Unbias Character Review

[GreatClayMonkey]

Hey, if you guys tell me who you want in Brawl and Ill review them.
Yeah you might of seen threads like this but most of them are bias so i'm going to put my opinions aside and try to be honest and listen to you guys.
Ok so the system Ill use is a 1-5 system
5-very very likely
4-pretty likely
3-50% chance
2-not likely
1-almost impossible
0-was not in a Nintendo game ever or was in a game based on a movie/TV show
I don't review 0s
So thats it.

Update: Due to certain events like the announcement of sonic and e for all I have made some changes

Now ill do a review to start it Captain Falcon
Ok, I see no reason for him to not be in the game. He was never a clone and part of the original 12. Ive stressed my thoughts and actually cannot see a reason for him to be in the game unless sakuri just doesn't want him which i cant see him doing. 5/5

Already reviewed
C.Falcon 5/5
Megaman 3.6/5 CHANGED DUE TO 3RD PARTY RACE AND BEING MOST LIKELY
Miles "Tails" power 2/5
Falco lombardi 4/5
Llyod Irving 2/5 CHANGED DUE TO AMOUNT OF 3RD PARTY CHARACTERS COMPETING
Ray 01 3.8/5
Rayman 2.8/5 Updated due to 3rd party race
Shy Guy 1/5
Black Knight 2.5/5 CHANGED DUE TO IKE BEING HEAVY AT E FOR ALL
Geno 3.5/5
Luciaro 3.9/5
Mii 2.8/5
Sonic Confirmed
Boo 1.5/5
Ridley 4.5/5 that hes in the game 4/5 that hes playable
Dark Samus 3.5/5
Alexandra Roivas 2.5/5
Final Fantasy Characters 0-0.5/5
Comic Book originals 0/5
Kumatora 2/5
Darkrai 2.3/5
Sylux 2.5/5
Jr. Troopa 2.7/5
Dixie Kong 2.8/5
Captain Olimar 4/5
Banjo Kazooie 2/5
Magikarp 2/5
Chuck Noris 5/5 but seriously -20/5
Ashley 2.7/5
Master Chief 1/5
Isaac 3.6/5
Dr. Kawashima 2.8/5 for PC 3.9/5 for AT
Crono 2.7/5
Sora 2.8/5
Tony Jones 2/5
Spyro 2.5/5
Updated Rayman 3.3/5
Pacman 3.5/5
Claus 3.8/5
Marina 2.4/5
Balloon Fighter 3.5/5 That maybe a little high
Krystal 4/5
Ness 2.8/5
Reviews can be found through-out the thread. From Geno on they have titles.

 

[Bendu]

The fact that you misspelled character AND biased in one topic title means this thread is full to the brim of ironic win.

 

[GreatClayMonkey]

The fact that you misspelled character AND biased in one topic title means this thread is full to the brim of ironic win.

Ok ill get rid of this thread if other people want me to

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

Technically no one can be truly UNbias...

Besides, what are you basing the % on when whether a character gets in is based partially on Sakurai's own bais

 

[GreatClayMonkey]

Technically no one can be truly UNbias...

Besides, what are you basing the % on when whether a character gets in is based partially on Sakurai's own bais

I agree with you but im talking about how when people decide that charecters are going to get because they like them but i might close this because there are alot of threads like this

 

[Enigma14]

Let's see...

Try Megaman.

 

[GreatClayMonkey]

Let's see...

Try Megaman.

Ok Thanks for actually feedback

MegaMan, He was born on the nes and his games carried to the snes. 1-7 were nintendo games but 8 was on the ps1. The early X games were on the snes but moved to sony. Since then megaman Nt Warrior came out for the gamecube and gba. Then starforce recently came out for the DS. He was on Sakuri's poll and has a fairly large fanbase. His problem is hes 3rd party but Sakuri said there would be more 3rd party charecters and he has a large amount of moves to chose from. If you have anything to add or correct tell me 3.5/5

 

[Enigma14]

Ok Thanks for actually feedback

MegaMan, He was born on the nes and his games carried to the snes. 1-7 were nintendo games but 8 was on the ps1. The early X games were on the snes but moved to sony. Since then megaman Nt Warrior came out for the gamecube and gba. Then starforce recently came out for the DS. He was on Sakuri's poll and has a fairly large fanbase. His problem is hes 3rd party but Sakuri said there would be more 3rd party charecters and he has a large amount of moves to chose from. If you have anything to add or correct tell me 3.5/5

fair enough.

