Who's deserving of the spot?

[punkomatic622]

Hey guys.

Who deserves to be in Brawl who isn't already?

Who deserves to be kicked out who has already made the cut?


My opinion:

Deserves to make it - Captain Olimar

Deserves to leave - Lucas + Ice Climbers

 

[Big-Cat]

Deserve to make it- Krystal, Claus, Kumatora, Ridley, Geno, Captain Syrup, and Marth
Deserve to leave - Lucas as he is now. He shouldn't be a cop out like Ness.

 

[Sabrewulf238]

Deserves to make it - Bomberman, Ness, Midna, Stafy, animal crossing rep, jigglypuff and mewtwo.

Deserves to leave - Nobody

 

[Lgndknight]

your sig Pwns punkomatic

should get in: Caprain Falcon, Ganon
Leave:Nobody

 

[Shuma]

Ridley, Geno, Claus, Issac, Black Knight, Wolf. and Remaining vets.

 

[SubparSmashBrother]

In: Ridley, C. Olimar, Paper Mario, WW Link, Mii

Out: Krystal (I know shes not technically confirmed, but still...)

 

[KiddyDong]

Needs to come in- Ray 01, Megaman,

Needs to get out- Ice Climbers, Zelda

 

[LemonKing]

Deserves to be in - Ridley, Geno, Claus, Black Knight
Deserves to be out - Pichu, Young Link, Roy

 

[punkomatic622]

your sig Pwns punkomatic

should get in: Caprain Falcon, Ganon
Leave:Nobody

thanks. it took me forever to find the right clips.

 

[Bassoonist]

Deserves to make it: Isaac, Captain Olimar, Geno, Megaman, Ridley, Krystal... I could go on.
Deserves to be kicked out: Nobody.

 

[Collective of Bears]

In: Jimmy T. and Shy Guy
Out: Zero Suit Samus and Sonic

 

[the_Capt_Falcon_Master]

in: chibi-robo

out: no one yet

and unfortunatly there are already a bunch of threads like this

 

[punkomatic622]

In: Jimmy T. and Shy Guy
Out: Zero Suit Samus and Sonic

I think you're the only person on earth who wants sonic AND samus out.

 

[Momocop]

IN: Crystal, Knuckles, Rayman, Banjo&Kazooe, Lucario, Blaziken, Lloyd, Emphraim, And Every other SSBM Vet.

Out: Pichu, Lucas (Ness FTW)

 

[raul]

I really feel like the Nintendo Miis deserve a spot. The success of Wii sports is undeniable and they are a major part of that success. They are not only representing the Nintendo Wii but also Nintendo as a whole.

Right now, the only character I am skeptical on is Zero Suit Samus. I like the idea, but I not a big fan of transforming characters and she reminds alot of Sheik from Melee. I would have rather seen the spot go to Ridley.

 

[AlbelNox]

In: Isaac, Skull Kid/Masked Link/Oni Link, Wolf, Micaiah/Another FE character.
Out: Ice climbers, Pichu, Dr Mario, Young Link.

 

[Black/Light]

"Deserves to get in". . . .Who ever the heck Sakurai and friends choose. I don't think made up models and sprites "deserve" any thing.

 

[MysticKenji]

In: Want a list?
Out: None

 

[Machspeed]

Get in: Lucario, Knuckles, Captain Olimar, Megaman
Out: Ice Climbers, Lucas

 

[punkomatic622]

Get in: Lucario, Knuckles, Captain Olimar, Megaman
Out: Ice Climbers, Lucas

Plain and simple; you are awesome

 

[Machspeed]

Plain and simple; you are awesome

Aye, much like your sig.

 

[vesperview]

Deserves to make it: all of the ones in my sig

Deserves to leave: noone

 

[smashmaniac16]

in: pico, balloon fighter, mach rider, waligi, bowser jr., animal crosser, krystal, lucario, and ridley
veterens: game&watch, jigglypuff, mewtwo, gannondorf, luigi, cpt. falcon, falco, Marth, ness, shiek
out: dr. mario, young link
????: roy, pichu

 

[Jackbandit]

IN: SUKAPON, Black Knight, Captain Olimar,Lucario, Megaman
OUT:None

 

[y3nia659]

leave: Dr. Mario/Young Link
come in: Captain Syrup

 

[shinhed-echi]

IN: Mike (StarTropics) Little Mac PLAYABLE :/, Crono (Chrono Trigger)
Captain Syrup, Alice...

