Gametrailers Brawl Review...

[IGN Forums]

First of all i wanted to know have any game ever got a perfect overall score of 10.0!! The only games i know ever got close was:

- Halo 3: Overall- 9.8
- Super Mario Galaxy: Overall- 9.8

Those are the only games close to a 10.0!! Brawl has the material to recieve a perfect 10 score!! There are too much opinions saying that brawl is awfull! That's different opinions, and opinions don't count when it comes to reviews! It's based on how good the Story, Design, Gameplay, Presentation... Let's wait to see but Brawl COULD get a perfect score! I love watching GT Reviews!! Do you think it will recieve a perfect overall score: 10.0 or even a 9.9??!!

 

[limitbreak]

I would hope so.

 

[p00pd0g]

Gametrailers isn't exactly the highest regarded reviewing site....

 

[Banjodorf]

Gametrailers isn't exactly the highest regarded reviewing site....

Although Famitsu IS. Well, not a site, a magazine, but it only gives one game per system a perfect score and what got the perfect score for the Wii? Not Galaxy, Brawl!!Thats all I need.

 

[TerminalMontage]

Woot.

Game is going to be great, but not to those who hyped themselves up over people like Ridley and Geno

 

[Rhubarbo]

No, Brawl will inevitably score low. Why, because reviewers aren't tournet players and don't notice if DI got reduced or L-Cancelling was removed. Essentially, to them Brawl is Melee with 9 more characters (kind of, it really is just that) and a half-***** story mode. Expect it to score low-mid eights. Famitsu is fan service. They scored Brawl high because their readers love it, and they don't want to alienate them.

 

[jdub03]

I believe legend of zelda got a perfect 10. Anyway a review is still an opinion. Its not fact. Its the collective opinion of the video game reviewer/s.

 

[Banjodorf]

No, Brawl will inevitably score low. Why, because reviewers aren't tournet players and don't notice if DI got reduced or L-Cancelling was removed. Essentially, to them Brawl is Melee with 9 more characters (kind of, it really is just that) and a half-***** story mode. Expect it to score low-mid eights. Famitsu is fan service. They scored Brawl high because their readers love it, and they don't want to alienate them.

You sound very bitter Rhubarbo. I dont hear the story mode is terrible. I hear it's great, but the ending is lacking. Thats all.

But what makes you say "THis is Melee with 9 more characters? Its not. Not even close. This is Brawl. Did Melee have a true story mode, online play, a fantastic stage builder, the ability to change music on stages? No. Amogn many other things. This game is much better than Melee was, and thats saying something..sigh..