Is he even cel shaded?

[cyber_turnip]

Certainly doesn't look like it.

 

[zyphon]

To tell you the truth, I thought the same thing when after the end of this video where they zoomed in on him.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FeeIYr5wW78

I suppose he was modeled in a way so that he looks cel-shaded from far away.

 

[Burning Lava]

Yeah, maybe he isn't cel shaded (and he isn't) because Sakurai wanted you to be able to see more detail at a distance, since most of the time while fighting, characters are kind of far away from the camera so to speak. I don't know, that's a crappy excuse. Has anyone thought that maybe one of his costumes is cel shaded? Perhaps those have been shown already and I just don't know about it.

 

[Regiwi]

Don't they need a special game engine to do cell shading? If so that would really be a bit much for one character. I think he looks awesome, and fits in perfectly, he looks cartoony but with that dark tinge that most the characters now have. If he was cell shaded he would look kinda silly to be honest.

 

[Kabyk-Greenmyst]

No, Poke Floats is cel-shaded. However, Toon Link is not cel-shaded. Why? Who knows, but looking at the roster, we can see characters were not a top priority for Sakurai.

No offense, but giving Toon Link, the "human" graphics over the cel-shading, makes his face just unnaturally weird. I mean, the cel-shading was what WW Link had that made him amazing looking, even though he has a weird shaped face and head. Turning that into "normal" graphics makes him just an awkward faced kid going through puberty.

 

[Aurion]

I don't reply much on things but actually he is cel-shaded but in another way we are used to it this type of cel-shading is pretty popular in allot of game's and i think Sakurai went this way to make him fit in a little bit more although. I can't be 100% certain of this yet. anyway i would have liked normal cel-shading style like WW but it would look a bit goofy in Brawl so I'm pretty pleased with him how he is now

 

[Burning Lava]

Don't they need a special game engine to do cell shading? If so that would really be a bit much for one character. I think he looks awesome, and fits in perfectly, he looks cartoony but with that dark tinge that most the characters now have. If he was cell shaded he would look kinda silly to be honest.

How can people say this? It's a video game for crying out loud. What, he doesn't look silly without cel-shading, but then with it, he would? That's how his character was designed. It was always supposed to be like a cartoon. That's why the art is drawn like a 2D cartoon, and they attempted to keep that style with cel-shading. How is that more silly than G&W being flat? Is that silly? Well, probably, but if you don't like silly, you probably should be warned... Smash Brothers is chock-full.

Well, don't mean to jump all over you, but I just can't see how people don't want diversity. Part of the fun for me is seeing totally different characters interacting with each other. That's what crossovers are there for IMO. (Why does TOON link have realistic textures and the same hair texture as TP Link, if he's supposed to be a... you know, TOON?? Why even call him TOON at all?)

I don't reply much on things but actually he is cel-shaded but in another way we are used to it this type of cel-shading is pretty popular in allot of game's and i think Sakurai went this way to make him fit in a little bit more although. I can't be 100% certain of this yet. anyway i would have liked normal cel-shading style like WW but it would look a bit goofy in Brawl so I'm pretty pleased with him how he is now

There again! Why? Why would it look goofy?? I can't understand it. Because it's different? Different=goofy? I think it would be highly interesting, not to mention aesthetically pleasing. Perhaps a round ball named Kirby is too goofy to be in the same game as Snake... I don't know, I'm baffled by how many people are thinking this way.

I agree with Kabyk-Greenmyst... thanks for your reason.

 

[Regiwi]

How can people say this? It's a video game for crying out loud. What, he doesn't look silly without cel-shading, but then with it, he would? That's how his character was designed. It was always supposed to be like a cartoon. That's why the art is drawn like a 2D cartoon, and they attempted to keep that style with cel-shading. How is that more silly than G&W being flat? Is that silly? Well, probably, but if you don't like silly, you probably should be warned... Smash Brothers is chock-full.

Well, don't mean to jump all over you, but I just can't see how people don't want diversity. Part of the fun for me is seeing totally different characters interacting with each other. That's what crossovers are there for IMO. (Why does TOON link have realistic textures and the same hair texture as TP Link, if he's supposed to be a... you know, TOON?? Why even call him TOON at all?)



