Mario Galaxy is 100% overrated!

[Masky64]

Super Mario Galaxy was a fun game, but when I found out it was rated best game of all time, I wasn't very happy. First of all, have you even played Orcarina of Time? The amazing gameplay and the great music and graphics made it an enjoyable gaming experience. All the game sites gave it a 10/10, 5/5, and/or 100%! While Galaxy only got a 9.7. I can see Galaxy being Game of the Year, but not the best game ever. Sorry.

 

[Blackadder]

It was rated Best game Of All time? Show me the link here, buddy boy.
I'm actually going to agree with you here.
The game is brilliant. It's so fun it should be banned in china. But it's not the best game ever...

I'd say it was voted this because it's currently "Flavour of the month" if you get me. Like Lord Of The Rings. When the movies came out, suddenly everyone's favorite book was LOR, even if they'd never read it.

I still say the best game ever is Kirby's Dream Land!
...

 

[Mad555]

At first I was about to get angry with this topic but when I heard you say that some websites call it the best game of all time it made me disagree also.
Its a great game but I dont think its anyway better than OOT except graphics wise. It would make sense if it got game of the year but best game ever, NO
A link would be nice though.

 

[Masky64]

Just Google "Mario Galaxy overrated" or something like that.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VJwzkKC_MOk

This guy is overreacting over this game.

 

[Y34HDUD3!!!]

The phrase that leaps to mind is: I don't care if you feel it's overrated.

Kthxbai

 

[Pink Reaper]

I still say the best game ever is Kirby's Dream Land!

Correction, Kirby Super Star is the best game ever.

Also, OoT is overrated. It lacked a story that would actually make me care about any of the characters in the game.

 

[Osco316]

Did you know we have a Galaxy topic already? Yeah, there's this thing called the search button.