What If?

[FalconOwnage]

A speculative thread regarding tiers...
...and specific character defining moves

Each "sentence" begins with the prefix "WHAT IF?":

Falco didn't have his infamous dair? (dat ain't Falco)
Captain Falcon didn't have his knee? (he still has 2 knees tho)
Sheik didn't have her dthrow?
Fox didn't have his upsmash?
The Ice Climbers didn't have any chain grabs?
Peach couldn't float?
Jigglypuff didn't have rest?
Marth's tipper mechanic was removed?

fellow comrades:
where would said characters place on the tier list if said moves/mechanics were removed?

...if this becomes a popular concept, more "editions & additions" will be added to the OP.

 

[iamgenderqueer]

Captain Falcon didn't have his knee?

 

[Knife Myths]

...if this becomes a popular concept, more "editions & additions" will be added to the OP.

There's nothing I enjoy more than a halfassed OP that ends with "If this thread becomes popular I will make it good scout's honor."

 

[Gameboi834]

There's nothing I enjoy more than a halfassed OP that ends with "If this thread becomes popular I will make it good scout's honor."

It's paid DLC. Each addition is five bucks per user.

 

[Luigi#1]

"Jigglypuff didn't have rest?"

7253185378th tier confirmed.

 

[FalconOwnage]

There's nothing I enjoy more

 

[Spoa]

Captain Falcon didn't have his knee

He'd elbow people

Spoiler

Or, y'know

Spoiler

Use the other knee

 

[Bauske]

What if... Bowser is top tier? (Because he's lookin' mighty fine right now.)