There again! Why? Why would it look goofy?? I can't understand it. Because it's different? Different=goofy? I think it would be highly interesting, not to mention aesthetically pleasing. Perhaps a round ball named Kirby is too goofy to be in the same game as Snake... I don't know, I'm baffled by how many people are thinking this way.

I agree with Kabyk-Greenmyst... thanks for your reason.

Yeah, because there are so many bright colourful characters in the game aren't there? They don't look dark or mature at all do they? Yeah, a cell shaded bright happy Link would fit in there tons better than a slightly darker more realistic but still perfectly recognisable Toon Link won't he? God, be thankful he's in at all, he looks awesome, his stage looks awesome, his weapons look straight from the game. Seriously just stop *****ing...

 

[Bottles98]

I think he looks fine without it. He's still styled toonishly after all.

 

[Norm]

he\'s not some of the effects are but he\'s not.

 

[Skillface]

He's got the same character model, with the swoopy hair and whatnot, and it still looks a bit cel shaded-esque, but he's not. I really like the way they did it.

 

[Pluvia's other account]

I really like the way he is, you can hardly notice he's not Cel-Shaded.

 

[Bassoonist]

Yeah it's really weird, from the usual view it really looks like he's cel shaded, but up close he looks just like any other character except for with the cartoon look.

I guess that was Sakurai's way of fitting him into the game.

 

[Darkpaladin of Chaos]

I think he would have looked bad with cel-shading in this game. He needed the texture.

 

[Thunderslf]

I actually like him better textured.

 

[B.W.]

I don't think he's cell shaded no, but he still does look pretty cartoony.

I actually think he looks a lot like a well animated clay model myself, and I don't mind the look at all. As for where it'd be better fitting if he were cell shaded or not, I don't think it would make much of a difference since this game has your more realistic characters, as well as cartoony and anime-ish characters.

 

[Parassita]

He looks a lot more polished, I like the sort of darker look for Brawl. It's nice.

 

[courte]

no because samirai panda along with common knowledge for some and a bit of snooping tells us
cel shaded characters equal cel shaded game

what i want to know it why those few "hardcore zelda fans" really didn't play wind waker and still refuse too...

i've heard some say because it's cel shaded, which is cack and bull, and others say because he's a kid, which is actually series accurate so what really gives

 

[Sockpuppet]

Here's a picture

 

[B.W.]

no because samirai panda along with common knowledge for some and a bit of snooping tells us
cel shaded characters equal cel shaded game

what i want to know it why those few "hardcore zelda fans" really didn't play wind waker and still refuse too...

i've heard some say because it's cel shaded, which is cack and bull, and others say because he's a kid, which is actually series accurate so what really gives

You raise a good point, but that's going a bit off topic, doncha think? We're not talking about hardcore Zelda fans who refuse to play Wind Waker (I don't know why it's a great game), just about whether Toon Link is cel shaded in Brawl or not.

 

[abgar]

then you think ness and the other ness-guy should be 2D sprites, because thats their original style?

 

[Reno-Vgas]

hes got the exact same clothes textures as Link from what I've seen.

 

[UncleGrandfather]

If he was cel shaded then he would look more out of place. They probably made him textured just because it would have taken a lot more work to make him cel shaded anyway and this way he doesn't look out of place with the rest of the characters.

Doesn't everyone agree that he would look to weird if he were cel shaded?

And again, I've heard that it takes an entirely different game engine to do cel shading, maybe they could've tried to simulate it.

 

[AsILayDying]

i dont know, but i really prefer the toon link non shaded look XD it looks plain awesome

 

[Paranoid_Android]

They probably did it to save processing power or some such, not because of any preference. Everyone knows he was cell-shaded to start with in Wind Waker and that's how he would appear in SSBB in a perfect world.

 

[ylink_underestimted]

I think it'd be cooler if he was cel-shaded. It just makes it more like his character. Ike I think looks better in texture though.
For his costumes though, instead of a Dark Toon Link (which I think looks weird, and somewhat supports the idea that he was meant to be a clone ) a black and gray/white costume would've been better. Also, why no Island Costume?