Signature Battle

[Conker315]

Alright, so I got challenged from this guy, so we decided to do a battle.
Here are our entry's, the deadline was yesterday and the Theme was haruhi.


Zero's sig:

Conkers sig:

It's open voting and voting ends on Friday.
Please give a good explanation why you voted for the signature you choose, and dont just say "Oh, I like it because of the colors or because I like that character."
Please give specific details on why you picked that signature.

Ok then go.



P.S. I hate my text =]


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


EDIT: Apperantly Zero has given up, and he doesn't want the voting to continue on.
Thanks for your votes people.
BW's made me laugh.

 

[The Dinkoman]

Oh GOD! Not one of these again...

I vote for Conkerrrrrrrr.

His sig is elaborate and his background is phenomenal. There's flow. good lighting. "good" i guess you could say text. And in Zero's, there's to bright lighting to much smudging. And the curved lines on the Left side of the sig take away from the focal point.

Conkerrrrrrs: 9/10

Zero's: 6/10

Spoiler

Why can't anyone just use the critique topic about this? Its easy you just put the sig down, ask people to rate it, put the other sig down, ask people to rate it then you PM the person the results. So I find these threads completely useless...

 

[Scinn]

lol i vote you all off the island conker wins in my book

 

[Black Waltz]

LOLOOLOLOL, first guy's sig sucks monkey balls: ****ty render quality, ****ty colors, ****ty text, meh lighting.

conker's: meh colors, bad text, decent effects, oversharpened, lack of depth.

None are great, but conker's definitely beats the **** out of the first one.

 

[PrepareYourself]

LOLOOLOLOL, first guy's sig sucks monkey balls: ****ty render quality, ****ty colors, ****ty text, meh lighting.

conker's: meh colors, bad text, decent effects, oversharpened, lack of depth.

None are great, but conker's definitely beats the **** out of the first one.

Ditto.

Conker wins!

 

[Allyssa]

.... Conker's is better because, in my opinion, he put more oomph into his sig. Even though these are not very adequate, I still think he has the upper hand here.

 

[Diddyknight]

Conker All the way. His background is more impressive instead of the boring background. Conker also used C4D so that helped while Neok...looks like all he did was brush/Smudge/Flare/Soft light....

Conker has a direct light source. Neo has light all over...

Imo anyway...flame me xDDD

 

[doom dragon 105]

I actually really liked Conker's imo the best he's pulled out

Was this even competition?

Conker's had a nice flow and the effects were nice. The lighting was cool too though the effects on the right were o_O

 

[Conker315]

UPDATED!!

Please close this thread mods :3

 

[Thunder Of Zeus]

I like zero's better. its barely above tho both are great

 

[Tektite]

Edit: Sorry I don't read the whole thread when I post.

 

[Honir]

Conker gmv.

He has most of the basics of GFX in the image.

The first one has flow, Loose focal and too much lighting.

 

[Conker315]

Omg, lol.
Read the first post guys, i've updated it.
This battle is over.I won and he lost.