This roster is really more of a wish list.

[Big-Cat]

Since everyone is posting their's I might as well put mine up. I put at least one more character for every series that underrepresented in Melee except for Yoshi

1. Mario (Dr. Mario as an alt.))
2. Luigi
3. Bowser
4. Peach (Daisy as an alt.)
5. Geno

6. Yoshi

7. Wario
8. Captain Syrup

9. Zelda/Sheik
10. Link
11. Young Link (based on WW Link)
12. Ganondorf

13. Samus Aran/Zero Suit Samus (Fusion Suit as an alt.)
14. Ridley

15. Donkey Kong
16. Diddy Kong
17. K. Rool

18. Fox
19. Falco
20. Krystal
21. Wolf

22. Lucas (Ness and Ninten as alts. All three get to be in.)
23. Kumatora
24. Duster or Claus

25. Pikachu
26. Jigglypuff
27. Mewtwo
28. Lucario
29. Pokemon Trainer
30. Meowth

31. Olimar

32. Kirby
33. King Dedede
34. Meta Knight

35. Captain Falcon
36. Pico
37. Jody Summers

38. Ice Climbers
39. Mr. Game and Watch
40. Pit
41. Andy
42. Little Mac
43. Stafy
44. Isaac
45. Lip
46. Tom Nook
47. Ray 01
48. Sukapon
49. Takamaru

50. Marth
51. Micaiah
52. Ike

53. Solid Snake
54. Sonic the Hedgehog
55. Megaman
56. Haruhi Suzumiya

 

[Mari0sPooPoo]

It's a pretty solid list, but 56 characters is a bit of a stretch. :D

 

[MysticKenji]

56. Haruhi Suzumiya

Who?

10char.

 

[Artc]

This falls under the category of "rosters that could never happen."
At least you have all your bases covered.

 

[:034:]

Captain Syrup? *laughs* I like you.

But yeah, 56 is a bit much. Try making it a nice fifty to go.

 

[Big-Cat]

Captain Syrup? *laughs* I like you.

But yeah, 56 is a bit much. Try making it a nice fifty to go.

That's what it was originally. Before I posted this, it was 52. I'm thinking the roster could be anywhere from 50-55.

BTW, Haruhi is a joke in the roster but it would be awesome.

 

[silver777]

Who?

10char.

i second that.

 

[Big-Cat]

HOW DARE YOU TWO NOT KNOW OF THE MIGHTY GODDESS HARUHI!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haruhi_Suzumiya

 

[:034:]

That's what it was originally. Before I posted this, it was 52. I'm thinking the roster could be anywhere from 50-55.

BTW, Haruhi is a joke in the roster but it would be awesome.

I'm expecting around 40-45, but who can say for sure?

And Haruhi..? No, thanks.

 

[silver777]

HOW DARE YOU TWO NOT KNOW OF THE MIGHTY GODDESS HARUHI!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haruhi_Suzumiya

nope.

never heard of her.

i thought it was a video game character...

 

[Big-Cat]

I'm expecting around 40-45, but who can say for sure?

And Haruhi..? No, thanks.

You must be a Yukiist.

 

[Drascin]

Who?

10char.

It's a joke, man, don't think abut it too much. She would be awesome, nonetheless (Final Smash: Summon Shinjin! ).

Anyway, as for the roster... Wayy too many chars, I'm afraid. Anything above 42-45 is probably stretching it far too much, IMO. Take away some of the most minor ones (Syrup for example) and you'd get much closer to an actual possible roster

 

[Big-Cat]

Got any suggestions?

 

[SilverFang]

Nice list but I'd remove Captain Syrup, Kumatora or Lucas (since he might replace Ness), Jody Summers, Andy, Little Mac, and Haruhi Suzumiya (yeah I know it's a joke, but still) and it would be a good 50 character roster imo.

 

[Caael]

No Simon or Isaac D:

 

[Big-Cat]

I'm leaving Kumatora in this plain and simple. Why should I take out Jody, Capt. Syrup, Andy, and LITTLE MAC?

 

[Xaron Fisk]

No stanley the bugman? Who's gonna fumigate DK's anus now?!

FAIL!!

jk since it's a wish list i won't quibble on the # of chars

 

[SilverFang]

I'm leaving Kumatora in this plain and simple. Why should I take out Jody, Capt. Syrup, Andy, and LITTLE MAC?

You can leave it like this if you want I was just saying. Anyway I just don't think those characters could make it. They aren't requested much (although I see Little Mac being suggested quite often so he can be an exception) and I think that Black Shadow has more chances than Jody.

 

[LukeFonFabre]

Yeah, much more of a wishlist, but still a pretty good one IMO. Probably pushing the roster limit a tad though.

No Simon or Isaac D:

Simon's not there, but Isaac definitely is.

 

[Darthkirby707]

Who the fudge is Captain Syrup?

 

[MysticKenji]

I'm leaving Kumatora in this plain and simple. Why should I take out Jody, Capt. Syrup, Andy, and LITTLE MAC?

I don't know about the other three, but Jody could be replaced with Black Shadow or Pico

 

[Drascin]

Who the fudge is Captain Syrup?

Wario series's bad guy, I think.

 

[Big-Cat]

Wario series's bad guy, I think.

Yep, and she's one of the few girl villains in the Nintendo universe.

 

[Caael]

Yeah, much more of a wishlist, but still a pretty good one IMO. Probably pushing the roster limit a tad though.



Simon's not there, but Isaac definitely is.

...shut up.