Could I suggest another character? Tails.

 

[GreatClayMonkey]

fair enough.

Could I suggest another character? Tails.

Tails, Well we all know that sonic is sega and since sega stopped making sytems hes been out on many systems and where theres sonic tails follows. My problem with tails is that I think we will be lucky if sonic makes it. Dont get me wrong i actually want sonic but if sonic makes it I think tails is more likley to be an assist trophy. I think sonic has a good chance to make but tails im not so sure. 2/5 If anyone sees any mistakes or wants to add anything let me know.

 

[Kooichi]

Try Falco! ;D

 

[Enigma14]

I don't likr Tails or Miles whatever you call the double tailed foxed, I just wanted to see your say on a supporting character who could be similair to Sonic.

 

[GreatClayMonkey]

Try Falco! ;D

Falco You got it. O.K. Falco is the smart mouthed bird of the star fox team and is 100% Nintendo. He was in melee but as a clone. I think most clones will get the boot but I think he and ganandorf have a chance. Fox's moves were made up for smash bros so falcos could to. He has a vital role in the series and many people want him to return. I say theres a good chance sakuri will give him a new move set and send him back. 4/5. If you see any mistakes or have something to add let me know

 

[Neo-X]

You think you could give Lloyd Irving a shot?

 

[Enigma14]

Ganon was only a clone due to time constraints. We can't be sure of the same on Falco, unless he was supposed to have his own moves.

 

[GreatClayMonkey]

You think you could give Lloyd Irving a shot?

sure
Lloyd Irving, He was a main character from Tales Of Symphonia. He starts out the game a foolish boy but slowly becomes a proud man. He is an intresting charedter and was on a Gamecube tittle but is 3rd party(namco). Also he uses a sword which there needs to be less of. Dang this is making me sad. But he also is an intresting charecter and can perform regular magic and speacial magic called hi-ougis . 2.5/5 sorry. Once again if anyone has anything to contribute let me know.

 

[Enigma14]

sure
Lloyd Irving, He was a main character from Tales Of Symphonia. He starts out the game a foolish boy but slowly becomes a proud man. He is an intresting charedter and was on a Gamecube tittle but is 3rd party(namco). Also he uses a sword which there needs to be less of. Dang this is making me sad. But he also is an intresting charecter. 2.5/5 sorry. Once again if anyone has anything to contribute let me know.

Can;t he do magic?

 

[PIT_IS_BACK]

lol wow eh why not

Ray 01

 

[GreatClayMonkey]

Can;t he do magic?

wow i cant belive i forgot that Ill update thanks

 

[killbeast301]

Interesting thread. How about Rayman?

 

[GreatClayMonkey]

lol wow eh why not

Ray 01

Ray 01, He is a main charecter in custom robo and is pretty popular in japan and america. He oviusly is a robot with quite a few abilities and is nintendo. He has a fairly large fanbase and would be a good addition. 3.8/5 Let me now if changes need to be made

 

[GreatClayMonkey]

Interesting thread. How about Rayman?

Rayman, Hes a limbless man with punching power who only appeared many times and recently on the wii for nintendo.Moves are no problem for him as he has many powers. He is somewhat popular but not as much as some other 3rd party candidates such as megaman, geno, pacman or sonic. Raving rabbids helps his chances as it was popular but im not sure. sorry rayman 2.8/5. Got something to add tell me

 

[killbeast301]

Rayman was also on the 64 (Rayman2), gamecube(Rayman3), and DS(portable version of Raving Rabids). The Advance game was actually based off the gamecube game. Rayman 2, the Great Escape is actually considered by many to be the greatest of the Rayman games. I'm not sure about Rayman 1 though. It may have been oon a nintendo system, but not sure.

