each? Also, who's in charge of keeping those 10% cuts from each circuit event pot?WoZ said:You sure cared enough about it to post about the issue, only to say you don't and "walk away." Don't care? Don't post.
No. I feel the same way about Reik, I just obviously feel more strongly when it comes to LK because he's probably my closest local friend. LK is completely irrelevant to PA's Smash scene, and PA's Smash scene is inactive in general. Ranking him as a PA Smasher because he goes to college in Eastern PA doesn't seem like the right thing to do if he's an active NJ Smasher. The same goes for Reik.Uhh, last I checked Inui, I have just as much say about the rankings as you do. And for the communities information, I have been pulling all of the weight around here. I have been archiving any and all tournaments that NJ players are involved in while you fell way behind to doing your part. AND I made the rules, which you and everyone else agreed to, until you realized that one of them was inconvient for your crew member. Its inconvient for my crew member too, but I'm not being a little girl about it. You are acting totally biased and trying to force change simply so that I can make an exception for your benefit.
Please Inui, propose a rule that would allow LK to stay with the NJ list. Be very clear and concise with this rule, just as I have with my own. I'd be happy to shoot it down for you will plenty of past examples of inconsistencies.
MMM that post tasted like sunshine and farts.The big ugly fat fly is attracted to garbage.
The big ugly fat fly is also pretty sexy.
Inui you are making far too many assumptions. LK is most likely not even going to be able to fit the criteria to be on the rankings at all, because he will be so busy with school. And arguing that he has and always will be an NJ player is senseless. Pretty soon he will be smashing with the PA players like Cactuar and Pakman, and many others. Its true, he might go to a few NJ tourneys, but its not likely that he will go to NJ exclusively.No. I feel the same way about Reik, I just obviously feel more strongly when it comes to LK because he's probably my closest local friend. LK is completely irrelevant to PA's Smash scene, and PA's Smash scene is inactive in general. Ranking him as a PA Smasher because he goes to college in Eastern PA doesn't seem like the right thing to do if he's an active NJ Smasher. The same goes for Reik.
There doesn't need to be a rule. LK doesn't compete in PA. LK has always competed in NJ. He still actively competes in NJ. His home is in NJ. It makes perfect sense to rank him as an NJ player. The panelists should be able to think about things and make the right decisions without a bunch of rules.
Inui Logic FTL.No. I feel the same way about Reik, I just obviously feel more strongly when it comes to LK because he's probably my closest local friend. LK is completely irrelevant to PA's Smash scene, and PA's Smash scene is inactive in general. Ranking him as a PA Smasher because he goes to college in Eastern PA doesn't seem like the right thing to do if he's an active NJ Smasher. The same goes for Reik.
There doesn't need to be a rule. LK doesn't compete in PA. LK has always competed in NJ. He still actively competes in NJ. His home is in NJ. It makes perfect sense to rank him as an NJ player. The panelists should be able to think about things and make the right decisions without a bunch of rules.
Agreed. That sounds fine to me.Right now, both LK and Reik are considered NJ players and will be ranked on the NJ list. They have qualified, and have spent the majority of their time for this season in NJ actively competing. So why don't we just focus on ranking them for this season, and than we can worry about the next season in 3-4 months from now. We can see how their tournament activity is, and make a judgement call later.
Wow. Rational, thought out, and well articulated. You get a gold star.Why don't we just focus on ranking them for this season, and than we can worry about the next season in 3-4 months from now. We can see how their tournament activity is, and make a judgement call later.