How Important Are Octagonal Gates?

[Caliburn89]

Hey all,
In my quest to improve my Smash game, I’m probably overthinking my choice of controller. I’ve been playing almost exclusively with the pro controller, and while I love the overall ergonomics and feel of the pro, I keep wondering about switching back to the GC Controller because of the gates around the sticks. How important are these really? Or do I just need to focus on cleaning up my stick inputs on a controller I otherwise love? Thoughts and comments appreciated.

 

[Orlando BCN]

I never liked them personally, but I think they’re better for more accurate inputs. If precision is your thing, then stick with the Pro Controller.

 

[Xelrog]

I've never consciously noticed the octagon when playing on a GCN controller.

 

[Alsyght]

Don’t particularly like it. The controller registers a diagonal flick as straight up or down while the left and right is just that. Don’t understand why they do that, but sure. I like the feel of the that Switch GC controller, but i could go for a circle over an octagon.

 

[Gryphon827]

Unless you're playing Ryu (which you clearly don't), then you might want it for more consistent input commands, but it isn't necessary for any other character. Sure, you might misinput a little less, but it won't change enough about your play for it to be worth the money. Just stick with the Procon.

 

[JiggyNinja]

I have certainly noticed a difference. I played Melee and Brawl with a GC controller and I'm now playing Ultimate with a Pro controller. Without the octagonal gates I've found myself occasionally doing an up/down tilt or special in the wrong direction because when I did the directional input it was slightly tilted to the side instead of straight down, which never happened with a GC controller. In a few cases I've accidentally input an up special instead of the side special I intended, a pretty horrible mistake to make when you're playing K. Rool.

I like the Pro controller a lot. If it had octagonal gates it would be perfect for Smash. You can stick with the Pro controller, you just need to practice better input discipline so you don't mis-input.

 

[Xelrog]

I paid attention while I was playing today and found out that I actually use the straight diagonals a lot when using up airs and up specials. I think it's beneficial.