 

[GreatClayMonkey]

Rayman was also on the 64 (Rayman2), gamecube(Rayman3), and DS(portable version of Raving Rabids). The Advance game was actually based off the gamecube game. Rayman 2, the Great Escape is actually considered by many to be the greatest of the Rayman games. I'm not sure about Rayman 1 though. It may have been oon a nintendo system, but not sure.

Sorry my bad you are 100% right

 

[killbeast301]

Rayman is still not a whole lot popular. He's a bit of a cult favorite

 

[GreatClayMonkey]

Rayman is still not a whole lot popular. He's a bit of a cult favorite

I know thats why his chance is low

 

[smashbot226]

Hmm... I want your opinion on two.

Shy Guy and Black Knight from Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance.

 

[Zoinkslls]

Maybe, oh say... Geno?

 

[Cinder]

Well, since no one has asked yet...Lucario?

 

[Ensee]

The topic creator obviously fails for not being able to spell two simple words. Plus there are already 53453 threads like this, they get pretty annoying.

 

[MFZ95]

ok how about....


Mii
Sonic the Hedgehog?

 

[Enigma14]

The topic creator obviously fails for not being able to spell two simple words. Plus there are already 53453 threads like this, they get pretty annoying.

And people are still asking, so stop spamming.

List:
Shy Guy
Black Knight
Geno
Luciaro
Mii
Sonic

 

[Mysteryfox1]

boo stands on my list

 

[Aphotik]

For a metroid rep, it's either Dark Samus or Ridley. Use your powers to tell me which one has a better chance.

 

[WarMachine]

Just a suggestion, but could you put your ratings in the original post?

Like where it says characters I've already rated - captain falcon, etc etc do captain falcon - 5 (or w/e score you put)

Makes it easier for a quick overview. XD

Oh, and Alexandra Roivas.

Edit- And I don't know if you can change thread titles, but you may want to fix the spelling. ><

 

[GreatClayMonkey]

Hmm... I want your opinion on two.

Shy Guy and Black Knight from Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance.

ok first shy guy, mario already has a lot of representation already plus theres the rummor of bowser Jr. Since hammer bro is an AT and shy guy is in the mario circuit stage. Seeing how hes a generic enimie I think hes more likley just to be on mario circuit. 1/5 sorry shy guy thats just the way it is. Let me know if you have anything to add.

 

[GreatClayMonkey]

Now Black Knight, Hes a villian from two fire emblem games. Brawl needs more villians but they should not be added just because there villians. He weres sacred armor that cannot be pierced by normal weapons. He becomes Ike's arch enemy. He has the sword alandite and has warp powers. He seems like he has good chances with quite a few fans. 3.5/5 maybe thats harsh aw well. let me know if you see mistakes.

 

[GreatClayMonkey]

Geno

Geno, he is a puppet possesed by a star spirt in mario rpg. He is 3rd party which lends him to some problems. He is owned by square enix and has only appeared in mario and luigi superstar saga but only as a cameo. Nintendo is rebuilding a relationship with square enix which lowers his chance. On the other hand he would have a unique move set since he had alot of move in mario rpg. He also has a Huge fanbase maybe second only to sonic. 3.5/5 sorry Geno. Let me know if you have anything to add.

 

[GreatClayMonkey]

Luciaro

Luciaro, Hes a pokemon. Now we already have pikachu and PokemonTrainer (I Hate Him).
The reason I hate him is now thats a pokemon slot filled the question is can he also be in. Maybe. Being a pokemon he has a huge move set to chose from. He has a lot of fans and really hes competing for the pokemon slot. 3.9/5 Forget Mewtwo. Tell me if you want me to add something.

 

[King Of Lusers]

black mage, or any final fantasy character

 

[GreatClayMonkey]

Mii

Mii, Aw the digital avatar. This would make you part of the battle. A few people like this idea and alot like the idea of custom characters. What about moves. Well I guess wii sports or well i cant think of alot of other places. I can see the mii as a AT but PC eh its sketchy. 2.8/5
Theres still a chance. Let me know if theres something to add.