OUT: ... who am I to say who's NOT deserving?? I guess Pichu... he's just a baby Pikachu... Maybe the Doc too.

^^^^^^

I <3 Captain Syrup. :D

 

[Pluvia's other account]

Nobody deserves to be out.

And anyway, tough, they're already in.

I'm going to enjoy beating up everyone as the Ice Climbers online.

 

[punkomatic622]

i'll enjoy beating anybody up online who plays as Ice Climbers...

...No offense or anything

 

[Dragonblader1]

In: Whoever Sakurai chooses
Out: Whoever you want in (Ice Climber haters are the worst scum in the universe)

 

[Darkraid]

In: Ridley, Geno, Krystal, Megaman, Lucario, Cap. Olimar & Cap. Falcon

Out: Ice Climbers

 

[punkomatic622]

In: Ridley, Geno, Krystal, Megaman, Lucario, Cap. Olimar & Cap. Falcon

Out: Ice Climbers

Thank you my friend, you read my mind.

 

[Insurance Salesman]

In: King K. Rool

Out: Sonic (Just hate the character)

 

[Zevox]

In: Krystal, Ridley, Olimar, Mega Man, K Rool, Isaac, Midna, Micaiah, Veterans (minus Doc, Pichu, Y Link, Roy).
Out: Zero Suit Samus (shes barely acceptable IMO due to being transformation-only).

Zevox

 

[Wu Tang Gang]

Ridley, Geno, Claus, Issac, Black Knight, Wolf. and Remaining vets.

You better not want Pichu, you forgot K. Rool, Lucario needs to be on there, and Krystal replaces Falco(well, Wolf does, but you put him on your list). Also, you have her on your sig, you're the spammer general of the club, but you don't mention her??

 

[Wu Tang Gang]

In: Krystal, Ridley, Olimar, Mega Man, K Rool, Isaac, Midna, Micaiah, Veterans (minus Doc, Pichu, Y Link, Roy).
Out: Zero Suit Samus (shes barely acceptable IMO due to being transformation-only).

Zevox

Zero Suit Samus Final Smash is stupid. I'd rather temporary hyper/**** mode where all of your attacks get more power, new grey thing around your armor, and new animations for the Projectile attacks.

I hope you know you're saying minus WW/Chibi/Cell Shade/Cartoon/Wind Link here. Also, You forgot quite a few.

In: King K. Rool

Out: Sonic (Just hate the character)

That post reaks of win, and forgetting characters.

 

[Bassoonist]

I hope you know you're saying minus WW/Chibi/Cell Shade/Cartoon/Wind Link here. Also, You forgot quite a few.

Yeah, and you know why? WW Link doesn't deserve it.

 

[shinhed-echi]

Deserved to make it: Little Mac

Deserves to leave: YOU


Ice Climbers are IN and they're staying. Don't know why people thing they know who's best for Brawl.

 

[punkomatic622]

Deserved to make it: Little Mac

Deserves to leave: YOU


Ice Climbers are IN and they're staying. Don't know why people thing they know who's best for Brawl.

Hey buddy; everyone's entitled to their own opinion. I could never fight that well using the ice climbers, and i just don't like them too much.

And no, maybe we don't know who deserves to make it. But that's kind of the point of this thread. "Who do you think deserves to make the cut?". Do those words make sense to you?

 

[shinhed-echi]

Hey buddy; everyone's entitled to their own opinion. I could never fight that well using the ice climbers, and i just don't like them too much.

And no, maybe we don't know who deserves to make it. But that's kind of the point of this thread. "Who do you think deserves to make the cut?". Do those words make sense to you?

Ah I see..

I just thought you were one of those people who hated them for no real reason (other than not knowing them, popularity excuse, etc).

Even so, deserving to leave because you can't use them is not a very good excuse.

Sorry if I sounded harsh.

 

[Pluvia's other account]

People are entitled to their own opinions but...

They're in!

It doesn't matter if you like it or not. Nothing can change that.