this time sheik should be...

[icymist]

...a seperate character.
Her b down could be like a deku nut or a smoke bomb or somthing.
I think she would be more popular if they made her a seperate character.
What do you think???

 

[Jackal478]

her up b involved her Deku Nuts.

uh....FAIL

she does deserve to return, but SEVERELY NERFED

 

[Diddy Kong]

This time Sheik sould be...

Removed.

 

[Kirby knight]

If Sheik does return as Zelda's vB they need to make her so that she doesn't entirely overshadow her.

-Knight

 

[ZenJestr]

Zelda's Down B

like Kirby knight said...as long as Sheik and Zelda are for the most part balanced...everything is fine...besides Sheik as a separate character is like making Zamus a separate character...

 

[RBinator]

This idea has only ever been suggested countless, countless times now. Was there really a need for another topic just to talk about it? There isn't some official Zelda or Sheik topic somewhere to discuss it?

 

[icymist]

now that I think about it, sheik wasn't in TP...
They probably will replace her w/ minda or something. (if sheik is to become a seperate character)

idk....

oh and to reply to jackal478
I knew that...
but the deku nuts you get can stun enemies. I was thinking it could be like mewto's down b paralize move.
oh and she shouldn't be nerfed! (if she's still zelda/sheik). A sperate character maybe a little...

 

[thejbr12]

oh and she shouldn't be nerfed! (if she's still zelda/sheik). A sperate character maybe a little...

How can you say that? Shiek was SO much better than Zelda that it became pointless to play as Zelda... A transformation character needs to be balanced so that both have advantages and disadvantages that make them relatively equal...

 

[xianfeng]

She should either be a severly nerfed seperate character or nothing at all.

 

[ZenJestr]

not severly...just nerfed in some areas...and improve Zelda in some of her weaknesses...

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

The most Shiek should be nerfed is her knock back thing should be reduced...Her killing shots...whatever they are called...

Everything else is fine...that way a switch so that Zelda truly can finish them off...and must...is necessary. Hopefully they increased Zelda's strength to make for that too

 

[ZenJestr]

yea they should make it

Sheik = fast, weak
Zelda = slow, strong

 

[dynamic_entry]

yea they should make it

Sheik = fast, weak
Zelda = slow, strong

this would solve many problems. sheik was a cool character. the negative stigma just arises from the completely overpowered aerials that she has.

besides, if sheik doesn't make it, who will be brawl's representative NINJARZ???!?!?!

 

[Mic_128]

Already a topic on this.