Which is better; Tap Jump or Button Jump

[HotChocolate]

So recently I have been watching a ton more streams on Smash, some with a live controller cam, and I noticed that most all of the people I am watching are using button jump. I, personally, have only ever known and used tap jump, but after doing a bit of research I found that most competitive players use button jump as it does provide a ton of benefits... should I try and make the switch before Ultimate or stick with tap jump???

 

[lucasla]

In my configuration, I change A and B to Jump, Y to Attack and X to Special Move, ZR and ZL to Shield, R and L to Grab, and Tap Jump OFF.

Tap Jump is very annoying to me, sometimes I just wanna direct some attack to the up direction, or I just rotate the analog stick for some reason, and the character ends up jumping, it's just not natural too. I'm used to Jump with the B or A buttons since the times from Super Mario World where B was normal jump and A was the rotatory jump. It's just natural to me that the jump action is too important and I must have full control of when I want to jump, and I feel I can jump in moments I dont pretend with the Tap Jump on.

 

[Deleted member]

Button jump for me, it's hard for me to do uairs without accidentally using my double jump with tap jump

 

[itsjustoskar]

button jump. using the stick is difficult and uncomfortable for me. btw, my controls for jumping are X and Y and A is for attack and B is for special.

 

[HotChocolate]

In my configuration, I change A and B to Jump, Y to Attack and X to Special Move, ZR and ZL to Shield, R and L to Grab, and Tap Jump OFF.

Tap Jump is very annoying to me, sometimes I just wanna direct some attack to the up direction, or I just rotate the analog stick for some reason, and the character ends up jumping, it's just not natural too. I'm used to Jump with the B or A buttons since the times from Super Mario World where B was normal jump and A was the rotatory jump. It's just natural to me that the jump action is too important and I must have full control of when I want to jump, and I feel I can jump in moments I dont pretend with the Tap Jump on.

Button jump for me, it's hard for me to do uairs without accidentally using my double jump with tap jump

button jump. using the stick is difficult and uncomfortable for me. btw, my controls for jumping are X and Y and A is for attack and B is for special.

Thanks for the input, I've made the switch and safe to say after about 4 hours of practicing that its second nature. Thanks!